Is some­thing right be­cause God says so or does God say some­thing is right be­cause it is right? This di­lemma was posed by Plato over 2000 years ago.

On the first in­ter­pre­ta­tion, God could say any­thing and be­cause he says it, it is right. He could flood the world, cause plagues, and ask Abra­ham to kill his own son. On the sec­ond in­ter­pre­ta­tion, there is a dis­tinc­tion be­tween the say­ings of the Lord and the na­ture of right and wrong.

In other words, there is a dis­tinc­tion be­tween the sphere of re­li­gion and the sphere of eth­ics. And that is one rea­son the at­tempt to mix church and state, like re­quir­ing the Ten Com­mand­ments to be posted in pub­lic schools, is a mis­take of bib­li­cal pro­por­tions.

The En­light­en­ment Dec­la­ra­tion

These kinds of dis­tinc­tions, like that be­tween re­li­gion and eth­ics, would un­dergo rig­or­ous anal­y­sis dur­ing the time in his­tory that we call the En­light­en­ment. No lon­ger tied to the dogma of the past, think­ers in this pe­riod felt them­selves free to ex­plore new ways of un­der­stand­ing our­selves and the world, guided by rea­son, ar­gu­ment, and the dis­cov­er­ies of what was called the New Science.

Advertise with us

Dur­ing the 1700s En­light­en­ment works had fil­tered down to a grow­ing com­mon un­der­stand­ing of hu­man dig­nity and hu­man rights. Indeed, the ideas of the En­light­en­ment were part of the moral back­ground for the French and Amer­i­can rev­o­lu­tions.

We see this in the rhe­tor­i­cal flare of the Dec­la­ra­tion of Inde­pen­dence. To be sure there is a heart­felt ref­er­ence to the Cre­ator, but the in­alien­able rights of life, lib­erty and the pur­suit of hap­pi­ness can, like the dis­tinc­tions above, stand on their own.

More­over, there is no men­tion of God in the ar­gu­ments of the Fed­er­al­ist Papers, our coun­try’s trea­tise on Po­lit­i­cal Philos­o­phy. Nor is there any men­tion of God in the Con­sti­tu­tion it­self. Indeed, the Estab­lish­ment Clause of the Con­sti­tu­tion states that “Con­gress shall make no law re­spect­ing an es­tab­lish­ment of re­li­gion, or pro­hib­it­ing the free ex­er­cise thereof.”

Newly en­acted Tol­er­ance Laws al­lowed both the free­dom to prac­tice re­li­gion and free­dom from a re­li­gious sect im­pos­ing its be­liefs upon oth­ers. The in­her­ently in­tol­er­ant tone of the First Com­mand­ment, “I am the Lord thy God … you shall have no other gods be­fore Me,” would not pass con­sti­tu­tional mus­ter then or now.

Jef­fer­son’s his­tor­i­cal odd­ity

It’s in­struc­tive to fol­low an his­tor­i­cal odd­ity here, Tho­mas Jef­fer­son’s “Bible” called “The Life and Morals of Je­sus of Naza­reth.” Jef­fer­son, like a num­ber of oth­ers dur­ing the found­ing pe­riod, was a “di­est.” He sought a “ra­tio­nal re­li­gion” that would pro­vide moral guid­ance.

Advertise with us

Jef­fer­son lit­er­ally took ra­zor and glue to cop­ies of the Bible and pasted to­gether a text with­out ref­er­ence to mir­a­cles, proph­e­sies, an­gels along with the de­ifi­ca­tion and res­ur­rec­tion of Je­sus. What re­mained, for Jef­fer­son, were the sim­ple moral teach­ing of Je­sus un­der­stand­able by all.

To be sure, Jef­fer­son saw these teach­ings as con­du­cive to “lib­erty, sci­ence and the fre­est ex­pan­sion of the hu­man mind.” A flawed man blind to the con­tra­dic­tions in­her­ent in his hold­ing of black slaves, he none­the­less be­lieved that he was a Chris­tian in the man­ner of one who fol­lowed the moral teach­ing of Je­sus as he con­strued him.

Need­less to say, many would take this as her­esy then and to­day. His ef­fort was not in­tended for pub­li­ca­tion, be­ing de­scribed by him as a “sect of one.” But it ex­em­pli­fies the dou­ble strength of the es­tab­lish­ment clause — free­dom from a state im­posed re­li­gion but also free­dom to be­lieve in mat­ters of con­science.

In Au­gust of 1814, the Brit­ish at­tacked and burned mul­ti­ple build­ings in Wash­ing­ton in­clud­ing the Pres­i­den­tial Man­sion and the U.S. Cap­i­tol build­ing. Jef­fer­son had “learned from the news­pa­pers that the van­dal­ism of our en­emy has tri­umphed at Wash­ing­ton over sci­ence as well as the arts by the de­struc­tion of the pub­lic li­brary with the no­ble ed­i­fice in which it was de­pos­ited.” He of­fered his per­sonal li­brary of over 6,000 vol­umes to Con­gress to help re­build the li­brary.

The of­fer faced op­po­si­tion. Con­gress­man Cyrus King ar­gued that this would al­low Jef­fer­son to dis­sem­i­nate his “in­fi­del phi­los­o­phy” and that many of the books were in “lan­guages that many can­not read and that most ought not.” The Bill passed and these books be­came part of the Li­brary of Con­gress.

Advertise with us

Plu­ral­is­tic, not theo­cratic

The moral of this story is that we live in a coun­try with many vi­sions of what to be­lieve in and how to live our lives. This is a mark of a mod­ern, plu­ral­is­tic de­moc­racy. We are not a the­oc­racy like those we see in Iran and Af­ghan­istan.

The re­cent de­ci­sion by the State of Lou­i­si­ana to post the 10 Com­mand­ments in ev­ery class­room and the re­cent de­ci­sion by Okla­homa’s Su­per­in­ten­dent of In­struc­tion to in­clude the Bible in the cur­ric­u­lum of ev­ery class fly in the face of our found­ing’s prin­ci­ples, how­ever flawed they may have been.

Robert Cava­lier, di­rec­tor of the Pro­gram for De­lib­er­a­tive De­moc­racy at Car­ne­gie Mel­lon Univer­sity, is the au­thor of “De­moc­racy for Begin­ners.” His previous article was “Pennsylvanians have already decided for Roe.”