Two children and their mother drowned on the American side of the Rio Grande last week. This is a fact. It cannot be disputed. What can be disputed are the reasons why.

One might say they died because of bureaucracy and jurisdiction. Mexican authorities alerted the Border Patrol that two children and their mother were “in distress” close to a boat ramp. When Border Patrol raced to help them, they were denied access to the park in question by members of the Texas military, who claimed jurisdiction of the area. No one made it in time.

Another might say the family died because they broke the law. Victerma de la Sancha Cerros and her children, Yorlei Rubi, 10, and Jonathan Agustín Briones de la Sancha, 8, drowned crossing the Rio Grande illegally, choosing to ford the river rather than be turned away at an official checkpoint and forced to stay in Mexico.

Their deaths are tragedies. No one wanted their deaths. Not even Texas governor Greg Abbott, though he speaks about undocumented immigrants in a way bound to encourage some to violence against them.

Advertise with us

Murder on the border

Last Thursday, on a conservative radio show, Abbott talked as if he’d be fine killing immigrants coming from the Mexican side of the border, if it weren’t for the federal government: "The only thing that we are not doing is we're not shooting people who come across the border — because, of course, the Biden administration would charge us with murder," he told Dana Loesch, NRA spokesperson.

The next day, he claimed that the media exaggerated his words. "I was asked to point out where the line is drawn about what would be illegal and I pointed out something that is obviously illegal.” But the words themselves sounded as if the only thing preventing the state of Texas from killing people are the potential federal charges — not morality, Christian values or ethics.

The implication is clear: an immigrant crossing the border has no worth in the eyes of the Texas governor. And he is not alone in this. Thousands of posts on social media desire worse for undocumented immigrants.

Their reasons (though not their solutions) seem valid at first: Immigrants are currently being blamed for opioid trafficking, human trafficking and increases in violent crime. But quick research reveals that none of these are true.

American citizens crossing the border are the ones trafficking fentanyl, American citizens are the ones exploiting people and engaging in human trafficking and American citizens are twice as likely to commit violent crimes than undocumented immigrants. But still, the narratives persist, and it’s hard to convince anyone, even with facts in hand, that their claims about undocumented migrants are false.

Advertise with us

Huddled masses

In 1883, Emma Lazarus wrote “The New Colossus,” a sonnet whose ending is almost as famous as the Statue of Liberty on which it’s displayed: "Give me your tired, your poor, / Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, / The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. / Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, / I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"

But only 46 years after those words were written, and 20 after they were displayed on the Statue of Liberty, we closed our border to those huddled masses yearning to breathe free. In 1929, Coleman Livingston Blease, who the History Channel calls “a white supremacist senator,” helped pass a law that criminalized “improper entry to the United States,” specifically focused on the southern border.

Before this, people just crossed. We wanted the “tired,” “wretched” and “homeless” to labor in empty states like Texas. Now, we discuss whether or not these countries are “sending their best people.”

The people fleeing are exactly the ones Emma Lazarus described. As places like Ukraine, Palestine, Yemen, Venezuela, Ecuador and a host of others fall to violence, more and more families will attempt to enter our country.

And many of these families will have young children. Which means that mothers and fathers like Victerma de la Sancha Cerros will continue taking dangerous risks to get them across.

Advertise with us

They’re coming to America

Whether we like it or not, the people are coming here. We can lie about them. We can criminalize them. We can let them drown. We can shoot them. But they won’t stop coming.

Can we do better? Can we be more humane? Can we be the nation that Emma Lazarus wrote about with such hope? Or are we content to watch people die for committing the crime of wanting something better for themselves?

We need to fix the border. But we need to do it in a way that expresses the values of our country, the beliefs and aspirations that define us as a nation, of kindness, generosity, openness, welcome.

The promise of the Statue of Liberty has to mean something. We should lift our lamps beside the golden door, as beacons to those coming here to work hard and start anew.

Or we could become the opposite, letting thousands die as we look away, huddled in our indifference against the masses.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “What do we make of the moon?”.