Once active in politics, Tim Watcher got so angry with the barrage of ugly commercials he got rid of cable. “I was just sick and tired of watching it all, and so after having been so deeply involved in it to actually extract yourself from it, it's been quite liberating,” Tim, resident of Erie, told me.

The ads have already started. You hate the negative ads. I hate the negative ads. And the carpet bombing will resume shortly, because Pennsylvania is a swing state, and Erie ground zero. Since 2008 there have been 25 state elections in Pennsylvania, and this weathervane county has picked the winner 92% of the time.

Political rubbernecking

Mary Buchert, an Erie swing voter, is a “political orphan” who freely admits she hates the ads but finds herself staring at them. “You will listen to it, even though you don’t believe it. But you will listen to it. And the worst part is, not only will you listen to it. You will remember it,” the retired hospital social worker told me. “It’s like rubbernecking at a bad accident. You can’t help but look, but it’s human nature.’’

Sadly, ugly political campaigns have been around since the moment George Washington walked out the door. “As soon as Jefferson and Adams are fighting in 1800 it really devolves into attacks on personality. So, people dig in, and it really goes downhill from there,” observed Smithsonian election expert Jon Grinspan.

Advertise with us

But in the 2022 mid-terms, Democrats launched a new, cynical strategy that was wildly effective and soon copied successfully around the country. And the same script just played out this spring in the U.S. Republican Senate primary in Ohio.

What’s the template? Pennsylvania Democrats spent millions of dollars boosting a far-right Republican in the governor’s race. Knocking out a more moderate in the Republican primary was smart politics.

Fair game MAGA

Bob Shrum, the legendary political operative and now USC professor whose past presidential clients have included Ted Kennedy and George McGovern, says those ads worked because the core of the Pennsylvania Republican Party “is Trump-ist, MAGA, fair game.’’

But critics inside the party say this tactic risks disaster. Helping election deniers to survive the primary means they are one step closer to winning a general election. It hasn’t happened yet, but it could just be luck.

In a 2022 race in Western Michigan, the same playbook beat Republican Peter Meier, a moderate from Western Michigan who even voted to impeach Trump. That prompted two dozen former Democratic Senators and Representatives, including former Speaker Dick Gephardt, to send a blistering letter to the Democratic campaign committee.

Advertise with us

Former Indiana Congressman Tim Roemer and I served together in Congress and often worked together, I as a Republican and he as a Democrat. He was appalled by the election gamesmanship because the stakes are so high.

Wrong on every front

“To me it is wrong on every front. We should not promote a candidate who tells lies about 2020, especially in a swing state like Michigan because it could all come back to bite us in 2024. Why would we risk electing election deniers?”

With another season of primary races ahead of us this spring and summer, I think the Democrats would be wise to pay attention to those warnings. I concede it may give them a short-term win, but at what cost to Democracy?

Scott Klug, a former member of Congress from Wisconsin, is the host of the podcast “Lost in the Middle.”