When Oklahoma’s Republican senator Markwayne Mullin challenged the leader of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, Sean O'Brien, to a fight during a televised committee hearing, he defended himself by recalling the bloody 1856 caning of famed abolitionist Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts by aggrieved South Carolina congressman Preston Brooks.
“We looked into the (Senate) rules, and you know, you used to be able to cane,” he said. “There is presence (sic) for it, if that’s what someone wants to do.” Check again, senator.
He wanted to finish it there
Sen. Mullin — a retired MMA fighter — carefully avoided cursing and even took off his wedding ring to avoid eye lacerations or broken teeth. In his former profession, these would be one of the infractions constituting a foul. Someone had apparently convinced the gentleman from Oklahoma a challenge of this kind was somehow safely within Senate rules.
“Sir,” declared Mullins, “this is a time, this is a place. You want to run your mouth, we can be two consenting adults, we can finish it here.” Still, no matter how sincere his motive — or how high the payoff in fundraising and media appearances — he should have checked the impulse.
Yes, the 1856 caning happened on the floor of the United State Senate, but caning was never in the rulebook. Sumner nearly died, and couldn’t return to the Senate for three years.
Read More
While the Constitution provides that members of Congress cannot be arrested while “going to and returning” from legislative session, there is no sanction for caning, fisticuffs, or even duels — no matter the level of offense to self or constituents. Permission, if that’s what was needed, was granted through unwritten rules of manly honor.
Butler’s polluted mistress
Sen. Sumner’s alleged breach was insulting South Carolina senator Andrew Butler, a leading promoter of slavery and a relative of Brooks’, on the Senate floor. Butler had taken a mistress,” Sumner said, “who, though ugly to others, is always lovely to him; though polluted in the sight of the world, is chaste in his sight — I mean the harlot, Slavery."
Honor, Brooks believed, demanded punishment. Three days later, aided by other congressmen, he beat the defenseless Sumner.
Like Mullins’ action, Congressman Brooks’ was undertaken with planning and premeditation. He later described how he waited until no ladies were present and even noted how he selected the “gutta percha and hollow” cane—"light and elastic” because he “fancied it would not break.” Brooks had come to the Senate Chamber to “flog him,” but not kill, he argued.
In the 19th Century, the debate on the caning of Sumner played out on front pages in the North and South — a prelude to the coming war. In 2023, the everyday disregard of formal and informal rules of civil discourse and decorum isn’t news. In 1856, these events were shocking outliers — fodder for debates around the cracker barrel for weeks and months.
Today’s “Senator v. that Teamsters guy” had a lifecycle of maybe 12 hours of TikTok shares and a round or two of cable fundraising appearances. Sadly, there have been other tantalizing episodes, like the bizarre tale of the alleged “Ex-Speaker v. Congressman” elbowing incident, to rival this one.
Veto the entertainers
Every elected official needs to object to the suggestion of a “viral opportunity” and avoid being goaded by public pokes and ear flicks. Campaign and congressional staffers need to stop being the social media whisperer for the boss. What works isn’t always what is right. And yes, voters need to use their veto to trade entertainers and performance artists in favor of more sober-minded, mature candidates.
Let’s hope we’ve learned something in the past 167 about what happens when intemperate leaders are unable to control passions for the good of the order.
Jeff Coleman is a former Pennsylvania state representative and 2023 candidate for the GOP nomination for lieutenant governor. He’s the principal and founder of Churchill Strategies in Harrisburg. Email: jeff@churchillmedia.org. His previous article was “The hospitality of Kfar Aza.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.