“Hillary Clinton should have been prosecuted and should be in jail. Instead,” Trump wrote on social media in October 2016, “she is running for president in what looks like a rigged election.” He was referring to Ms. Clinton’s violation of security protocol in her use of a private email server.

Over the years, calls of “Lock her up!” have become a mainstay of Trump’s rallies, and he has never made an effort to quiet or quell the chants, often affirming them.

Yesterday, days after he was historically convicted in the hush money trial, he denied ever doing anything of the sort. “I didn’t say ‘lock her up,’ but the people said ‘lock her up, lock her up,’” he told “Fox & Friends Weekend.”

Rewriting reality

“Then, we won,” he continued. “And I say — and I said pretty openly, I said, all right, come on, just relax, let’s go, we’ve got to make our country great.”

Advertise with us

It took me less than a minute to find several videos of the crowd chanting “lock her up,” as he placidly watches from the podium — all from the last month.

In the newest season of Trump reality, he was magnanimous when his successor was cruel. He chose not to prosecute Ms. Clinton (after the FBI recommended the Justice Department not prosecute her). In a partisan twist of fate, he asserts, President Biden prosecuted him (even though the state of New York prosecuted and was in no way directed by Mr. Biden).

Trump is retconning history in an attempt to soften the blow of his conviction. The problem was due process, not him, never him. And the hypocrisy can only be explained by having never existed in the first place.

“I beat her,” Trump said in the too-well-lit “Fox & Friends” segment (everyone was being interrogated, it seemed). “It’s easier when you win. And they always said ‘lock her up,’ and I felt — and I could have done it, but I felt it would have been a terrible thing. And then this happened to me.”

Tangled up in the blatant duplicity of Trump’s statement is the innocuous and revealingly accurate, “It’s easier when you win.” Which is to say: Donald Trump is finally acknowledging that he lost the last election, though without specifying what exactly it is that he lost. He’s also finally signaling that there are benefits to winning that are not granted to the loser.

Advertise with us

Trump’s message

Ms. Clinton was not completely innocent. She used a private email server when she should have been using a government one, which led to issues in document archival as well as security. That the FBI determined that her violations did not rise to the level of prosecution does not mean that violations did not exist.

In my attempts to make sense of why Trump is walking back his statements about Ms. Clinton, I think he’s trying to tell us there was no moment when he actually thought or believed that Ms. Clinton should go to jail. It was always pretend. It was always theater, bread and circus to keep his supporters entertained.

Then the penny dropped. He could actually go to jail.

Going to jail is scary. There is a reason that humankind has persisted with punitive practices like isolation and incarceration. A loss of freedom is the ultimate loss of control. Donald Trump never imagined himself in jail because people like him usually do not end up in jail.

We live in a world in which access to good lawyers can make all the difference, can keep someone free for a crime for which someone else would go to prison. Trump will always have access to the very best lawyers, as will Ms. Clinton. Both exist at the top of pyramid of American power. Neither have ever calloused their hands. Most people who have been processed through the justice system in this country cannot say the same.

Advertise with us

House arrest

I doubt Trump will ever be in a prison with general population inmates. The Secret Service logistics alone would create a nightmare.

The reality is that someone like Trump, if he ever sees any jail time, will likely serve it out at home, confined and incarcerated, but inside a literally gilded cage (having seen the color palette Trump prefers). He will have everything, except the freedom to leave. He may be home, but he’ll still be a prisoner.

It might seem that Trump is telling an outrageous lie about Ms. Clinton in claiming that he both never believed should be locked up and implying she would be if not for him. But, to me, his statement really reveals an equally outrageous truth.

Trump assumed that Ms. Clinton was above the law, that his followers’ chants were simply the songs of children, and never portents. But turns out they were sirens — harbingers of the impending rocks, and personal doom, ahead.

I’m sure he regrets his old comments now that he’s lost. It’s easier when you win.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “Two Juneteenths are better than one.” Find her on X @zadri.