Does our politics drive our culture or our culture our politics? It’s culture that mostly defines us. But sometimes politics can move culture.
The great civil rights legislation of the 1960s was politics on a high professional level. It changed the culture. The civil rights movement was politics on a high moral level. It profoundly changed the culture.
The Supreme Court of the 1960s believed law could change culture. The Supreme Court of today believes the same thing. I’m not sure that is a proper use of the law. But I am sure that our popular culture today is unhealthy and I am absolutely sure that our politics is.
Broken politics
Go to almost any movie theater and watch the previews. They are full of violence and greed — the veneration of violence and greed. How about middlebrow and high culture? Both are better. People still read books and take serious music seriously.
Many Americans are seekers — be it through yoga classes, adult higher education, or religion. The success of the film “Jesus Revolution” (a surprise hit) is hopeful.
Read More
But our politics is broken. When Congress not only cannot deal with our massive debt, but cannot even pass a budget, we have more than dysfunction. We have total breakdown. The budget is their job.
We elect legislators who do not legislate. Imagine a carpenter who cannot hammer a nail; a doctor who cannot diagnose; a teacher who cannot teach. Well, you say, there is a fair amount of that sort of professional failure in our society. But it's actually worse than that.
A powerful faction in the U.S. House is not just incapable of passing a budget, they want to prevent others from trying to do so. “Rip off the bandaid,” they say. This really means: Nihilism for all. Wreck. Tear down. Repeat. They seek to do politically and systemically what the January 6 rioters sought to do physically.
Thus, some of our congresspersons are like demolition men posing as carpenters; doctors who prescribe poison; teachers who teach falsehood and fear. Yes, we are talking, partly, about incompetence. But also about malice and recklessness.
Back to the center
So, how can we move our politics back to center? How can our politics move the culture toward decency? Three thoughts, in no way intended as comprehensive:
First, we must restore respect for work and the dignity of work. It’s hard to get things done, and done well, in America today. We need people in the trades. We need to train people to make and fix things and not just answer phones or provide services they cannot or will not provide. We need more plumbers, mechanics and electricians and fewer business majors and MBAs.
We need to have a minimal threshold, or platform, for income for all, established by a higher minimum wage and transfer payments. When an autoworker cannot afford to buy the car he makes, our economy is disordered.
When people in the hospitality business — restaurants, grocery stores, hotels — work 50 or 60 hours a week and cannot afford braces for their kids, because they have no benefits, we have an economy that is as irrational as it is unjust.
If we restore pride in work, it will change our politics, starting with Congress.
Second, we need a major push for civic education. We have produced three generations now — from the boomers to the Gen Zers — who know almost nothing about the founding principles of the country (American political thought). They know even less about the structures and functions of our democracy.
No surprise then, when we elect people to govern us who do not know where they are when they get to work. They do not know their duty.
Finally, we have to challenge the constant diet of blather and bad faith that our politicians and most of our media feed us. Their talk is as empty as it is endless.
Feinstein vs. the yahoos
I find it hard to take all the crocodile tears for the late Sen. Dianne Feinstein. For months the political ghouls in her party and on our screens have been telling her to get out of the way. Well, she finally did. But I am glad she would not resign and hung in until the end: She was a professional politician proud of her craft; one who wanted to work until her last day on earth.
Contrast this with the yahoos in the House who pass no legislation and do no oversight. Or the ex-president who promised he would end doublespeak but quadrupled it. He lately opines on who should be executed and who will be shot. Talk about ignorance of the American idea.
Respect for work, from plumbing to legislating, and respect for straight talk are mutually dependent, like culture and politics. Together they form a culture, and a politics, of solidity.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “The lame legacy press's trivial pursuits.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.