Is something right because God says so or does God say something is right because it is right? This dilemma was posed by Plato over 2000 years ago.
On the first interpretation, God could say anything and because he says it, it is right. He could flood the world, cause plagues, and ask Abraham to kill his own son. On the second interpretation, there is a distinction between the sayings of the Lord and the nature of right and wrong.
In other words, there is a distinction between the sphere of religion and the sphere of ethics. And that is one reason the attempt to mix church and state, like requiring the Ten Commandments to be posted in public schools, is a mistake of biblical proportions.
The Enlightenment Declaration
These kinds of distinctions, like that between religion and ethics, would undergo rigorous analysis during the time in history that we call the Enlightenment. No longer tied to the dogma of the past, thinkers in this period felt themselves free to explore new ways of understanding ourselves and the world, guided by reason, argument, and the discoveries of what was called the New Science.
During the 1700s Enlightenment works had filtered down to a growing common understanding of human dignity and human rights. Indeed, the ideas of the Enlightenment were part of the moral background for the French and American revolutions.
We see this in the rhetorical flare of the Declaration of Independence. To be sure there is a heartfelt reference to the Creator, but the inalienable rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness can, like the distinctions above, stand on their own.
Moreover, there is no mention of God in the arguments of the Federalist Papers, our country’s treatise on Political Philosophy. Nor is there any mention of God in the Constitution itself. Indeed, the Establishment Clause of the Constitution states that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
Newly enacted Tolerance Laws allowed both the freedom to practice religion and freedom from a religious sect imposing its beliefs upon others. The inherently intolerant tone of the First Commandment, “I am the Lord thy God … you shall have no other gods before Me,” would not pass constitutional muster then or now.
Jefferson’s historical oddity
It’s instructive to follow an historical oddity here, Thomas Jefferson’s “Bible” called “The Life and Morals of Jesus of Nazareth.” Jefferson, like a number of others during the founding period, was a “diest.” He sought a “rational religion” that would provide moral guidance.
Jefferson literally took razor and glue to copies of the Bible and pasted together a text without reference to miracles, prophesies, angels along with the deification and resurrection of Jesus. What remained, for Jefferson, were the simple moral teaching of Jesus understandable by all.
To be sure, Jefferson saw these teachings as conducive to “liberty, science and the freest expansion of the human mind.” A flawed man blind to the contradictions inherent in his holding of black slaves, he nonetheless believed that he was a Christian in the manner of one who followed the moral teaching of Jesus as he construed him.
Needless to say, many would take this as heresy then and today. His effort was not intended for publication, being described by him as a “sect of one.” But it exemplifies the double strength of the establishment clause — freedom from a state imposed religion but also freedom to believe in matters of conscience.
In August of 1814, the British attacked and burned multiple buildings in Washington including the Presidential Mansion and the U.S. Capitol building. Jefferson had “learned from the newspapers that the vandalism of our enemy has triumphed at Washington over science as well as the arts by the destruction of the public library with the noble edifice in which it was deposited.” He offered his personal library of over 6,000 volumes to Congress to help rebuild the library.
The offer faced opposition. Congressman Cyrus King argued that this would allow Jefferson to disseminate his “infidel philosophy” and that many of the books were in “languages that many cannot read and that most ought not.” The Bill passed and these books became part of the Library of Congress.
Pluralistic, not theocratic
The moral of this story is that we live in a country with many visions of what to believe in and how to live our lives. This is a mark of a modern, pluralistic democracy. We are not a theocracy like those we see in Iran and Afghanistan.
The recent decision by the State of Louisiana to post the 10 Commandments in every classroom and the recent decision by Oklahoma’s Superintendent of Instruction to include the Bible in the curriculum of every class fly in the face of our founding’s principles, however flawed they may have been.
Robert Cavalier, director of the Program for Deliberative Democracy at Carnegie Mellon University, is the author of “Democracy for Beginners.” His previous article was “Pennsylvanians have already decided for Roe.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.