Pres­i­dents are faulted for just about ev­ery­thing that hap­pens dur­ing their term. But they are not re­ally re­spon­si­ble for as many things as vot­ers, jour­nal­ists or po­lit­i­cal op­po­nents try to blame them for.

The pub­lic de­mands ac­tion, and can­di­dates prom­ise it, but the pres­i­dency is an im­pos­sible of­fice. It com­bines out­sized ex­pec­ta­tions — which pres­i­dents them­selves have em­braced by cam­paign­ing as the voice of the whole coun­try — with highly con­strained po­lit­i­cal power in a sys­tem dis­tin­guished, cur­rently, by grid­lock.

Nei­ther Biden nor Trump would likely take of­fice in Jan­u­ary with a ma­jor­ity in the House and a fil­i­bus­ter-proof ma­jor­ity in the Senate. And the pub­lic pays lit­tle at­ten­tion to the area where pres­i­dents have the most di­rect au­thor­ity: for­eign af­fairs.

In­stead, at the de­bates, both can­di­dates spoke mostly of their eco­nomic records and made prom­ises about what they would do in a sec­ond term. But the econ­omy is a com­pli­cated pic­ture. Unem­ploy­ment is low, the stock mar­ket is do­ing well, and in­fla­tion may be un­der con­trol.

Advertise with us

The com­pli­cated econ­omy

Con­sumer con­fi­dence is on the rise, but that shift has not trans­lated to a more fa­vor­able view of Biden. That may be be­cause gro­cery prices have not fallen, and so higher prices are on vot­ers’ minds. Ac­cord­ing to Gallup poll­ing, the high cost of liv­ing is far and away Amer­i­cans’ most press­ing fi­nan­cial con­cern.

Vot­ers tend to blame the in­cum­bent pres­i­dent and his party for eco­nomic trou­bles. Credit for the good times doesn’t al­ways flow the same way. Shouldn’t his­tory tell us whether pres­i­dents are re­spon­si­ble for the di­rec­tion of the econ­omy?

While some stud­ies have found that the econ­omy per­forms bet­ter un­der Demo­cratic ad­min­is­tra­tions, one study con­cluded that the par­ti­san dif­fer­ences in eco­nomic per­for­mance did not stem from dif­fer­ent pol­icy ap­proaches, but rather from fac­tors such as oil shocks, growth of de­fense spend­ing and stron­ger eco­nomic growth abroad.

A de­cade ago, a col­league and I found that gas­o­line prices, home fore­clo­sure rates and lo­cal un­em­ploy­ment lev­els in a voter’s com­mu­nity were in­flu­en­tial in shap­ing their per­cep­tions of the na­tional econ­omy, which in turn af­fects vot­ing for pres­i­dent. Fac­tors like lo­cal un­em­ploy­ment, fed­eral spend­ing in one’s com­mu­nity and fed­eral re­spon­sive­ness in the af­ter­math of a nat­u­ral di­sas­ter drive sup­port for in­cum­bent pres­i­dents in af­fected com­mu­ni­ties.

This re­search helps ex­plain why Amer­i­cans may not broadly agree about how well the na­tion is do­ing — and whether Biden should be blamed or cred­ited for the econ­omy’s di­rec­tion. Par­ti­san po­lar­iza­tion also leads some vot­ers to set aside their own knowl­edge and ex­pe­ri­ence and blame the pres­i­dent, or a can­di­date, for al­most any­thing.

Advertise with us

Vot­ers also change their views of pres­i­dents be­cause of events well be­yond a pres­i­dent’s con­trol — such as when a lo­cal col­lege foot­ball or bas­ket­ball team wins a game right be­fore an elec­tion, or even the oc­cur­rence of a nat­u­ral di­sas­ter. One study found ev­i­dence that vot­ers blamed Pres­i­dent Wil­son for shark at­tacks off the coast of New Jer­sey in 1916.

The weather mat­ters

Here’s an­other thing pres­i­dents can’t con­trol: the weather. In 2012, Su­per­storm Sandy hit the East Coast in late Oc­to­ber as the pres­i­den­tial cam­paigns were in their fi­nal sprint.

The storm gave in­cum­bent Pres­i­dent Barack Obama the chance to be seen co­or­di­nat­ing the fed­eral re­sponse, com­fort­ing the af­fected com­mu­ni­ties, and meet­ing with Re­pub­li­can and Demo­cratic lead­ers. Some re­search shows that Obama re­ceived votes based on his re­sponse to Sandy.

Pres­i­dents can’t con­trol nat­u­ral di­sas­ters, but they do de­cide how to re­spond — some­times demon­strat­ing lead­er­ship and even bi­par­ti­san co­op­er­a­tion. Such re­sponses can re­veal in­for­ma­tion about the qual­ity of an elected of­fi­cial and po­ten­tially in­flu­ence votes.

The elec­tion could be in­flu­enced more by a ran­dom act of Mother Na­ture in the fall than by a de­bate per­for­mance in June.

Andrew Reeves is a professor of political science and director of the Weidenbaum Center on the Economy, Government, and Public Policy at Washington University in St. Louis.