Attracting foreign students to U.S. universities is a strategic advantage and a solid “America First” policy, yet it remains controversial” with many pushing back against immigration and demanding sharp limits to the numbers of immigrants the United States allow into the country — including students.
As a postdoctoral researcher at Carnegie Mellon University, I have witnessed firsthand how vital these students are to the well-being of our system of higher education and innovation ecosystem, as well as to the nation’s economy and global standing.
Fallacies about foreign students
Despite their clear benefits to the United States, several key misconceptions have led some in Washington to seek limitations on foreign students’ ability to study in the United States. I aim to address and dispel these fallacies here.
Foreign students do not steal admissions slots from U.S. students. In reality, they pay on average higher tuition payments that form a bedrock of our universities’ financial stability. Even a small reduction in the number of foreign students would require substantive cuts to U.S. university budgets and a higher tuition burden for American students.
Exposing American students to foreign ideas and cultures helps them. Studying with students from other countries helps American students learn and grow in a way they will not otherwise.
Read More
It does not pull them away from American values, but instead is crucial in preparing them to thrive in the global economy. A free exchange of diverse opinions and perspectives stimulates critical thinking and problem solving abilities. Likewise, international experience and cultural competence greatly aids American competitiveness in the global economy.
Increasing competition
Foreign students who remain in the U.S. do not steal American jobs. Instead, they greatly improve America’s technological competitiveness by filling critical STEM roles, and this competitiveness creates a huge number of jobs built around the technology ecosystem. According to a report by NAFSA, an association of international educators, international students added $42 billion to the US economy in the 2019-2020 academic year, supporting over 458,000 jobs.
It is easy to see why. America’s thriving tech economy simply could not exist without access to the global workforce attracted by American Universities, and these tech firms create a giant web of peripheral jobs and economic activity. Likewise, many of America’s most impactful entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, were attracted to the U.S. by the opportunity to study at a prestigious American university.
Foreign students who return home have not stolen an American education. They help spread American soft power and ideas. Education is a powerful tool for soft power. It creates a positive image of the US and its values. Graduates who have studied in the US often become influential leaders, policymakers and entrepreneurs in their home countries. Their positive view of the U.S. is a powerful geopolitical and economic tool we have come to rely heavily upon.
Foreign students are essential to making American universities a crucial catalyst for technological innovation. Without foreign students working in American labs and engaging in serious research, as well as supporting our institutions financially, none of this would be possible.
The Association of University Technology Managers reported that technologies developed at U.S. Universities and licensed to American companies increased U.S. industry gross output by up to $1.9 trillion and U.S. GPD by up to $1 trillion between 1996 and 2020. These innovations also directly led to the creation of 6.5 million jobs. Losing this vital economic engine would be catastrophic for our economy.
America first
Foreign university students provide America with a multifaceted economic benefit, contributing to education, research, local economies, job creation, innovation, and global connectivity. Their impact extends far beyond the campus, playing a crucial role in shaping a vibrant and globally engaged U.S. economy. Allowing them to study here is an America first policy.
Nathan Zavanelli is a postdoctoral research associate in the Soft Machines Lab at Carnegie Mellon University.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.