Human flour­ish­ing is a hot sub­ject. Har­vard Univer­sity, Johns Hop­kins Univer­sity, the Univer­sity of Notre Dame — these are just some of the uni­ver­sities host­ing cen­ters and in­sti­tutes ded­i­cated to in­quir­ing into the na­ture of hu­man well-be­ing and hap­pi­ness. The pages of op-eds and grant ap­pli­ca­tions are sim­i­larly filled with in­qui­ries into hu­man flour­ish­ing.

What con­tri­bu­tion to hu­man flour­ish­ing does good med­i­cine make?

Two ideas of med­i­cine

We can­not an­swer the ques­tion about the re­la­tion­ship of med­i­cine to hu­man well-be­ing un­less we also can an­swer the ques­tion: what is med­i­cine? There are two broad un­der­stand­ings and they give con­trast­ing an­swers for many parts of the prac­tice of med­i­cine.

This ques­tion seems sim­ple and straight­for­ward to an­swer: surely med­i­cine is for the sake of hu­man health, and good med­i­cine is both mo­ti­vated by con­cern for a pa­tient’s health, and shaped by the phy­si­cian’s ex­per­tise in the ways of the hu­man body.

Advertise with us

And health seems, equally ob­vi­ously, an im­por­tant, even es­sen­tial as­pect of hu­man flour­ish­ing. If you are sick or suf­fer­ing from a health-re­lated im­pair­ment, you are just not as well off as you could be.

That is a plau­si­ble ac­count of both health and one di­men­sion of hu­man well-be­ing. It makes sense of what we know.

It is an ac­count that can give rise to im­por­tant norms of med­i­cal mo­ral­ity. For health care pro­fes­sion­als, those norms in­clude: do not act con­trary to a pa­tient’s health; do not let your con­cerns for your pa­tients’ health be sub­verted by prej­u­dice, ap­a­thy, or self-in­ter­est; give to your pur­suit of pro­fes­sional med­i­cal prac­tice the at­ten­tion, time, and en­ergy needed to shape your life as a per­son de­voted to ex­cel­lence in health care.

With my col­league Farr Curlin, a phy­si­cian at Duke Univer­sity, I have ar­gued that this con­cep­tion of med­i­cine and its mo­ral­ity, which we call “the Way of Med­i­cine,” should guide med­i­cal prac­tice. Med­i­cal pro­fes­sion­als must act in ac­cor­dance with the norms of the Way for their med­i­cal prac­tice to be truly con­gru­ent with hu­man well-be­ing and hap­pi­ness.

The con­trast­ing model

But this vi­sion of med­i­cine finds com­pe­ti­tion in an ap­proach that we call “the Pro­vider of Ser­vices Model.” This model as­sumes that med­i­cine com­prises a set of tech­ni­cal skills that pro­fes­sion­als are to use pri­mar­ily in ser­vice of a pa­tient’s au­ton­o­mously cho­sen pref­er­ences, even if those pref­er­ences are not di­rectly in ser­vice of, or even in con­flict with, hu­man health.

Advertise with us

The norms of the PSM are rather dif­fer­ent than those of the Way. A med­i­cal in­ter­ven­tion may, and in­creas­ingly of­ten must, be pur­sued so long as it is ef­fec­tive in serv­ing pa­tient pref­er­ence; is le­gal; and is freely cho­sen by the pa­tient.

A prac­ti­tioner of the Way might ob­ject, for ex­am­ple, to phy­si­cian as­sisted sui­cide or eu­tha­na­sia as acts that dam­age the pri­mary good sought by med­i­cine, hu­man health. Pro­po­nents of the PSM will ar­gue that, where such prac­tices are le­gal, phy­si­cians should pro­vide them, re­fer for them, or, if un­will­ing to do so, exit the pro­fes­sion.

More and more, the ex­pec­ta­tion that phy­si­cians will pro­vide re­quested ser­vices is framed as a claim of right: the pa­tient has a right to such ser­vices, and the phy­si­cian has an ob­li­ga­tion to pro­vide them.

Of course, few phy­si­cians fit per­fectly into ei­ther cat­e­gory. No one op­er­at­ing within the PSM thinks health is un­im­por­tant, and many ded­i­cated phy­si­cians pro­vide oc­ca­sional ser­vices whose con­nec­tion to health seems re­mote. Ne­ver­the­less, the two mod­els of med­i­cine pro­vide a help­ful way to un­der­stand a num­ber of con­flicts in med­i­cine, such as those, for in­stance, be­tween de­fend­ers and op­po­nents of “con­sci­en­tious ob­jec­tion” in med­i­cine.

When a pa­tient re­quests or de­mands some­thing that a phy­si­cian finds mor­ally prob­lem­atic, this is of­ten framed as a mat­ter of the phy­si­cian’s pri­vate con­science in­trud­ing upon his or her pub­lic prac­tice. Such phy­si­cians are told that they must leave their pri­vate moral con­vic­tions at the gate of pro­fes­sional prac­tice.

Advertise with us

Con­tro­verted in­ter­ven­tions

But un­der­stand­ing med­i­cal prac­tice from the stand­point of the Way of Med­i­cine sug­gests some­thing else: in most cases that phy­si­cians ob­ject con­sci­en­tiously to some con­tro­verted in­ter­ven­tion, it is pre­cisely be­cause of their com­mit­ment to hu­man health.

Con­sider the ob­vi­ously con­ten­tious prob­lem of abor­tion. Pro­tect­ing phy­si­cians from the ex­pec­ta­tion or de­mand that they pro­vide or re­fer for abor­tions is pro­tect­ing them from pro­vid­ing or re­fer­ring for a ser­vice that they be­lieve is harm­ful to the life and health of an un­born child. Life and health are pre­cisely the val­ues that good phy­si­cians com­mit to serve.

Under­stand­ing dis­agree­ments within med­i­cine as con­flicts be­tween the Way of Med­i­cine and the Pro­vider of Ser­vices Model does not, ob­vi­ously, set­tle those dis­agree­ments. But per­haps it helps chart a path to­ward sus­tained con­sid­er­ation of the re­la­tion­ship be­tween med­i­cine and hu­man flour­ish­ing.

Christopher Tollefsen is professor of philosophy at the University of South Carolina and the author, with Farr Curlin, of “The Way of Medicine: Ethics and the Healing Profession.”

Mr. Tollefsen is giving the inaugural Bioethics, public health, and human flourishing lecture on Tuesday evening at 5:00 at the Public Health Building, Rm A115, of the University of Pittsburgh. The lecture is sponsored by the David C. Frederick Honors College and the Beatrice Institute.