As a Senate staffer of an earlier generation who later wrote three books about the Senate, I have plainly spent more time thinking about the Senate than any reasonable person should. But even as public attention focuses on the extraordinarily high stakes race for the presidency, it is important not to overlook the importance of the Senate.

The truth is both that Bob Casey has been a fine senator and that at a different time, David McCormick could also be. But control of the Senate hangs by a thread, and that reality presents Pennsylvania voters with a choice as stark as night and day.

Republican damage

We should have a clear memory of the damage done by the Republican Senate, led by Mitch McConnell, when they had the majority. They waged endless war against the Affordable Care Act, coming close to repealing it and throwing millions of people off the insurance rolls.

After the Sandy Hook massacre, they refused to do anything to limit gun violence, captured by the NRA and the gun manufacturers even when there was a national consensus favoring mandatory background checks and banning assault weapons. They opposed every effort, domestically and internationally, to combat climate change. They cut taxes for the corporations and the wealthiest Americans.

Advertise with us

McConnell stacked the federal courts with young, right-wing judges like Aileen Cannon. And he rammed through the confirmation of three extreme Supreme Court justices — Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett — who joined John Roberts, Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito in an unprecedented assault on constitutional rights, personal freedom and the rule of law.

Disgraced Republicans

And of course, the Senate Republicans disgraced themselves and betrayed the country by acquitting Donald Trump in two impeachment trials, the second coming just weeks after he incited the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol. They knowingly disregarded their responsibility to be the check provided by the Founders to deal with a corrupt president who commits abuses of power that threatens the constitutional order.

In contrast, when the Democrats regained a paper-thin majority in the Senate, the Senate immediately began to function again. Within weeks after Joe Biden took office, the Senate narrowly approved the American Rescue Plan, which gave people the help they needed to get through COVID.

The Senate passed a trillion-dollar infrastructure legislation, the largest investment in infrastructure since the Interstate Highway system in the 1950’s. They enacted the CHIPS and Science Act, a massive investment that will allow us to compete with China in the technologies that will shape future prosperity. They gave authorized Medicare to negotiate drug prices for the first time.

They passed the first meaningful, if modest, gun safety measure in thirty years. They confirmed more than 200 federal judges with a more progressive outlook. And they made the first major investments in bringing about the transformation to a clean energy economy.

Advertise with us

Democratic progress

Governing our diverse, contentious country is never going to be easy, but with the Senate in Democratic hands, progress became possible.

I am confident that Kamala Harris will win the election, carried to victory by an expanded turnout driven by women and younger voters. But she will need a Democratic Senate to help her govern successfully. America cannot afford another period of Senate Republican obstruction like Barack Obama faced.

And if the worst were to happen, and Donald Trump is elected, America will desperately need a Democratic Senate to protect our democracy and our freedoms.

Ira Shapiro, a former Senate staffer, is the author of three books about the Senate, the most recent of which is “The Betrayal: How Mitch McConnell and the Senate Republicans Abandoned America.”