When our fam­ily moved back to Pitts­burgh from Ger­many 35 years ago this fall, we chose to set­tle in Mt. Leb­a­non. We chose Lebo for the same rea­son as many par­ents with young kids: the schools.

Our Foster el­e­men­tary school epit­o­mized safety and sen­si­bil­ity. It was like liv­ing in May­berry. Kids walked to school (they still do) and came home for lunch.

While Foster School’s motto (“I will al­ways be kind, cour­te­ous and re­spect­ful”) seems as dis­tant as a gal­axy far, far away, I still re­call that gal­axy fondly. The com­mu­nity sup­port that Foster’s prin­ci­pal back then (“Saint Bar­bara” Float) mar­shaled was real and im­pres­sive. One proj­ect demon­strat­ing that was when res­i­dents pro­vided money and mus­cle to re­build the school’s aging play­ground.

Sadly, con­sen­sus and co­op­er­a­tion are no lon­ger val­ued in the so­ci­ety we in­habit. Such val­ues have been re­placed by to­day’s cul­tural land­mines of di­vi­sion and griev­ance. Even in a place like Mt. Leb­a­non. Or per­haps I should say, es­pe­cially now in a place like Lebo.

Advertise with us

A pa­ren­tal right

Some would con­tend that the law­suit filed in fed­eral court against the school dis­trict two years ago is an­other sign­post of di­vi­sion and griev­ance. Per­haps it is.

But shouldn’t par­ents have the le­gal right (and moral lat­i­tude) to ob­ject when their six- and seven-year-old chil­dren are be­ing taught about gen­der ide­ol­ogy? Espe­cially when such in­struc­tion is not part of the dis­trict’s own pub­lished el­e­men­tary cur­ric­u­lum?

The fed­eral judge over­see­ing the case thinks so. Twice the dis­trict has sought to dis­miss the com­plaint, along with all pa­ren­tal rights. And twice the judge has said, there is enough here for a jury to con­sider. The case is ex­pected to go to trial this fall, un­less the plain­tiffs’ pe­ti­tion for sum­mary judg­ment is granted be­fore.

Many have por­trayed the ac­tions of the teacher who trig­gered the law­suit as be­nign, but that is not the case. The court record tells a far dif­fer­ent story.

Many Mt. Leb­a­non teach­ers and ad­min­is­tra­tors have tes­ti­fied, un­der oath in depo­si­tions, on be­half of the plain­tiffs — three Lebo moms who chal­lenged what hap­pened in the 2021-22 school year to their chil­dren. The moms have paid a steep price for their cour­age.

Advertise with us

They’ve been called big­ots and worse at school board meet­ings, while the teacher was cel­e­brated as a cham­pion against big­otry rather than be­ing rep­ri­manded.

Her in­struc­tion in­cluded tell­ing stu­dents that “when chil­dren are born, par­ents make a guess whether they’re a boy or a girl. Some­times par­ents are wrong.” Par­ents were not in­formed of the in­struc­tion be­fore­hand nor were they given any no­tice al­low­ing them to opt out of it, both in­con­sis­tent with long-stand­ing dis­trict prac­tices and pol­i­cies.

Selec­tive opt-outs

Ac­cord­ing to the co­pi­ous court record, the dis­trict per­mits pa­ren­tal opt outs for a wide va­ri­ety of sub­jects. They in­clude an as­sem­bly in­volv­ing a ther­apy dog; dis­sec­tion of an­i­mals in bi­ol­ogy class; and even the Scripps Spelling Bee.

Yet pa­ren­tal no­ti­fi­ca­tion is not prac­ticed for gen­der in­struc­tion among first grad­ers, even though it’s not part of the pub­lished el­e­men­tary cur­ric­u­lum. It bog­gles the mind.

In other words, re­li­gious opt-out rights in the dis­trict are not ac­corded the same pro­tec­tion granted to those who ob­ject to their chil­dren par­tic­i­pat­ing in a spelling bee!

Advertise with us

The Mt. Leb­a­non School board has cho­sen to sup­port a rad­i­cal po­si­tion in de­fend­ing the teacher. The law­suit has es­tab­lished that the dis­trict per­mits out-opts for sex ed­u­ca­tion among mid­dle and high school­ers. In ad­di­tion, 62% of el­e­men­tary-school teach­ers don’t be­lieve gen­der iden­tity should be taught in school, ac­cord­ing to a new Pew Re­search Center poll.

But com­mon sense is un­com­mon among those lead­ing the dis­trict. They have sided with ac­tiv­ists who as­sert that per­mit­ting opt-outs on any grounds is equiv­a­lent to sanc­tion­ing a hate crime. The goal, as peo­ple have claimed in var­i­ous ways, is to cul­ti­vate par­ents who are “less hate­ful.”

In terms of how this in­ter­sects with my own fam­ily, the dis­trict’s re­fusal to fol­low its pol­i­cies is the main rea­son my seven-year-old grand­son at­tends our church acad­emy rather than Foster, where his par­ents re­side. It’s a sad com­men­tary on mod­ern times that my daugh­ter (and her hus­band, both reg­is­tered Dem­o­crats) can­not in good con­science send their son to the same Foster School she at­tended three de­cades ago.

A bad idea

I know these sit­u­a­tions are fraught with par­ti­san­ship and con­flict. Mod­ern sen­si­bil­i­ties have made it so. But is the world so con­fused that we can­not see the ob­vi­ous: that sex­u­al­iz­ing chil­dren at the mere age of six or seven is an in­dis­put­ably bad idea? Espe­cially when it’s be­ing done against par­ents’ wishes?

The old Foster School motto ap­plies. Let’s be kind, cour­te­ous and re­spect­ful to­ward ev­ery­one.

Tho­mas O’Boyle (to­moboyle107@gmail.com) is a for­mer Post-Ga­zette ed­i­tor and cur­rent com­mu­ni­ca­tions di­rec­tor for Bev­erly Heights Church in Mt. Leb­a­non, where he re­sides.