To mash together famous sayings from different eras, it is a truth universally acknowledged that if mama ain’t happy, ain’t nobody happy. But a January survey by the Pew Research Center shows that, despite all the resources that come with being the wealthiest country in the world, many American mothers are struggling. This Mother’s Day, policymakers should commit to supporting America’s mothers by enabling them to better care for themselves and their families.
The Pew study revealed that 47% of American moms are tired “all or most of the time.” Similarly, 33% of American mothers say they find parenting stressful “all or most of the time.” These pressures were only exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic: In 2020, many moms found themselves balancing work, remote school, and trying to cook dinner at the same time. But for too many mothers, trying to “do it all” has left them burned out and exhausted.
Just pay them
The most obvious way to bring relief to mothers, and to show that the country values parents and parenting, is to expand the child tax credit. On the federal level, the principle has bipartisan support, but it gets bogged down in details about work and income requirements. Both the Biden Administration and some Republican politicians have created proposals that would send more money into the pockets of parents, which helps to relieve the biggest pressure point in family life, even for those nominally in the middle class: financial precariousness.
If Washington can’t get its act together, a number of state governments have also either proposed or adopted a larger child tax credit for state tax bills. While Pennsylvania has a small “child and dependent care tax credit” for families who rely on child care, a broad-based child tax credit for all parents could be a big bipartisan victory for the divided legislature and Gov. Josh Shapiro.
Helping working moms
Read More
Policymakers should also focus on measures that make life easier for working mothers. The new PUMP Act, which provides protections for breastfeeding mothers in the workplace, is a good start. Until recently, too many working moms were not guaranteed a clean place to pump milk for their young infants, or work breaks to do so. The law is a model for how federal policymakers can and should work together across the aisle to support moms.
The new and dynamic flexibility of work scheduling is often discussed a silver lining of the pandemic — and this is certainly the case for many white-collar working moms, whose lives were simplified by working at home. (Though the blending of the office and domestic spheres has also come with its challenges.) But for many other women, “flexible” scheduling has been more a nightmare than a dream.
“Just in time” scheduling, where bosses adjust their employees’ schedules on the fly, is almost completely incompatible with motherhood — especially for single moms. An employer may cancel shifts — or demand an employee come in — at the last minute: For example, a restaurant might send home servers that show up for work if there are too few diners, or call servers in for an unexpected rush.
This makes planning for childcare, not to mention getting kids to and from school and activities, all but impossible. In the worst case, this might mean children are left unattended, or with someone unqualified. Some research has even found that this type of erratic scheduling has long-term negative impacts on kids, as their own behavior matches the chaos imposed on their families by employers.
Policymakers should investigate how they can reduce these types of scheduling practices by creating minimum lead times for call-ins and cancellations in most industries. Employers seeking efficiency above all else aren’t considering the humanity of their workers, and so government will have to step in.
Valuing homemaking
Policymakers should also seek to support moms who want to stay home. Surveys show that more than half of married American mothers would prefer having one parent at home full-time, especially during early childhood. This is not surprising, given that many families struggle to access quality, affordable childcare. But even for families who do have access to good childcare at a reasonable cost, many mothers find staying home with their babies to be a valuable and special experience.
One way to support stay-at-home moms is to help them prepare for retirement. Right now, Social Security disfavors moms who move in and out of the workforce by docking them “credits” while they are supporting their families as home. In general, the more years a person works, the more Social Security credits they earn — and the higher their payout at retirement. That’s in part why American women are less likely to be prepared for retirement than men.
Many American moms step out of the workforce for a few years, or longer, after having kids, but many years later they’re penalized in the form of a smaller Social Security check. It doesn’t have to be this way: Some countries allow mothers to earn similar retirement credits for time out of the workforce taking care of their babies and toddlers. Any revamp of Social Security should include some provision for crediting the labor of stay-at-home moms.
This Mother’s Day, legislators and other policymakers should commit to supporting America’s moms. Mothers not only take care of their immediate families and communities: They are also responsible for raising America’s children, the next generation of citizens who will someday take positions of leadership in government and business.
In other words, moms are responsible for the future of the country. They deserve our robust support, not just privately but publicly. Flowers and cards are nice, but let’s give Mom what she really needs: policies that help her to fully live out her vocation as a mother.
Ivana Greco is the Wollstonecraft Fellow at the Abigail Adams Institute in Cambridge, Mass.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.