The article, on a more-patriotic-than-you site, spoke of a homeless man as “a teetering, drooling zombie barely maintaining the accustomed vertical orientation of humanity — its head, neck, and back doubling over further and further, heavy eyelids drooping down time and again on the remaining vestiges of any consciousness to which it only weakly clings.”

You will have noticed that “its.” That surprised me. No one talks like that, even people who think like that. It’s not done.

Reading someone write of another human being as an “it” is like seeing a man in a tuxedo at a banquet pee on the floor. However uncouth he is, he knows not to do that. However morally coarse a man is, he knows (I would have thought) not to call another person “it” in public.

A true American wouldn’t talk like that. A true American — the America we celebrate this Fourth of July — lives by the vision of humanity Thomas Jefferson gave us in the Declaration of Independence.

Advertise with us

The famous words

Not that Jefferson managed to live by it himself all that well. But he gave us the words.

I mean, of course, the famous ones, that we Americans “hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” This implies a great deal, but one truth it assumes is that no one is an it, that everyone is a human being possessed of the almost infinite dignity of a human being.

The article appeared on the hard-MAGA site American Greatness and is still up after a couple of years. It’s extreme, to be fair, but it represents one natural end of the movement’s moral trajectory — a movement led by a man who who has built a campaign not on a vision of what America could be but on how awful other Americans are. (I am not convinced how many other politicians really believe in Jefferson’s vision, but at least they speak as if they do, which is something.)

“I know the unyielding ukase of my educated pedigree and those who share it is that empathy and compassion are the only sanctioned responses to this sorry spectacle,” Alexander Zubatov wrote. “But that would require me to rationalize my way out of a feeling and override all my sound, sane animal instincts.”

He explains that “those instincts are of pre-cognitive repulsion and disgust, and I refuse to let them go. I refuse to humanize those who cannot be bothered to lift a finger to humanize themselves. The mentally ill need our care. The rest need the whip.”

Advertise with us

He seems to include people with alcohol problems in “the rest.” He says they, the whipped, will thank us for it someday. That’s the cruel man’s universal justification. He cares. He cares so much he’s willing to be hard. But it’s a lie. He doesn’t care. He couldn’t write the way he does if he did. He despises, which is to say hates.

The article is titled “We Are Living in the Ruins of Our Civilization,” but if our civilization is ruined, Zubatov is himself the perfect example of the ruin and of the mind and morals that ruin it. As is the site that published his article.

Our civilization

As a practical test, try to think of any of the great heroes and exemplars of our civilization who could have written that article. Not, definitely not, Jesus. Not St. Francis or St. Clare. Not Shakespeare, George Washington, Jane Austen, Martin Luther King Jr., not 10,000 more people we could name.

One of the marks of our civilization is overcoming what Zubatov calls our “animal instincts” and our “pre-cognitive repulsion and disgust” and treating as human, as human as you and me, those he calls the “sorry spectacle.” Our civilization begins in the belief that being human means rising above our animal instincts, especially in seeing everyone as a creature made (in the Christian way of putting it) in the image of God.

A major MAGA website published this repellent, hateful piece. Is this their idea of “American Greatness”? Because no true American, no one who lives by the idea of humanity Thomas Jefferson articulated in our founding statement, would write or publish such a thing.

Advertise with us

It’s not American greatness, it’s un-American squalor. But an uncomfortably large number of Americans think like Zubatov, even if they know not to say it. They will be found on left and right both, because dehumanizing others is so easy, and so rewarding.

Better Americans

Jefferson failed to see, or at least to put into practice, the inalienable rights of those he’d enslaved, with which their Creator, and his, had endowed them. But we are all worse than our best principles, and nothing keeps us from being better Americans, better observers of Jefferson’s declaration, than he was.

That includes an expansive and expanding view of those we see as — we know to be with complete conviction — human beings endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, among them the rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. It includes an expansive and expanding view of what that means for the way we treat others and care for each other, including not only the citizen but the alien.

That’s the America we celebrate every Fourth of July. And God bless that America.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Louisiana, thou shalt not use the Ten Commandments to make a political statement.”