It’s al­ways a bad sign when you ask how good some­one is at his job and the first re­sponse is, “He’s a re­ally nice guy.” Writ­ing in The Ath­letic, Sam Blum and Cody Staven­ha­gen did this twice in their pro­file of MLB um­pire An­gel Her­nan­dez, who abruptly re­tired the next day, to the re­lief of many, maybe mil­lions, of base­ball fans.

Was he that bad? Was it fair that he be­came a fa­vor­ite sub­ject for so­cial me­dia pile-ons and sports site com box mug­gings?

He might not have been. The web’s not al­ways fair. People like to form into mobs to go af­ter shared whip­ping boys. You can en­er­gize a dead din­ner party when you dis­cover you all de­spise the same guy. Maybe Her­nan­dez was just the guy ev­ery­one agreed to abuse, be­cause we enjoy abuse as long as we’re not the target.

As I was writ­ing this, a Man­hat­tan jury found Don­ald Trump guilty on all 34 counts in the hush money case. I think the con­trast be­tween An­gel Her­nan­dez, so­cial me­dia vil­lain, and Don­ald Trump, con­victed felon, il­lu­mi­nat­ing, about which, more at the end.

Advertise with us

Was Her­nan­dez that bad?

First the um­pire. Fans piled on the poor man, but what we do know? Play­ers and man­ag­ers rarely com­ment on the um­pires, for ob­vi­ous rea­sons. The num­ber who openly crit­i­cized Her­nan­dez and what they said about him offers important evidence.

Her­nan­dez once tossed Tigers All Star Ian Kin­sler from the game for ... look­ing back at him af­ter a bad call on a third strike. Not say­ing any­thing. Just look­ing. “He needs to find an­other job,” Kin­sler said af­ter­ward. “He re­ally does. I’m just say­ing it’s pretty ob­vi­ous that he needs to stop ru­in­ing base­ball games.”

“He’s al­ways bad. He’s a bad um­pire,” said pitcher C.C. Sabathia, for example. Tigers man­ager A.J. Hinch accused him of be­ing “ar­ro­gant” and called him “un­pro­fes­sional.” Many other said the same kinds of things.

Former Pirates man­ager Jim Ley­land was kinder. “You can get out of char­ac­ter a bit when you have a tough sit­u­a­tion on the field. I think we all get out of char­ac­ter a lit­tle bit. But I’ve al­ways got­ten along fine with An­gel.”

The wit­ness state­ments in­di­cate Hernandez was not good at his job. The data in­di­cates that as well. Dy­lan Yep of Um­pire Au­di­tor ranks him as the 60th to 70th most ac­cu­rate um­pire out of 85 to 90 um­pires. Not great, but that’s not the real prob­lem.

Advertise with us

“He con­sis­tently ends up in in­cred­i­bly odd sce­nar­ios,” Yep told Blum and Staven­ha­gen, “and he seems to make in­cor­rect calls in bi­zarre sce­nar­ios.” Others say this as well. In one game Yep posted about, Her­nan­dez called strikes on seven pitches more than three inches out­side. He called three straight on one poor bat­ter, the third strike be­ing out­side by al­most seven inches. That’s inexplicably bad umpiring.

A bad umpire

Judg­ing from my read­ing: An­gel Her­nan­dez was a be­low av­er­age Ma­jor League um­pire, though not the worst; he made some ri­dic­u­lously bad calls of the sort even his fel­low be­low av­er­age um­pires didn’t make, at least so of­ten; some of these were so bad peo­ple could rea­son­ably sus­pect he just didn’t care or was play­ing some weird per­sonal game, maybe of the “I’m do­ing this be­cause I can” sort; and he did not seem to be­lieve he could make mis­takes.

So a bad um­pire, but off the field he seems to be the re­ally good guy his friends de­scribed. A lot of peo­ple go from Dr. Jekyll to Mr. Hyde when they go on­line, when they have the power to say what­ever they want, like spit on an in­fu­ri­at­ing um­pire. Maybe Her­nan­dez went from great guy to ty­rant when he got on the base­ball field, where he had the power to do what­ever he wanted.

Most of us have places we’re not at our best, but most of us don’t make our liv­ing in those places, and not in front of mil­lions of peo­ple where our faults shine in the spot­light. We could be An­gel Her­nan­dez if life had gone oth­er­wise. I’m glad he re­tired, though.

But Don­ald Trump

But Don­ald Trump, Don­ald Trump is dif­fer­ent. He’s not nec­es­sar­ily guilty of any charge against him. He might ac­tu­ally be in­no­cent. Some of his en­e­mies are no more scru­pu­lous than he is, and some are de­ranged, and some are cyn­i­cal.

Advertise with us

But, and this I think a key to his char­ac­ter: He is a man who is never nec­es­sar­ily in­no­cent.

He does not seem to live in a world with moral and eth­i­cal rules. I think this is ob­vi­ous in the way he lies, say­ing any­thing he needs or wants to say at the mo­ment. He doesn’t seem to know the eighth com­mand­ment (don’t lie), much less think it a rule.

Not recognizing moral and ethical rules, he treats the law it­self as if it were ar­bi­trary and there­fore some­thing to be ma­nip­u­lated and evaded and bro­ken if needed. Like illegally gam­ing the sys­tem to keep an em­bar­rass­ing story out of the news.

There is no place that Don­ald Trump is not Don­ald Trump. You can never say “Oh, he wouldn’t do that.” Because he might.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “The right’s careless, reckless, sneaky propaganda.”