Some friends were talking about the challenges of raising children today, and a youngish man (he looked about thirty) said that he thought ours a bad time to have children.

He liked children. He wanted children. He believed couples should have children. But he fretted about bringing children into this world. He explained why. The public schools, he said, “are overflowing with anti-Americanism and revisionist history.”

I thought: So he won't have children because ... they might become liberals?

What we do with our children

This seems to me an odd way of thinking about being a father, though I suppose I might feel a bit of what he felt if I’d lived in Texas and faced the possibility of our next child becoming a Dallas Cowboys fan. No one wants that for his child.

Advertise with us

I think about this kind of thing reading articles on families in places like the New York Times and The Atlantic. What we do with our children is a subject that can set off angry steam-coming-off-the-screen arguments. Many people are heavily invested in how not only their but other people’s children turn out.

And rightly. Hillary Clinton’s book “It Takes a Village” should have been titled “It Takes a Government,” but the idea is sound. Everyone has, as a member of the community, some responsibility for the community’s children — for helping make sure our society is a good society for children.

Everyone can vote for the school board, for example. You’re not responsible for teaching your neighbor’s children manners, but you are responsible for helping (mostly through voting) to ensure they’re housed, fed, and educated.

The child is a person

Many recognize the responsibility, but exercise it the wrong way, by trying to take control of children’s lives, including other people’s children’s lives. “A child isn't a religious or ideological project,” wrote my friend Mindy Robinson in a discussion about raising children.

“They are a person. You have children and give them love and freedom, just like God gives us love and freedom. You don't produce units for your team. Nor is the value of a human life contingent on them believing a certain way.”

Advertise with us

She pointed out that people who try to raise children for a cause with a very specific idea of what kind of person their children must turn out to be will probably be surprised. The square peg being forced into the round hole may well make itself even squarer.

Mindy, speaking of conservative Catholics, said: “A really good way to raise future angry atheists is to treat your kids as future ‘good Catholics’ that you are making for the Church, rather than as individuals who you are welcoming because they are intrinsically valuable regardless of what they eventually choose to think.” I’ve seen the same thing happen to leftist parents who found themselves with conservative children.

What they are

You treat things according to what they are. You don’t buy a willow tree and plant it in a desert or plant a cactus in a swamp. You have to see where the plant grows best and nurture it as you can, which may mean intense attention and care or leaving it mostly alone.

The same applies to children. They come to you not just with bodies determined by genetics but with minds wired in a certain way, with strengths and weaknesses, inclinations and disinclinations, loves and hates, that are not yours and may not be the qualities you wanted.

You work with them to make them the best version of what they were made to be. (Something actual parents can on the whole do best, because they love and know the particular child the most.) That means accepting that the square peg is a square peg, and your job is to help it be a good square peg, but also that the square peg may need its corners sanded off a bit, and that’s your job too though the square peg won’t like it.

Advertise with us

It’s a hard thing to get right, and ego often intrudes. I admit to having been, like nearly every other parent I knew, too eager to push my square pegs into my chosen round holes, being swept up in the culturally dominant idea that you had to form your children and that disaster would come if you didn’t.

Forming children best

The young man felt anxious about the way the culture would form his children, whatever he thought best for them. Other people feel that way about children in general. He and they aren’t unreasonable in that. Whatever you believe, you will want to push back against the culture’s desire for your children.

Fortunately, we have a personal influence Hollywood and Wall Street don’t have. We form our own children and the children around us mostly by being the kind of person we want them to be. Systems like schools and social benefits matter, but they only do so much. Parenting will involve politics and culture, but it mostly involves being there.

The English writer G.K. Chesterton got at this. “Education,” he said, “is implication. It is not the things you say which children respect; when you say things, they very commonly laugh and do the opposite. It is the things you assume that really sink into them. It is the things you forget even to teach that they learn.” We want good children, we have to be better adults.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Giant Eagle's woke capitalism and their offended customers who go to Walmart.”