Perhaps you’ve heard: Our governor is a moderate president-in-the-making.
Josh Shapiro is leaning into this image as the state legislature negotiates next year’s budget, indicating that he supports a school-choice scholarship program for low-income students — a popular policy across the political aisle. But he’s so far shown that appearing moderate is more important than passing moderate policies.
The governor’s choice
Gov. Shapiro now faces a choice. He can either fail to pass the scholarships before the June 30 budget deadline, perhaps permanently tarnishing his moderate image, or he can show the kind of leadership he promised but has yet to deliver.
The governor’s political calculus is clear. He leads a swing state, perhaps the most important swing state in America. His best shot at higher office will come in 2028. Before that, he must win re-election in 2026.
Surviving that long requires keeping the political middle happy without simultaneously angering progressives. That’s a hard line to walk, but he has already shown how he prefers to navigate it. The short version: Look in a moderate direction while moving to the left.
Consider what happened when school choice came up last year. The governor forged a deal with Senate Republicans to create a $100 million program — Lifeline Scholarships — for low-income kids in the state’s worst schools. But after the House and Senate passed the bill, he vetoed his own victory. He claimed it was necessary to prevent a budget “impasse,” yet in reality, it let him please everyone while preserving his moderate persona.
Read More
He’s been able to continue pandering to the 77% of Pennsylvanians who support the scholarships, calling school choice “unfinished business.” But he’s also kept progressives happy, since public schools and teachers’ unions are safe from the competition that would help students.
Playing and pleasing
Was last year’s school-choice fiasco a one-off? Hardly. On multiple occasions, Gov. Shapiro has pulled a similar stunt, playing to moderates while pleasing liberals. He’s done so twice since the start of the year.
In early May, Gov. Shapiro called on the University of Pennsylvania to disband its pro-Palestinian encampments. On the surface, that looked like a bold political move, one that would upset the leftist wing of the Democratic Party.
It therefore burnished his moderate credentials, letting him say that he stood up to the fringe to fight anti-Semitism. In short order, the camps were torn down.
But the media soon reported that Shapiro already knew Penn was going to disband the camps. He wasn’t taking a moderate stand. He was putting on a political show. He can safely tell liberal donors and activists that he didn’t do anything, while telling the broader public that he did.
Gov. Shapiro pulled a similar stunt with energy in March. He proposed a cap-and-trade plan that he billed as good for the environment and the economy alike. The plan would replace his predecessor’s Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, an aggressive effort that would cost Pennsylvanians at least $800 million while raising electric bills by 30%. For middle-of-the-road voters, the cap-and-trade plan looks much better.
But the governor knows his plan will die in the state legislature. Instead of fighting for it, he’s quietly asking the state Supreme Court to uphold the very Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative he says he wants to replace.
Environmentalists can feel confident their preferred plan is secure, even as everyday Pennsylvanians feel like the governor is fighting to repeal it for the sake of their financial and job security.
Will school choice play out differently? Gov. Shapiro must prove it. He’s saying many of the right things about the need to empower kids, especially those who attend truly awful schools — no small thing for a Democrat with national ambitions.
True leadership
But the governor hasn’t used his bully pulpit to pressure his fellow Democrats in the legislature. That’s what leadership would look like: Twisting your own party’s arms and spending political capital. It’s the best way to get votes to pass school choice before the June 30 budget deadline.
The worst thing Gov. Shapiro can do is repeat last year’s failure. It would cement a new image, one of someone who promises moderate change, while winking at progressives that he doesn’t really mean it.
Surely that’s not the persona Pennsylvania’s governor wants, especially as he looks to the national stage. Passing Lifeline Scholarships may be Josh Shapiro’s last chance to prove he’s a true moderate.
Charles Mitchell is president and CEO of the Commonwealth Foundation. His previous article was “You believe in school choice, governor. Act on it.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.