It’s Sep­tem­ber be­fore a No­vem­ber pres­i­den­tial elec­tion. No one knows which party will win the pres­i­dency or the Con­gress. That is why this is the per­fect time to get rid of the fil­i­bus­ter in the Senate — be­cause no one knows which party will ben­e­fit from that change.

The fil­i­bus­ter al­lows a mi­nor­ity of 41 sen­a­tors to block a vote on a piece of leg­is­la­tion. In prin­ci­ple, this means that sen­a­tors rep­re­sent­ing around 34 mil­lion Amer­i­cans — a lit­tle more than 10% of the pop­u­la­tion — can ef­fec­tively veto con­gres­sio­nal ac­tion.

Four rea­sons

There are nu­mer­ous ex­cep­tions when the fil­i­bus­ter does not ap­ply. Re­pub­li­cans can raise taxes with only 51 votes — a sim­ple ma­jor­ity of the Senate. Dem­o­crats can raise spend­ing with a sim­i­lar sim­ple ma­jor­ity. Both par­ties can con­firm judges by ma­jor­ity vote as well.

But most leg­is­la­tion can be blocked by a fil­i­bus­ter, which means you would need 60 votes in the Senate to pass some­thing—a very dif­fi­cult stan­dard to meet.

Advertise with us

There are four rea­sons to end the fil­i­bus­ter, which can be done at any time by a sim­ple Senate ma­jor­ity. First, in our po­lar­ized era, both par­ties abuse the fil­i­bus­ter to block or­di­nary leg­is­la­tion by the other party. It used to be said that the fil­i­bus­ter pro­tected mi­nor­ity in­ter­ests from big changes in na­tional life, which should re­quire a large ma­jor­ity to en­act.

This was a du­bi­ous claim to be­gin with. His­tor­i­cally the fil­i­bus­ter was mostly used against civil rights leg­is­la­tion — but the fil­i­bus­ter is cer­tainly not used that spar­ingly to­day.

To­day, the fil­i­bus­ter, or even just the threat of it, is used to thwart the en­act­ment of or­di­nary leg­is­la­tion. Both par­ties do this, but right now, the Re­pub­li­cans are block­ing an ex­ten­sion of the child tax credit and the en­act­ment of a ban on bump stocks that turn ri­fles into ma­chine guns.

The op­po­nents of these pro­pos­als have their rea­sons, of course, but the fram­ers of the Con­sti­tu­tion did not cre­ate a Senate in which you need 60 votes to pass a law. De­moc­racy re­quires ma­jor­ity rule. The Amer­i­can peo­ple are en­ti­tled to a gov­ern­ment that works.

Second, the U.S. Supreme Court is prac­ti­cally de­mand­ing the abo­li­tion of the fil­i­bus­ter. When the Court struck down the ad­min­is­tra­tive ban on bump stocks, Justice Samuel Alito wrote a con­cur­rence in which he said Con­gress could en­act such a ban any time — sure, if there were no fil­i­bus­ter.

Advertise with us

In a se­ries of cases this term, the Court re­stricted ad­min­is­tra­tive de­ci­sion-mak­ing in fa­vor of Con­gres­sio­nal ac­tion. The Court also held that only Con­gress could ban in­sur­rec­tion­ists from run­ning for of­fice. The Justices are in­sist­ing that Con­gress act.

But it’s mean­ing­less to in­sist on con­gres­sio­nal ac­tion when the fil­i­bus­ter frus­trates ex­actly that.

No prin­ci­pled case

Third, there is no prin­ci­pled case for the fil­i­bus­ter any more. You can see this be­cause when the fil­i­bus­ter does not ap­ply — when Re­pub­li­cans are cut­ting taxes or Dem­o­crats are in­creas­ing spend­ing — no one ever sug­gests that these things should re­quire 60 votes in the Senate. Nor does any­one pro­pose elim­i­nat­ing any of the cur­rent ex­cep­tions to the fil­i­bus­ter.

Finally, we need to abol­ish the fil­i­bus­ter to re­turn re­spon­si­ble gov­ern­ment to Wash­ing­ton. The les­son of the Dobbs case over­turn­ing Roe v. Wade and elim­i­nat­ing the con­sti­tu­tional right to choose abor­tion is that our pol­i­tics im­prove when our rhet­o­ric has real con­se­quences.

As long as Roe pro­tected the right to abor­tion, pol­i­ti­cians could fa­vor and leg­is­late abor­tion bans freely be­cause Amer­i­cans as­sumed that abor­tion would be pro­tected and did not pay that much at­ten­tion. Now, with Roe over­turned, vot­ers even in con­ser­va­tive states are re­vers­ing such bans. Pol­i­ti­cians have been forced to take no­tice.

Advertise with us

Some­thing sim­i­lar would hap­pen if there were no fil­i­bus­ter. Our two ma­jor par­ties would then have to ac­tu­ally grap­ple with our na­tional prob­lems. Once in of­fice, they would have to de­liver.

We have seen this kind of forced re­spon­si­bil­ity. In 2017, be­cause the fil­i­bus­ter did not ap­ply, Re­pub­li­cans had to vote on re­peal­ing the Af­ford­able Care Act, Obam­ac­are, as they had pro­posed to do for years. They found out that such a re­peal was ac­tu­ally un­pop­u­lar. Now, they only talk about im­prov­ing Obam­ac­are.

No one need worry that with­out the fil­i­bus­ter, the par­ties will never ne­go­ti­ate and com­pro­mise. Most of the time, power in Wash­ing­ton is shared, with one party con­trol­ling the pres­i­dency and the other party con­trol­ling at least one house in Con­gress.

One party con­trol

But it is true that with­out the fil­i­bus­ter, if the vot­ers gave con­trol of the gov­ern­ment to one party, that party could en­act any­thing that the Con­sti­tu­tion per­mits.

So what? We have a name for that sit­u­a­tion. It’s called de­moc­racy. And if the vot­ers do not like the re­sults, they will be free to pun­ish that party and elect the other party in the next elec­tion cy­cle.

Advertise with us

Sounds like a good sys­tem. We should try it.

Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “Trump and Biden are both wrong about democracy.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.

The number of Americans represented by the senators who could in principle veto legislation has been corrected.