If you bought the idea of a “new Trump,” after his near-death experience, perhaps recent evidence has disabused you of that notion. We have, first, the selection of JD Vance as Donald Trump’s running mate. Mr. Vance is Mr. Trump’s Agnew — the attack dog.

Next, Mr. Trump’s first major speech after the convention, in Grand Rapids, Michigan. What was the message? Strength. Strength is all. He praised the autocrats of the globe and said they truly understand: The leader must be the protector of the nation.

Third, we have Mr. Trump saying this: “It’ll be fixed; it’ll be fine; you won’t have to vote any more my beautiful Christians.” If they get out the vote, and he wins, his Christian followers will no longer need to vote.

Can voters see?

Can American voters truly hear this? Can they see past the show? For, at the moment, it is all show. There is certainly little politics, as we once understood it. For example, the choice of Mr. Vance would be a mistake in traditional political terms.

Advertise with us

He is a shock jock with the U.S. Senate as his radio. He brings no one new to his party; he reassures no one. He is not a legislator, but a culture warrior.

Traditionally, the idea of a general election campaign is to go beyond the base – to add, not just intensify. But we are in the grip of MAGA politics: Magical thinking meeting the primal scream.

And we are not asking the questions we need to ask. For example: How do we define strength in a democracy? Is it merely might? Or is it also principle and character? Do we want a president who seeks to be strong the way Putin is strong?

Is isolationism “strong”? And might true “protection” of citizens have something to do with the rule of law?

The left doesn’t exactly help citizens focus: Intimidating people about ideological purity, the tests of which change daily. The left feeds Trumpism.

Advertise with us

I like the new (old) John Fetterman — a labor liberal of the old school who simply won’t go along. But he is still standing.

In the Grand New Party, the Cult of the Donald, anyone who does not go along, is not just shouted down but destroyed. The new Republican Party wants to eliminate the federal government as we know it; the tax system as we know it; the right to privacy, as we know it.

Are these good ideas?

Bad ideas

How about allowing boys, kids really, to arm themselves with weapons of war and terror? How is it that we are not talking about this?

The Republicans promise to abolish the deep state. Well, yes, the deep state can be arrogant and resistant to accountability. The deep state is also the permanent bureaucracy. It is the WAY we staff embassies, and deliver Social Security checks, and collect taxes.

Advertise with us

The federal government can overreach and be oppressive. And we need it to help us with our lives and to keep the nation functioning. Both things are true.

If your passport is stolen in Greece; your partner disappears in Mexico; or your kid is busted in Thailand, you’d better hope there is a state, and that it is fairly deep.

The center of actual politics, real politics, is moderation and nuance. Both are banished in the Grand Trump Party. The Republican convention was a long recital of the music of nihilism, just tuned, for a moment, to easy listening instead of punk.

JD Vance a heartbeat away? How utterly irresponsible and unserious. I remember when people were afraid of Bob Dole a heartbeat away (1976). Too extreme they said.

Mr. Trump had a chance to do something for the country. He could have united poor whites and poor blacks in a populist movement that renewed the country’s faith in itself. (As Robert Kennedy and Bernie Sanders also sought to do.)

Advertise with us

Instead, he contented himself with whipping his constituency into a permanent state of betrayal and aggression.

And, in four years in power, actually occupying the presidency, he blew it. He did almost nothing. He showed no bravery or independence. He could not figure out the job and would not do the work.

He didn’t bring jobs back to Appalachia, or Cleveland, or Detroit. He didn’t begin to rebuild the working class. Joe Biden did that.

The nation’s choice

And since Jan. 6, 2021, Mr. Trump has decided he is both a victim of the deep state and the reincarnation, not of Andrew Jackson, but Benito Mussolini.

Mr. Trump says we are a ruined country, a third world country. He frames our choice as between strength and weakness.

Advertise with us

Ms. Harris and the Democrats should say: No, it is a choice between crazy and sane; unstable and stable; extremism and pragmatism; rage and decency; autocracy and American constitutional liberty.

For that is the choice.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Joe Biden is a lover in a time of rage.”