It’s September before a November presidential election. No one knows which party will win the presidency or the Congress. That is why this is the perfect time to get rid of the filibuster in the Senate — because no one knows which party will benefit from that change.
The filibuster allows a minority of 41 senators to block a vote on a piece of legislation. In principle, this means that senators representing around 34 million Americans — a little more than 10% of the population — can effectively veto congressional action.
Four reasons
There are numerous exceptions when the filibuster does not apply. Republicans can raise taxes with only 51 votes — a simple majority of the Senate. Democrats can raise spending with a similar simple majority. Both parties can confirm judges by majority vote as well.
But most legislation can be blocked by a filibuster, which means you would need 60 votes in the Senate to pass something—a very difficult standard to meet.
There are four reasons to end the filibuster, which can be done at any time by a simple Senate majority. First, in our polarized era, both parties abuse the filibuster to block ordinary legislation by the other party. It used to be said that the filibuster protected minority interests from big changes in national life, which should require a large majority to enact.
This was a dubious claim to begin with. Historically the filibuster was mostly used against civil rights legislation — but the filibuster is certainly not used that sparingly today.
Read More
Today, the filibuster, or even just the threat of it, is used to thwart the enactment of ordinary legislation. Both parties do this, but right now, the Republicans are blocking an extension of the child tax credit and the enactment of a ban on bump stocks that turn rifles into machine guns.
The opponents of these proposals have their reasons, of course, but the framers of the Constitution did not create a Senate in which you need 60 votes to pass a law. Democracy requires majority rule. The American people are entitled to a government that works.
Second, the U.S. Supreme Court is practically demanding the abolition of the filibuster. When the Court struck down the administrative ban on bump stocks, Justice Samuel Alito wrote a concurrence in which he said Congress could enact such a ban any time — sure, if there were no filibuster.
In a series of cases this term, the Court restricted administrative decision-making in favor of Congressional action. The Court also held that only Congress could ban insurrectionists from running for office. The Justices are insisting that Congress act.
But it’s meaningless to insist on congressional action when the filibuster frustrates exactly that.
No principled case
Third, there is no principled case for the filibuster any more. You can see this because when the filibuster does not apply — when Republicans are cutting taxes or Democrats are increasing spending — no one ever suggests that these things should require 60 votes in the Senate. Nor does anyone propose eliminating any of the current exceptions to the filibuster.
Finally, we need to abolish the filibuster to return responsible government to Washington. The lesson of the Dobbs case overturning Roe v. Wade and eliminating the constitutional right to choose abortion is that our politics improve when our rhetoric has real consequences.
As long as Roe protected the right to abortion, politicians could favor and legislate abortion bans freely because Americans assumed that abortion would be protected and did not pay that much attention. Now, with Roe overturned, voters even in conservative states are reversing such bans. Politicians have been forced to take notice.
Something similar would happen if there were no filibuster. Our two major parties would then have to actually grapple with our national problems. Once in office, they would have to deliver.
We have seen this kind of forced responsibility. In 2017, because the filibuster did not apply, Republicans had to vote on repealing the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare, as they had proposed to do for years. They found out that such a repeal was actually unpopular. Now, they only talk about improving Obamacare.
No one need worry that without the filibuster, the parties will never negotiate and compromise. Most of the time, power in Washington is shared, with one party controlling the presidency and the other party controlling at least one house in Congress.
One party control
But it is true that without the filibuster, if the voters gave control of the government to one party, that party could enact anything that the Constitution permits.
So what? We have a name for that situation. It’s called democracy. And if the voters do not like the results, they will be free to punish that party and elect the other party in the next election cycle.
Sounds like a good system. We should try it.
Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “Trump and Biden are both wrong about democracy.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.
The number of Americans represented by the senators who could in principle veto legislation has been corrected.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.