The chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan three years ago has been in the news a lot lately, and those offering their thoughts have been busy providing us their woulda, coulda, shoulda commentary about how it all would have gone well if only they had been in charge — and Joe Biden wasn’t.
The problem is 99.9% of those armchair field marshals have never been involved in the evacuation of American embassy personnel and many others in the midst of a civil war.
I have. So, allow me to explain why it never had a chance to be anything but chaos.
It will be chaos
The civil war in Liberia started at Christmas in 1989, shortly after I arrived in the country to serve as deputy head of mission. Initially it appeared to be a minor border incident, but over the next few months it spread throughout the country.
As the government and its army lost control over more and more of the country, the embassy’s warnings to American citizens grew more urgent and ominous. Initially, they were able to leave through the international airport outside of the capitol.
When that became impossible to reach, we started chartering flights from the in-town airport to neighboring countries. As we advised Americans to leave, we also drew down the embassy community, which numbered about 600, including dependents, as we prepared for the worst.
Read More
By mid-1990, rebel forces commanded by two competing warlords had surrounded the capital and the president, in effect, became the mayor of about 20 square blocks of downtown Monrovia. Since there was no other way out, in early August the ambassador agreed to launching Operation Sharp Edge.
Over 200 Marines landed on what had been the basketball court to protect the embassy compound and helicopters touched down long enough to evacuate communications technicians from two outlying sites.
Those helicopters then began to shuttle Americans and others that we agreed to take out to the USS Saipan. That ship, with the assistance of others, transported over 2,400 noncombatants to neighboring Sierra Leone and safety.
The operation went smoothly because we had several crucial advantages that those who had to deal with the situation in Kabul did not. First, we had time. It took months for the situation to go from bad to worse allowing for planning and a variety of options for dealing with it.
Second, when we needed the military, they were there in force and ready to act as there had been a task force of several ships standing by just off the coast since early June.
Third, the numbers were large but manageable. We had thousands to deal with, and not over 100,000. We also did generally not take out Liberians, which created particularly painful decisions in some situations given the tribal nature of the conflict and the families where some but not all members were American citizens.
Fourth, and most important, was the fact that it was a “permissible environment,” which is military jargon for the evacuation force not having to fight its way in and its way out. In Liberia, the president and the two warlords and their respective forces did not try to prevent or interfere with the operation.
No favorable conditions
None of those favorable conditions were present in the situation in Afghanistan, especially the last one. American forces had been actively engaged in combat against the Taliban until President Trump signed a deal with them and set the date for American withdrawal.
The Taliban had not lived up to their side of the bargain. Given that fighting between them and the Afghan armed forces had continued, it was not at all clear how Taliban fighters would conduct themselves in the midst of an American evacuation.
Perhaps worst of all was the uncertainty about how our supposed allies would react to the American departure. Over the years scores of American soldiers and troops from other coalition countries had been killed and wounded in green-on-blue attacks. That was the name for Afghan army and police personnel turning their guns on coalition forces.
What the Afghan army did do was collapse quicker than a $10 tent in a hurricane, allowing the Taliban to take control of Kabul far faster than anyone had anticipated.
So, all the talk about how easy it would have been to have an orderly and well-planned departure is largely nonsense. But why is this all coming up now? Politics.
The slime machine
It is because the third anniversary has fallen in the middle of an election year. That means the great rightwing slime machine must gear up to Benghazi Biden and by extension Vice President Harris.
Back when it was clear that Hillary Clinton was going to run for president, Republicans in Congress conducted four investigations, wasted years and millions of dollars to conclude that she was not responsible for the deaths of the four Americans in Benghazi.
As with the accusations of Biden being corrupt, it does not matter that the charges are unfounded and false. All that is required is to make the accusation and then let Fox News, the Wall Street Journal and Russian Television repeat them ad nauseum before some voters will accept them as fact.
Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, is professor of international affairs at the Pennsylvania State University. His previous article was “Donald Trump and the two medals.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.