I really wanted to go the Statue of Liberty with the rest of my classmates. But my fourth grade teacher had a rule that you had to turn in your homework to go on class field trips. I hadn’t. So while my class enjoyed a fun outing climbing the 354 steps to the statue’s crown, I worked on completing my homework assignments back at school.
I was afraid to tell my mother what had happened, so I did what a lot of ten year olds do: I lied. I not only lied, but I went to great lengths to enthusiastically spin a fable of how much fun I had. I smugly reveled in my storytelling skills until my mother came home from the beauty parlor one afternoon.
Understandable but lousy
It seems that a mother of one of my classmates sympathetically said to her, “Wasn’t it a shame that Jay didn’t go on the trip to the Statue of Liberty?” My mother did a double take before she recovered her composure and readily agreed.
She lost her composure on her trip home to confront me.
What I had done was understandable. I took a chance because the odds of being caught in a lie were slim and by not telling the truth I avoided being scolded for lazy homework habits. It proved to be a lousy decision.
We all lie. The consequences of our lies are more important than the fact we lied. I lied to protect myself from punishment. We also lie to protect the feelings of others (How do you like the pot roast ? I love it.) Lying to protect the feelings of others is less serious than lies that harm other people.
Read More
In politics, spreading lies to gain an advantage in an election unfairly hurts the liar’s opponents and deceives the liar’s supporters.
George Santos was expelled from Congress for telling lies about graduating from Baruch College, working for Citicorp and Goldman Sachs, and being Jewish. His lies enabled him to unfairly defeat his opponent in a 2022 Congressional election and persuaded his constituents to vote for someone who wasn’t remotely who he claimed to be.
In Arthur Miller’s World War II play, “All My Sons,” an airplane manufacturer knowingly builds faulty planes, which often crash, killing their pilots. His own son dies flying in one of the planes and his criminal lie takes on a painful personal meaning for him.
Similarly, lies like withholding information about the faulty brakes on a used car or the level of toxicity in a stream polluted by a nearby factory constitute a malicious degree of lying, which could result in injury, illness or death. But people lie because they don’t expect to suffer the results.
The growth of conspiracy driven information on platforms like Tik Tok, X, Facebook and the dissemination of disinformation by unscrupulous politicians has put the very nature of truth on trial. The harm done is not to an individual or group but to the role of the press, the integrity of the courts, the work of the intelligence services, the trust in the justice department; the institutions which collectively hold the fragile fabric of our democracy together.
The malicious distortion of reality also provides opportunities for crazy groups like QAnon to gain a level of credibility we’d never give to schizophrenics and psychotics.
Reality is always subject to different interpretations because people have opposing values. Liberals value protecting the environment even if it means that workers in the coal mining industry lose their jobs. Conservatives disagree.
Conservatives value giving tax breaks to corporations because they believe it advances the economy and creates jobs. Liberals disagree. We are allowed to have different opinions on the same subject. We aren’t entitled to have different sets of facts.
Either we do or we don’t
We either choose to live in a society where facts matter or we don’t. We either agree that democracy with all its faults and failings is worth preserving or we don’t. We either side with Lincoln that a “house divided cannot stand” or we widen our divisions and end up devouring ourselves.
We don’t have to like or agree with each other to support the idea that people have a right to disagree and an obligation to try to resolve our differences peacefully, civilly, without recourse to rancor and violence. We embarked on an experiment in self government 248 years ago that had never been tried before.
We are testing that experiment every time we go to vote and elect leaders to represent us. We are only as good as the people we elect; we are only as good as the people who elect them.
Jay Wissot is a columnist for the Vail Daily in Vail, Colorado, and occasional contributor to the Post-Gazette. His most recent article was “Running the marathon, and loving the Pittsburgh they saw.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.