HARRISBURG — A day after the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania accused state leaders in court of failing to adequately fund public defender’s offices, the top official at the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania (CCAP) said funding for 2024-25 should be 50% higher than what Gov. Josh Shapiro has proposed.

The $7.5 million in the current budget is the first-ever funding of indigent defense within the state spending plan, and Mr. Shapiro has proposed a boost to $10 million for next year. Asked to comment on the ACLU’s lawsuit against Mr. Shapiro and top state lawmakers, CCAP Executive Director Lisa Schaefer said the figure for next year should be $15 million.

“Counties appreciate the dedicated state funding that was provided this fiscal year to support indigent services that have until now been forced to be wholly supported by county property tax dollars,” Ms. Schaefer said. But the figure for next year should be $15 million, she said.

“That $7.5 million should be considered a first step,” she said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Schaefer did not comment directly on the allegations in the lawsuit filed in Commonwealth Court against Mr. Shapiro, Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland County, and House Speaker Joanna McClinton, D-Philadelphia. The ACLU filed the suit on behalf of 17 people facing criminal charges in various courts around the state, including five in Fayette County.

The suit said both the state and federal constitutions guarantee the right to “assistance of counsel” for those accused of crimes, and that means “effective counsel.” The lack of funding has violated those rights, the plaintiffs said, and left more than 100,000 Pennsylvanians who cannot afford lawyers without effective counsel each year.

The lawsuit seeks, among other things, a declaration that the state “not discriminate against indigent defendants” by providing them with defense services whose funding depends on which county their case is brought in.

Outside of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania is tied with Mississippi for the worst funded public defender system on a per capita basis, according to Mike Lee, executive director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania. “Gov. Shapiro’s budget allocation of $7.5 million is better than zero. But it is nowhere near the amount necessary to solve this crisis,” Mr. Lee said.

A spokesperson for Mr. Shapiro, Manuel Bonder, said the governor has been saying for years that a lack of funding for public defenders “has created unacceptable inequities in our legal system.” On the state funding level, Mr. Bonder said, the governor knows there is a long way to go.

Advertise with us

The governor, Mr. Bonder said, has made it clear every state resident deserves fair and equal treatment under the law. He said the governor is reviewing the ACLU complaint.

A spokesperson for Ms. McClinton, Nicole Reigelman, said the top Democrat in the House started her career as a public defender and “has been an outspoken champion of legislation to improve access to legal counsel for indigent clients.” Ms. McClinton celebrated, Ms. Reigelman said, when the state budget finally included money for indigent defense.

Erica Wright, a spokesperson for Sen. Ward, a Republican, said she had not yet seen the lawsuit.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com