Respiratory syncytial virus, or RSV, is a nasty bug. It’s the leading cause of hospitalizations among American infants and results in thousands of deaths among the elderly each year. The Food and Drug Administration-approved vaccines for adults over 60, antibodies for babies and toddlers, and a vaccine for pregnant individuals to protect newborns, are a medical breakthrough.
But this breakthrough has a history, one tangled up in questions of medical ethics and racial exploitation.
Experimenting on children
A fascinating report published this week in Undark, a nonprofit digital magazine affiliated with MIT, found that in the 1960s, some of the first and youngest subjects to receive experimental shots in early attempts to develop RSV vaccines, were Black and poor children, some in foster care.
And though questions remain about what parents knew, “archival documents housed at the N.I.H. suggest that parents did not give informed consent — or in some cases, any consent at all — for their children to receive the largely untested shot.”
It appears that for some of those children, rather than offering protection from the virus, an early experimental vaccine worsened it. Two Black children in the trial died, just one day apart, as the new year dawned in 1967, both in the same Washington hospital.
Read More
The two boys
One of them was 16-month-old Victor Marcellus King. As his big brother, Darius King, who was 5 years old at the time, recently told me, he thought his brother died of pneumonia, and he blamed his stepfather, who had taken the child outside in the cold to show him off to friends.
That impression remained until Undark’s Michael Schulson contacted him and told him that Victor’s death was most likely caused by an experimental RSV vaccine. But that revelation came too late for a reconciliation — his stepfather died last year. Of his brother, who died so young, Darius King said, “My life would have turned out totally different if he had been a part of it.”
The other boy who died was 14-month-old Ross Otto Hambrick. I spoke to his sister, Sharlette Hambrick, who was also 5 at the time. She doesn’t remember her brother getting sick, or even his funeral. But, she said, “What I do remember vividly was the change in my mother.” She said her mom had been funny and outgoing, but after Ross’ death she became “super, super, super religious” and “she barely let us out of her sight.”
Hambrick said that when she was made aware that her brother’s death was most likely caused by the same experimental vaccine, her first reaction was anger. When she realized how helpful the new FDA-approved vaccine would be, part of her was happy. Still, her anger didn’t subside.
Both siblings of the two boys expressed these complex feelings, but King also expressed the sorrowful resignation of a people — Black people — who have so often been mistreated, and he reflected on our country’s checkered history, including when it comes to medical ethics.
“That was the way America was,” he said, adding that the children who were given the experimental vaccine “were probably thought of as disposable.”
Disposable children
Indeed, Schulson, who became interested in RSV vaccine research last year after his own son was hospitalized with the virus, told me that what surprised him most during his work on the story was the relative lack of surprise that family members expressed to him when they learned about how an experimental vaccine most likely played a role in how two children died.
That lack of surprise is the scar tissue that Black Americans have built up — the knowledge that the worst is always possible. The mind and spirit continually make space for it, forever hoping, but preparing contingencies for hope’s inevitable betrayal.
We have learned this from history: Undark’s reporting about Victor and Ross calls to mind infamous cases of racism in the U.S. medical establishment, such as the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, which treated Black people as disposable, and Henrietta Lacks, who was treated as dehumanized tissue.
Tissue samples were harvested from the boys’ dead bodies, Undark reports. Not only did researchers study the tissue samples, finding that the vaccine fatally altered the boys’ immune response, but “Over five decades, scientists publish dozens of papers drawing on clinical data of the boys who died.” In light of that, it’s hard not to think of the deaths of those boys as part of the journey that led to the breakthrough of today’s vaccines.
But as is often the case, the question comes down to the issues of justice, reparations and restoration: What are the families of the children involved in those experiments, particularly the families of Victor and Ross, now owed?
The issue of justice
Undark reported that Victor’s family members recall the family receiving a modest payment after his death: “funeral expenses, plus $1,000 — around $9,000 today, adjusting for inflation.”
This year alone, sales of the new RSV vaccines are expected to be in the billions of dollars. How should the country make this right with these families? And how many more tragic and complicated stories are out there waiting to be discovered and told? As Schulson said, “I’m sure there are many more stories just like this one.”
Charles M. Blow is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “Ron DeSantis’ Christian Nationalism lies about Black history.” He’s a member of the Undark advisory board.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.