There are transgender and gender non-conforming kids in Mt. Lebanon — just as there are in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and all around the country. Lebo Pride, a nonprofit organization dedicated to bringing queer and gender-diverse education to their community, knows this well, as they work directly with these kids — most of whom receive their education in the Mt. Lebanon School District.

The same Mt. Lebanon School District that is almost two years into defending itself from a lawsuit “alleging misconduct by their children’s first-grade teacher and claiming the children were taught about several social issues involving gender in a manner that violated district policy and precedent,” as reported by the Post-Gazette in June 2022.

They exist

The teacher in question, Megan Williams, “provided ‘direct classroom instruction’ about gender dysphoria and transgender transitioning on March 31, the International Transgender Day of Visibility.”

A handful of parents were upset, wanting the ability to let their children “opt-out” from materials related to gender and sexuality. Those parents wanted more control over how their children were exposed to these topics.

Advertise with us

This all sounds fine on the surface — parents wanting to reserve tough discussions about complicated subjects for their homes. But the truth is that transgender and gender non-conforming people exist in the world. We cannot opt-out from seeing them or their expressions of self. To “opt-out” is to pretend they don’t exist.

Kids have eyes and questions about gender. They should be informed in an age-appropriate way about the kinds of people they are encountering in the world. And if our schools are tasked with making sure that we are educated, then our schools should absolutely provide clarifications on how to best interact with our peers.

There are transgender and gender non-conforming people of every age. Some people don’t feel safe enough to express their true selves until late in life, and others do so as children.

Transitioning is never easy, and understanding the spectrum of gender can allow people on the other side to do better with their cavalier assumptions. Most people who have met a transgender or non-binary person emerge more tolerant, less hateful and more empathetic for it.

Some folks will never see it differently. I get that. There are still holdovers who believe that the desegregation of schools was a mistake. But history has proven them wrong. Knowing how to interact with people of different backgrounds and identities only makes us culturally richer — regardless of what your privately held beliefs may be.

Advertise with us

“It feels sometimes like people think they can pretend my child doesn’t exist,” Michelle (who preferred not to use her last name) told me. “But she does exist, and one day, she might be your doctor, your teacher or your pastor. How will they interact then? Kids, and adults, should know that not everyone exists in the binary.”

Alexis Sheehan, another parent in the Mt. Lebanon school district, thinks it’s important for kids to be able to talk about what they see. “It’s not a ‘one time a year’ conversation,” she said. “It’s not only when they turn a certain age — kids have always encountered the world around them.”

“If a parent wanted to say ‘we believe something different in our house,’ and I think they honestly have the right to do that,” she continued, “they could — but it’s 2024 and we know because of science and psychology what produces the best outcomes for LGBTQ+ kids, which is an affirming stance from the adults in their lives.”

Diverse and inclusive

From talking with Mt. Lebanon parents, including Ms. Sheehan, Michelle and several others, it’s clear that the parents believe in their school district, school board and especially in their teachers. Most of the parents I found trust educators to do their jobs — and in Mt. Lebanon, that means preparing kids for a diverse and inclusive world.

Last week, Lebo Pride filed an amicus brief supporting the efforts of the district and Ms. Williams. The document included affidavits from parents, including Asta Kill. Ms. Kill’s words are quite affecting, as she documents raising a cis-gendered straight child as a trans person. She also points out that an effective education doesn’t have to be too complicated.

Advertise with us

“In early elementary school, many students noticed that my gender identity was not exactly the same as many of the other parents. One question I got from my kiddo’s classmates early on was ‘Are you a boy or a girl?’ I usually said that I am a girl but was born with a boy body. That was all it took most of the time for them to happily continue on their day and never ask that question again.”

The research is clear. Education and visibility lessen hate crimes. Education and visibility dispel ignorance. Education and visibility work.

To acknowledge the existence of trans and non-binary folk isn’t to “promote” them, the same way as acknowledging that some people are double-jointed isn’t promoting them. They simply are — it cannot be denied. The lawsuit seeks to do just that: deny reality. But the stakes couldn’t be higher.

“To deny their existence and to say that their existence is something that you can choose to recognize or not — that’s a way of eliminating them. And in the school context, the research is clear that [denying the existence of trans kids] has a very, very detrimental effect on the health of those students,” said Dan Vitek from the Community Justice Project.

Her life matters

“Parental rights are important,” he continued, “but this isn’t going into their homes; this is a curriculum at public school that is designed to benefit the student body as a whole — and it’s not forcing anyone to believe any particular thing. It’s just helping acknowledge everyone’s existence.”

Advertise with us

For Michelle, her child’s life matters more than the discomfort of others.

“My daughter attempted suicide when we lived in Texas. Part of the reason we moved to Mt. Lebanon, to the Pittsburgh area, is that we were told good people lived here, people who would treat her like a person.”

“This lawsuit depresses me as much as the people fighting it hearten me. I just don’t understand: Why can’t people just let her, and all the kids like her, simply exist?”

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Find her on X @zadri.