Donald Trump’s conviction on 34 counts — I defy you to name them — tells us that we are in a dangerous moment in which the indictment threatens to replace the ballot. For once, I can agree with Democrats who have been saying democracy is at risk.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg reached deep into the arcana of election law to convince a jury that by paying off a porn star, Donald Trump materially affected the 2016 presidential election in a state he lost by nearly 10 points. If Trump was trying to save his chances of winning the vote somewhere, it sure wasn’t New York.
Legal backflips
Instead of a clear crime demanding prosecution, prosecutors did legal backflips to find a crime they could prosecute. That should frighten everyone.
We are at the point in our history where a fifty-year accretion of vague statutes can be employed in virtually any combination. All we need is a target (Trump) and a venue (Manhattan) where the defendant is already considered a villain.
Bragg needed more than a provable case of false bookkeeping. To turn those presumed payoffs into a felony, he needed them to be in the furtherance of another crime. His staff scoured the law to find something.
They found New York Election Law 17-152. That law makes it illegal for someone to use “unlawful means” to influence an election. A reasonable mind might imagine vote-buying or embezzling money to pay for ads. Certainly, the first thought is not paying off a porn star.
Read More
We won’t know. Judge Juan Merchan would not permit testimony by the head of the Federal Elections Commission, a witness who might have said whether that vague statute comports with reality.
Validating legal abuse
The New York law is vague and almost never invoked, and yet tacking it onto a bookkeeping violation allowed Bragg to convict the former president. In years ahead, some variation of this unique legal tactic could be used by a Republican against a Democrat.
The Democratic district attorney of Manhattan just gave backhanded validation to Republican efforts to resurrect Hunter Biden’s laptop.
It’s important to keep in mind that Donald Trump denies an affair with Stormy Daniels. Absent the testimony of a porn star who extracted money for silence, we have no concrete proof that this was anything more than a celebrity trying to prevent his public humiliation.
Bragg’s predecessor, Cyrus Vance Jr. searched the same lawbooks and decided there was no prosecutable felony. Possibly, he valued fidelity to the law and its purpose over becoming a public rock star and, just maybe, the next Mayor of New York.
The reason we have laws
Donald Trump would not have been the first public figure hit with a demand for cash from someone threatening to defame them. For years celebrities have settled nuisance suits to avoid the misery and litigation of false accusations.
We cannot know what, if anything, happened in that hotel room in Lake Tahoe. Which side we believe is largely shaped by our politics. But the reason we have laws is that public sentiment isn’t supposed to decide whether someone’s a criminal.
Certainly, it’s not how we’re supposed to choose a president.
Sam DeMarco is Republican Chairman of Allegheny County and an at-large member of Allegheny County Council.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.