A man named Oliver Anthony has written and sung a song that has gone viral — 21 million views and now number one worldwide. The song has lines like this:
“If you're 5-foot-3 and you're 300 pounds / Taxes ought not to pay for your bags of fudge rounds / Young men are puttin' themselves six feet in the ground / 'Cause all this damn country does is keep on kickin' them down.”
He’s the wrong kind
Mr. Anthony’s song has become a cause célèbe with the populist right, much like the film “The Sound of Freedom.” And the left is hating on both. Mr. Anthony is the wrong kind of person saying the wrong kind of things, even if some of them are true.
In the false binary, Manichaean culture wars of today, everything, all aspects of life, must be political, ideological, and zero sum. The movies you like, the beer you drink, the music you listen to, and the company you keep are all litmus tests; all a matter of “whose side are you on?”
Take one package. All of it. But only one. No à la carte thinking for yourself.
Read More
One cannot see truth in both of these songs. A liberal must not admit that Anthony’s song expresses something real. No, better to stick to un-actionable discontent.
Organize today
British musician Billy Bragg has answered Mr. Anthony: “Are you gonna take action now you sung your damn song? If you don't like the rich men having total control, you better get the union to roll. Join a union. Fight for better pay. Come on and join a union. Organize today.”
Mr. Bragg at least suggests a remedy. Unions are coming off a tough 50 years — marred by the cynicism and corruption of many of their leaders. And the utter disconnect of many more from their rank and file.
For decades the only growth in unions was among public employees who, in effect, voted themselves raises and absolute job security in states like Connecticut, where they have long controlled the legislature while they staffed the state apparatus.
Unions drifted far from Samuel Gompers’ or Walter Reuther’s sense of the common good. But this may be changing with unionization by the men and women of Amazon who are struggling to survive and to attain some measure of justice from their (liberal) employer.
Unions could be finding a second wind. But they must calculate the critical balance between moral power and economic might and logic. Between righteousness and consequence. I am not sure that the new national UAW president, Shawn Fain, has found it.
This matters. Because, well, it’s complicated. If you demonize the capitalists and risk takers, some of them will eventually walk away. And take jobs away with them. And sometimes something even more valuable: Most advances in medicines have been funded by the “evil” pharmaceutical companies.
A worker in Virginia, one in a hotel or a chain restaurant, or perhaps a small community hospital, does not have access to a union and would not know how to organize one. He needs the capitalist.
Helpless populism
That doesn’t mean he is helpless. And that’s my problem with rightist populism – it acts helpless. It doesn't mobilize or empower; it never forms an action plan. It is all about grievance and its volume. Nothing ever comes next.
In this it mirrors the left. Both groups celebrate their gloom. Seldom their blessings or opportunities.
Yes, we have challenges: Young people are not being well prepared for either technical or white collar jobs. Too many come out of college with $100,000 to $200,000 in debt and are qualified only to be baristas. Housing and health care are too expensive. We need to build new housing. And the blue collar workers of the small towns in the heartland did get the shaft from unfettered free trade and globalism.
Our problems require policy responses. Pitchforks and rage solve nothing. Lamentation, resentment and self-pity accomplish nothing.
Populists never grow up.
And neither do leftists. These are the folks who insist that America is a racist nation, always has been, and always will be.
And yet, two groups of Americans, the poor and the young, bridge the racial divide every day, because they live and work together.
Getting better
Moreover, some things are getting better. Unemployment is lower than it has ever been. Inflation is falling. And there are signs of industrial comeback.
One wants to ask the malcontents, left and right: What is it that you seek? And what is it that you feel you are owed? Few unhappy people are truly the victims of politics.
Let us heed our grandmothers and grandfathers: Count your blessings. Do your part.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “America's two opposed and conflicting cultures.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.