Human flourishing is a hot subject. Harvard University, Johns Hopkins University, the University of Notre Dame — these are just some of the universities hosting centers and institutes dedicated to inquiring into the nature of human well-being and happiness. The pages of op-eds and grant applications are similarly filled with inquiries into human flourishing.
What contribution to human flourishing does good medicine make?
Two ideas of medicine
We cannot answer the question about the relationship of medicine to human well-being unless we also can answer the question: what is medicine? There are two broad understandings and they give contrasting answers for many parts of the practice of medicine.
This question seems simple and straightforward to answer: surely medicine is for the sake of human health, and good medicine is both motivated by concern for a patient’s health, and shaped by the physician’s expertise in the ways of the human body.
And health seems, equally obviously, an important, even essential aspect of human flourishing. If you are sick or suffering from a health-related impairment, you are just not as well off as you could be.
That is a plausible account of both health and one dimension of human well-being. It makes sense of what we know.
Read More
It is an account that can give rise to important norms of medical morality. For health care professionals, those norms include: do not act contrary to a patient’s health; do not let your concerns for your patients’ health be subverted by prejudice, apathy, or self-interest; give to your pursuit of professional medical practice the attention, time, and energy needed to shape your life as a person devoted to excellence in health care.
With my colleague Farr Curlin, a physician at Duke University, I have argued that this conception of medicine and its morality, which we call “the Way of Medicine,” should guide medical practice. Medical professionals must act in accordance with the norms of the Way for their medical practice to be truly congruent with human well-being and happiness.
The contrasting model
But this vision of medicine finds competition in an approach that we call “the Provider of Services Model.” This model assumes that medicine comprises a set of technical skills that professionals are to use primarily in service of a patient’s autonomously chosen preferences, even if those preferences are not directly in service of, or even in conflict with, human health.
The norms of the PSM are rather different than those of the Way. A medical intervention may, and increasingly often must, be pursued so long as it is effective in serving patient preference; is legal; and is freely chosen by the patient.
A practitioner of the Way might object, for example, to physician assisted suicide or euthanasia as acts that damage the primary good sought by medicine, human health. Proponents of the PSM will argue that, where such practices are legal, physicians should provide them, refer for them, or, if unwilling to do so, exit the profession.
More and more, the expectation that physicians will provide requested services is framed as a claim of right: the patient has a right to such services, and the physician has an obligation to provide them.
Of course, few physicians fit perfectly into either category. No one operating within the PSM thinks health is unimportant, and many dedicated physicians provide occasional services whose connection to health seems remote. Nevertheless, the two models of medicine provide a helpful way to understand a number of conflicts in medicine, such as those, for instance, between defenders and opponents of “conscientious objection” in medicine.
When a patient requests or demands something that a physician finds morally problematic, this is often framed as a matter of the physician’s private conscience intruding upon his or her public practice. Such physicians are told that they must leave their private moral convictions at the gate of professional practice.
Controverted interventions
But understanding medical practice from the standpoint of the Way of Medicine suggests something else: in most cases that physicians object conscientiously to some controverted intervention, it is precisely because of their commitment to human health.
Consider the obviously contentious problem of abortion. Protecting physicians from the expectation or demand that they provide or refer for abortions is protecting them from providing or referring for a service that they believe is harmful to the life and health of an unborn child. Life and health are precisely the values that good physicians commit to serve.
Understanding disagreements within medicine as conflicts between the Way of Medicine and the Provider of Services Model does not, obviously, settle those disagreements. But perhaps it helps chart a path toward sustained consideration of the relationship between medicine and human flourishing.
Christopher Tollefsen is professor of philosophy at the University of South Carolina and the author, with Farr Curlin, of “The Way of Medicine: Ethics and the Healing Profession.”
Mr. Tollefsen is giving the inaugural Bioethics, public health, and human flourishing lecture on Tuesday evening at 5:00 at the Public Health Building, Rm A115, of the University of Pittsburgh. The lecture is sponsored by the David C. Frederick Honors College and the Beatrice Institute.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.