A year ago I wrote an opinion article for this newspaper in which I implored Mayor Ed Gainey to address the violence on the South Side with more than just platitudes. He had just released his "Plan for Peace," intended to quell violence across the city. In it he claimed all that was necessary was to focus on 200 people who were committing a majority of the crimes, and said that “public safety is the number one priority,” which was also his main campaign platform commitment.

Nothing has improved since then — and what’s happening in my neighborhood is happening across the city. Businesses continue to close as a result of crime. Moreover, the criticisms I posed are even more applicable today; things have gotten considerably worse as evidenced by the spate of shootings over the past several weekends on the South Side. The safety and security of residents has actually degraded under the Mayor’s so-called Plan for Peace.

Ironically, soon after that article was published, a drive-by shooting on our street resulted in a bullet whizzing through our front door, ricocheting off of our staircase and ceiling, and lodging where our family sleeps. The shooter had leaned out of his car window and emptied his pistol at the car in front of him.

A responding officer observed that, based on security camera footage, the gun had been modified to shoot bursts of three rounds, essentially making it an automatic weapon. A second officer stated that, based on his experience with the District Attorney’s office, the perpetrator would likely be charged with "criminal mischief.” Criminal mischief, not attempted murder, for firing an automatic weapon on a busy street and terrorizing a neighborhood. The equivalence of a graffiti charge.

Advertise with us

Too few officers

The city has budget for 900 police officers but employs only 792. It recently commissioned a $180,000 study on policing. The study found that 85% of the officers interviewed said they either disagreed or strongly disagreed with the statement, “We have sufficient proactive time available to address problems in the community.”

This bears out in how overtime is mandated for officers and how the city relies on the Allegheny Sheriff to supplement overwhelmed resources on weekends. And yet, in a statement last week addressing the recent violence, Mayor Gainey said "This issue isn’t about the number of officers on our streets but about the number of guns in our city."

The Mayor directly contradicted this less than a month ago in a rambling interview as he sought to take credit for marginal successes in crime. He attributed improvements to “beefed up patrol downtown,” saying “we did that because we wanted to make sure downtown was safe,” and “every time I go downtown people tell me thank you for the increase in police patrol.”

While he gets credit for fielding questions from the reporter instead of repeating what has become de facto “no comment” responses from his administration, he promoted statistics that the Post-Gazette said “stretched the truth.” He over-stated the number of officers patrolling Downtown, for example.

Advertise with us

The statistics Mayor Gainey asserted can’t be confirmed or refuted, however, because the city’s crime dashboard has been down for months. This, despite the fact that one of six key principles in his Plan for Peace was "usage of data" to inform decisions and provide transparency. The mayor hasn’t been able to keep his plan and a basic website on track for even one year.

It’s also possible that he simply doesn’t want residents to have the ability to quantify how bad the problem has become under his management, and is intentionally obfuscating the data. Meanwhile, citizens are literally dying in the streets on his watch.

Pittsburgh has almost all of the necessary ingredients to be a world class city: terrific cultural institutions, lush natural beauty, professional sports, exceptional universities, stunning architecture, reasonably priced housing, a productive labor force, and an emergent technology-based business foundation. Sadly, however, the most essential ingredient is missing: mayoral leadership that can marshal these vast, extraordinary resources and accelerate the city forward.

He can be both

Mayor Gainey proves that one can be simultaneously well-intentioned and incompetent. The public sees that he is in over his head. This should also be abundantly clear to the dedicated civil servants working closely with him each day.

Advertise with us

He, too, has likely come to the realization that managing fewer than ten staff in the State Legislature is radically easier than managing more than 3,500 across a multi-department city. His incompetence has created an utter lack of accountability while he attempts to do things he is simply incapable of doing.

Let’s not squander this once-in-a-generation opportunity to become a world class city. Instead of yet again asking Mayor Gainey to address these issues as I did previously, I now implore him to do the honorable thing and resign. For the greater good of the city, allow someone who is capable of leading change to solve these crises that limit our city’s significant potential.

Eric Gillespie is the founder of national security firm Govini and a resident of the South Side Flats. His previous article was “Stop the violence on the South Side.”