David L. Lawrence, the former Pittsburgh mayor and governor of Pennsylvania, used to take his grandson to Steelers games in the 1950s and ’60s, long before they would become one of the NFL’s most iconic franchises.
Back then, they were simply known in these parts as the “Same Old Steelers”, a self-deprecating phrase coined by team founder Art Rooney years earlier.
The boy Lawrence took to those games was Tom Donahoe, who went on to head the Steelers’ personnel department from 1991-99.
“The crowds were sparse, and the players weren’t very good, but my grandfather was a great sports fan,” Donahoe said over the phone this week. “He would always drag me along to those games. Sometimes those Steelers teams weren’t very fun to watch.”
The 1965 team, in particular.
Donahoe was a senior at South Hills Catholic during the fall when the Steelers suffered through one of the worst seasons in franchise history.
Those Steelers were infamous for bad execution and a carelessness with the football that hasn’t been matched in more than six decades.
The ’65 Steelers set two records for futility that might never be broken. Their minus-195 point differential remains the worst in franchise history. They lost six games by 21 points or more, including the final five, when they were outscored 190-61.
They also set an NFL record with a minus-30 turnover differential. Tommy Wade, a young backup quarterback from Texas and a protege of Bobby Layne, made quite the contribution to that dubious record one day.
Wade threw seven interceptions, one shy of the NFL record, in a game late that season.
The Steelers finished with a 2-12 record, the worst season for the franchise since a 1-9-1 mark in 1941.
The historically bad season cost Mike Nixon his job. It was his first and only season as the Steelers’ head coach.
It was also Art Rooney Jr.’s first season as the team’s personnel director, a position he held until 1986.
Now 91, Rooney Jr. quipped earlier this week he had nothing to do with that team “stinking up the joint.”
And yet this ragtag bunch did something that season no Steelers team has done since.
The Philadelphia jinx
In 1965, Lyndon Baines Johnson was president, the Beatles played Shea Stadium and “A Charlie Brown Christmas” premiered on CBS.
It also was the last time the Pittsburgh Steelers won a game in Philadelphia. Their 11-game losing streak has spanned six decades, six head coaches and six Super Bowl victories.
Hall of Fame coaches Chuck Noll and Bill Cowher failed to win there. Mike Tomlin didn’t, either.
Mike McCarthy was a few weeks shy of his third birthday when Nixon led the Steelers into Franklin Field and walked out victorious.
“That’s unbelievable that it’s been that long,” Donahoe said.
On Oct. 24, 1965, the Steelers beat the Eagles 20-14, thanks in large part to a heroic effort from the defense. The Eagles outgained the Steelers 388-132, but the Steelers scored two defensive touchdowns to overcome their inept offense.
Cornerback Willie Daniel scored on a 17-yard fumble return. And safety Jim Bradshaw intercepted three passes, returning one 82 yards for a touchdown.
Quarterback Bill Nelsen completed only six passes, but one went to fullback Mike Lind for a four-yard score in the third quarter. The leading receiver for the Steelers was running back Dick Hoak, who died on Nov. 11.
This Sunday — 22,309 days later — the Steelers will try to win in Philadelphia for the first time since that day.
It’s the longest road losing streak in franchise history. The Steelers never won in Veterans Stadium, and they’re 0 for 4 at Lincoln Financial Field, which opened in 2003.
Two Steelers teams that went on to win the Super Bowl lost in Philadelphia during the regular season.
The 1979 Steelers had only four losses, but one of them was a 17-14 setback to Ron Jaworski and the Eagles.
The 2008 Steelers likewise had only four losses during the regular season. Donovan McNabb outdueled Ben Roethlisberger in a game that had the Steelers quarterback contemplating retirement less than four years into his career.
The Eagles sacked Roethlisberger nine times in a 15-6 defeat. The Steelers gained just 180 yards of offense in the entire game.
“I’m not a big ‘remembering games’ type guy, especially losses, but that’s one that I do remember vividly,” Roethlisberger said on his 93.7 The Fan radio show back in 2016. “I remember getting sacked eight or nine times. I remember driving home from the airport after that game and thinking to myself like, ‘Do I want to keep doing this? Do I really want to keep playing football?’ ”
The games in recent years have been even less competitive. In 2016, Eagles rookie quarterback Carson Wentz beat the Steelers 34-3.
In 2022, it was 35-13.
In 2024, it was 27-13.
The average margin of defeat during the 11-game losing streak is 11.8.
‘The time of our lives’
There was only one player on the 1965 roster who went on to earn a Super Bowl ring during the Steelers’ dynasty of the 1970s. Ray Mansfield was in his second season with the Steelers — as a defensive tackle.
It wasn’t until the following year, 1966, that Mansfield switched to center, a position he manned for the next decade. He was the starting center on the Steelers’ first two Super Bowl teams in 1974 and 1975.
(Andy Russell — like Mansfield, a member of those Super Bowl IX and X teams — arrived in 1963, but he honored an ROTC commitment and spent two years in the Army before rejoining the Steelers for the 1966 season).
After winning in Philadelphia in 1965 — 61 years ago now — that Steelers team lost seven games in a row to close out the year.
They went 11-28-3 over the next three seasons.
For most of his early years as personnel director, Rooney Jr. scoured colleges trying to find players who could change the franchise’s fortunes.
“I spent an awful lot of time on the road back in those days,” Rooney Jr. said. “I really loved the scouting part of it and the guys I worked with. Jack Butler and Bill Nunn were two of the best. It was the time of our lives.”
Still, for those following the Steelers, it wasn’t clear if and when the franchise would ever turn a corner.
“The thing I remember most about those teams is how frustrating it was to watch as a fan,” Donahoe said. “You just always wondered if they would be able to overcome all of that mediocrity and ever win. Luckily, Coach Noll came a few years later.”
Donahoe said Noll changed “the entire organization and the culture of the team.”
“It took him some time, but he was able to turn it around,” Donahoe said. “I remember the 1969 team. I don’t think they won a game.”
Actually, they won one — their first. It was followed by 13 consecutive losses, an unfortunate feat that turned into the No. 1 pick in the 1970 draft, a choice by the name of Terry Bradshaw.
Steelers fans know how the rest of the decade turned out.
Rooney Jr. has been retired since 1986, but he still serves as a member of the Steelers’ board of directors. He watches every game — even when he’d rather not.
Last Sunday night, he reached for the remote control and turned the television off when the Cincinnati Bengals were putting a whipping on the Steelers before a national television audience.
“My wife said, ‘You turn that game back on. You’re still an officer of that team.’ ”
This Sunday afternoon, Rooney and the rest of Steelers Nation will be watching to see if this team can finally put the Philly jinx to bed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.