Much of the national political commentariat seems to agree that the Republican Party is a lost cause and that this should induce no tears or regret. They argue that the GOP is inextricably entwined with Donald Trump and his rants and revenge fever dreams: The party cannot be saved given its irreversible Trumpism. So the party’s demise should be accepted, with relief.

I think this is wrong as both political science and political theory.

Reversing Trumpism

Trumpism can be, if not reversed, outgrown and absorbed. Time and new personalities will inevitably, eventually change the landscape. More important, there is a history of 170 years of Republicanism prior to Trump to consider. The Republican tradition is responsible and sane.

Advertise with us

The Republicans will and should return to traditional Republican tropes, like limited government, limited spending, and a robust foreign and defense policy. They will not, if they are smart, abandon fair trade.

The party has Republicans like Mike DeWine and Rob Portman, and in bygone days, members like Jim Rhodes and Chuck Kurfess, William Scranton and John Heinz. They existed before Trump. There is no reason they cannot exist after.

Trump brought his stamp to the party, of course. And that is all anyone sees at the moment. Largely because of cowardice in other Republican leaders.

And some of the Trump message — the non-fascist part that advocated fair trade instead of “free” trade and a rebuilding of industry and the heartland — was good for his adopted affiliation. It made the Republicans a blue- collar party.

No one wants to talk about ways that Trump “won” these days, but he did win on the one issue he cared about. Both parties were globalist parties prior to Trump and both are moderately protectionist today. (Interestingly, Mr. Trump himself no longer talks about trade and manufacturing.)

Advertise with us

Not a Republican

But Mr. Trump is not a Republican. Not really. He is not even a true populist. He is a Trumpian.

The worst thing about his influence on the GOP is Trump’s character — his demons and his contempt for law, rules and good form. He’s actually the ultimate un-Republican.

So, replace him. Pick someone else to lead the party and the party will be instantly reborn. I pray this will happen in 2024: Someone emerges. Maybe Nikki Haley, the former governor of South Carolina. Maybe Glenn Youngkin, the present governor of Virginia.

But at some point Donald Trump will be gone and there will be oxygen in the room. Leaders like Rep. Mike Gallagher, of Wisconsin, an ex-Marine with a Ph.D., will be able to emerge. Or someone we do not quite see yet.

Advertise with us

The post-Trump future depends on new faces and a little straight talk.

We should all want a GOP revival because we need political competition in this country. It is the great, unwritten check and balance. There is not a single case of a one- party town, city, or state in which government was, or is, excellent and the common good well served.

The Democrats and the Republicans both have their excesses and blind spots. We don’t want either party unchecked.

Republicans tend not to question the police, the military, the corporations. They forget justice.

Democrats tend not to question that the state can solve intractable problems. They tend not to question the PC fads of the moment and the “truths” of the legacy media and universities. And they think life can be made totally fair, if they rule.

Advertise with us

A party worth saving

The Republican party is also worth saving because roughly half of the nation more closely identifies with it than with the Democrats. And not all of those people are “deplorables,” or dumbbells. They are our fellow citizens. They deserve our respect.

And they want a party that stands for personal responsibility, constitutionalism, skepticism, and limits. They want the party of Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, Dwight David Eisenhower and John McCain. And of Bob Dole, Howard Baker and Gerry Ford — a party of modesty and moderation.

And of Calvin Coolidge. Ronald Reagan loved Calvin Coolidge, as any sane person should. Silent Cal was competent, dignified, and never in our faces.

Saving Republicanism

Advertise with us

There is a Republican tradition and a heritage — of persons, ideas and temperament. It is bigger and deeper than Donald J. Trump. And it is worth saving. How?

Stand firm on the old principles of limits and modesty.

Stand against Mr.Trump and any -ism that offends and contradicts these principles.

Encourage new talent and ideas.

Be honest about what government and politics can and cannot do and practice a humane, legal, respectful populism.

Advertise with us

Wait and have faith.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Right, left, populist, progressive: They need to grow up.”