It is not often that both political parties raise the same theme at the same time in the middle of a presidential election.
That is what happened recently, in suggestions by GOP presidential candidate and former President Donald Trump that the president should have some say over the setting of interest rates and President Joe Biden’s proposed reforms — basically an ethics code and term limits — aimed at the U.S. Supreme Court.
It is not my intention to debate the details of these proposals. The Federal Reserve has not done a stellar job of controlling inflation — too slow to raise interest rates at the start and maybe too slow to cut them now — and all states but one have abandoned the federal model of lifetime appointment of judges. Perhaps some reforms of these institutions are in order.
What lacks merit, however, is the premise of both these proposals.
Two democratic ways
That premise is that the independence of the Fed’s Board of Governors in making monetary policy and the independence of the Justices on the Supreme Court in interpreting the Constitution, are undemocratic.
As vice presidential candidate Ohio senator JD Vance put it, “The political leadership in this country should have more say over the monetary policy.” Both proposals are aimed at adding a layer of democratic control over the Fed and the Court.
Read More
But this premise is mistaken. As my late teacher Charles Black pointed out, there are two different ways that the people of the United States can exercise their democratic authority.
One way, our usual way, is for the people, through their representatives, to act directly and to choose policy. In this case, that would mean elected officials determining interest rates and a higher and faster turnover on the Court so presidents could appoint justices who share their ideology.
There is, however, another way for the people to set policy. The people can create decision-making institutions that are independent of their own wishes and preferences.
When the people do that, it is also an expression of democratic will. As Black put it, “The American people can be trusted because they do not trust themselves.”
The independence of the Fed and the Supreme Court are the result of just such democratic decisions. In the case of the Fed, independence flows from structure. There is a seven-member Board of Governors that sets monetary policy.
The term of each governor is 14 years. So, every two years a president nominates a governor. Removal over a disagreement concerning interest rates would probably be unlawful and has never been tried.
Congress could change the structure of the Fed tomorrow and introduce direct political control.
Democratic preference
With regard to the Supreme Court, the democratic nature of the commitment to independent judicial review is not as clear.
After all, Congress is stuck with the Court and the lifetime tenure of its justices, which are both delineated in the Constitution. Changing that structure would require a constitutional amendment.
Nevertheless, Congress could easily control judicial decision-making if it were determined to do so. Congress controls the number of justices on the Court through statute. Tomorrow, the Court could have nine additional Justices with nine nominations to be made by the President.
In 1802, Congress cancelled that year’s Supreme Court term because Congress did not want the Court to overturn its repeal of the prior administration’s expansion of the judiciary. And Congress decides the appellate jurisdiction of the Court, determining what types of cases the justices can hear.
Of course, there would be a political firestorm were Congress to exercise these powers in order to control the Court’s decision-making. But that is the point.
The American people have shown over time that, whatever they think of particular judicial decisions and particular justices, they prefer that an independent body determines their rights.
The reasons for this democratic preference of independent economic policy-making and independent constitutional interpretation are presumably rooted in the same soil of a fear by the public that politicians might seek short-term solutions and sacrifice longer-term goals.
This could happen even if our elected leaders acted completely in good faith.
Hands off
It would be natural for a president to seek to avoid the suffering that a recession brings by pressing for lower interest rates.
Slowing economic activity is clear to everyone while the threat of future inflation that lower interest rates might bring is purely speculative. Plus, losing one’s job is much more harmful to people than paying a little more for goods and services.
Similarly, it would be easy for politicians to press nominees to the Court to crack down on vicious hate speech and intentional disinformation despite the protections of the First Amendment.
The harm that these expressions do is obvious. The foundational role of free speech in a free society is often overlooked.
The people of the United States have made the decisions to cede direct democratic control over economics and law. These decisions have served us well. So, hands off the Fed and the Court until it is clear that the people have changed their minds.
Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “What JD Vance and the progressive left don’t understand about America.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.