Two very stupid things happened at last Sunday’s Academy Awards show. One was also shocking. The other was not.
Chris Rock’s “G.I. Jane” joke about Jada Pinkett Smith’s shaved head was either clueless or mean, but all it deserved was the eye roll she gave it. When her husband, Will Smith, strode to the stage and slapped Mr. Rock, he shocked the world and upended decades of accumulated goodwill.
The other very stupid thing at the Oscars was the trio of female hosts taking aim at Florida’s so-called “Don’t Say Gay” bill.
“For you people in Florida, we’re gonna have a gay night,” proclaimed comedian Wanda Sykes, whose co-hosts Amy Schumer and Regina Hall joined her in chanting “gay, gay, gay” to plenty of audience laughter and applause.
This was not shocking at all. I expect Oscar hosts to attempt political humor, and I expect it to take aim at that week’s news-making conservative, libertarian or moderate targets. That’s what “limousine leftists” do.
Setting up a straw man is a debater’s — or ideologue’s — easiest, most obviously dishonest tactic. You greatly distort an opponent’s argument or actions and attack the distortion, thereby making your opponent seem extreme and forcing her to respond from a weakened position.
That’s what opponents of Florida’s “Parental Rights in Education” bill, HB 1557, did when they dubbed it the “Don’t Say Gay” bill.
The legislation, at first reading, strikes me as occasionally vague, which could create unforeseen difficulties, but it does establish important territory. It affirms parents’ rights to guide their children’s education, at a time when those rights are in dispute all over the country.
For several years now, in school districts from California to Utah, Illinois to New York, parents have been protesting what they see as age-inappropriate and ideologically driven curriculum on such basic matters as sexuality, gender and race.
These are not rare, isolated problems. The protests are not limited to religious rubes in red states, as some would have us think.
Parents at Manhattan’s posh Dalton School (annual tuition, $55,000) hit the roof last year when they learned first-graders were being shown cartoons to help them understand erections and masturbation. One parent pointed out that Dalton was teaching 6-year-olds about “consent” without getting the parents’ consent.
Aggression is another tactic of ideological warfare, as the advantage usually goes to the aggressor. Advocates introduce explicit sex-ed materials or racist “anti-racism” curricula and then try to shame parents for objecting. The only correct response to such bullies is to refuse to back down.
If you do even minimal online research on sex education, you are likely to be shocked by the detail that some states or districts deem “healthy” in the classroom setting.
If you are not shocked, well, do you alone get to decide what’s best for other people’s children? Isn’t this an important enough part of life that we should try to reach a consensus — openly, without playing political games?
The Florida bill, which Gov. Ron DeSantis signed last Monday, is about much more than sex ed, but the portion that earned its nickname states: “Classroom instruction by school personnel or third parties on sexual orientation or gender identity may not occur in kindergarten through grade 3 or in a manner that is not age appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students in accordance with state standards.”
Its clear intent is to protect innocence and to allow children to develop at their own speed, without intrusion. Why would very young children need instruction on gender identity, sexual orientation or any sexual activity at all?
When such issues become appropriate is when kids raise them. If they do so in the classroom, creating an awkward situation for the teacher, the solution is not difficult. The teacher can reply, “That’s outside our curriculum — You should ask your parents.” Or, “Would you like to talk privately with the school nurse or counselor?”
Human sexuality is more complicated than an Oscar host’s lame one-liner or any protest group’s chant. It is also too precious to be decided by strangers.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.