It’s always a bad sign when you ask how good someone is at his job and the first response is, “He’s a really nice guy.” Writing in The Athletic, Sam Blum and Cody Stavenhagen did this twice in their profile of MLB umpire Angel Hernandez, who abruptly retired the next day, to the relief of many, maybe millions, of baseball fans.
Was he that bad? Was it fair that he became a favorite subject for social media pile-ons and sports site com box muggings?
He might not have been. The web’s not always fair. People like to form into mobs to go after shared whipping boys. You can energize a dead dinner party when you discover you all despise the same guy. Maybe Hernandez was just the guy everyone agreed to abuse, because we enjoy abuse as long as we’re not the target.
As I was writing this, a Manhattan jury found Donald Trump guilty on all 34 counts in the hush money case. I think the contrast between Angel Hernandez, social media villain, and Donald Trump, convicted felon, illuminating, about which, more at the end.
Was Hernandez that bad?
First the umpire. Fans piled on the poor man, but what we do know? Players and managers rarely comment on the umpires, for obvious reasons. The number who openly criticized Hernandez and what they said about him offers important evidence.
Hernandez once tossed Tigers All Star Ian Kinsler from the game for ... looking back at him after a bad call on a third strike. Not saying anything. Just looking. “He needs to find another job,” Kinsler said afterward. “He really does. I’m just saying it’s pretty obvious that he needs to stop ruining baseball games.”
Read More
“He’s always bad. He’s a bad umpire,” said pitcher C.C. Sabathia, for example. Tigers manager A.J. Hinch accused him of being “arrogant” and called him “unprofessional.” Many other said the same kinds of things.
Former Pirates manager Jim Leyland was kinder. “You can get out of character a bit when you have a tough situation on the field. I think we all get out of character a little bit. But I’ve always gotten along fine with Angel.”
The witness statements indicate Hernandez was not good at his job. The data indicates that as well. Dylan Yep of Umpire Auditor ranks him as the 60th to 70th most accurate umpire out of 85 to 90 umpires. Not great, but that’s not the real problem.
“He consistently ends up in incredibly odd scenarios,” Yep told Blum and Stavenhagen, “and he seems to make incorrect calls in bizarre scenarios.” Others say this as well. In one game Yep posted about, Hernandez called strikes on seven pitches more than three inches outside. He called three straight on one poor batter, the third strike being outside by almost seven inches. That’s inexplicably bad umpiring.
A bad umpire
Judging from my reading: Angel Hernandez was a below average Major League umpire, though not the worst; he made some ridiculously bad calls of the sort even his fellow below average umpires didn’t make, at least so often; some of these were so bad people could reasonably suspect he just didn’t care or was playing some weird personal game, maybe of the “I’m doing this because I can” sort; and he did not seem to believe he could make mistakes.
So a bad umpire, but off the field he seems to be the really good guy his friends described. A lot of people go from Dr. Jekyll to Mr. Hyde when they go online, when they have the power to say whatever they want, like spit on an infuriating umpire. Maybe Hernandez went from great guy to tyrant when he got on the baseball field, where he had the power to do whatever he wanted.
Most of us have places we’re not at our best, but most of us don’t make our living in those places, and not in front of millions of people where our faults shine in the spotlight. We could be Angel Hernandez if life had gone otherwise. I’m glad he retired, though.
But Donald Trump
But Donald Trump, Donald Trump is different. He’s not necessarily guilty of any charge against him. He might actually be innocent. Some of his enemies are no more scrupulous than he is, and some are deranged, and some are cynical.
But, and this I think a key to his character: He is a man who is never necessarily innocent.
He does not seem to live in a world with moral and ethical rules. I think this is obvious in the way he lies, saying anything he needs or wants to say at the moment. He doesn’t seem to know the eighth commandment (don’t lie), much less think it a rule.
Not recognizing moral and ethical rules, he treats the law itself as if it were arbitrary and therefore something to be manipulated and evaded and broken if needed. Like illegally gaming the system to keep an embarrassing story out of the news.
There is no place that Donald Trump is not Donald Trump. You can never say “Oh, he wouldn’t do that.” Because he might.
David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “The right’s careless, reckless, sneaky propaganda.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.