“I’m just the mid­dle guy.” It seems like a harm­less and jus­ti­fi­able ex­cuse. But when en­tire com­pa­nies, gov­ern­ments and com­mu­ni­ties be­come dom­inated by “mid­dle guys” work­ing for “the boss,” the lit­tle guys lose out.

Case in point, my friends hired a mov­ing com­pany to de­liver their goods to a home in a new state. Well, that’s what they thought. In ac­tu­al­ity, they hired a “bro­ker,” who hired a “mover,” who hired con­trac­tors to move their stuff.

Dam­aged and late

When their goods ar­rived dam­aged and two weeks late, they tried to get a re­fund from the con­trac­tors — who pointed them to the mover, who pointed them to the bro­ker, who never an­swered their calls. My friends wanted to hire an at­tor­ney to go af­ter any­one and ev­ery­one but lacked the time and money to get back their time and money.

Advertise with us

Ini­tially, I ques­tioned why my friends didn’t read enough Google re­views to hire a bet­ter com­pany. Then, I re­al­ized … Wow! I have drunk way too much Kool-Aid.

I rushed to ques­tion the con­sumer — the Joes and Janes with no power rather than an in­dus­try and cul­ture that has robbed lit­tle guys of any means to im­pose con­se­quences on those who should be held ac­count­able.

This may not seem like a prob­lem to those who can af­ford to get around mid­dle guys. They’re the hand­ful of in­di­vid­u­als who can, for ex­am­ple, char­ter pri­vate jets and avoid the air­line ticket counter — a do­min­ion con­trolled ex­clu­sively by mid­dle guys whose hands are al­ways tied.

People don’t keep their promises

For ev­ery­one else, there’s a loom­ing ac­count­abil­ity cri­sis brought on by prom­ises be­ing made by in­di­vid­u­als and in­sti­tu­tions with no in­ten­tion of ever keep­ing them — and in­stead put­ting the blame on an un­ac­count­able mid­dle guy. Ac­count­abil­ity does not ex­ist if those who hold power don’t face con­se­quences for tak­ing in­ad­e­quate, il­le­gal or im­moral ac­tions.

Advertise with us

In the Age of the Mid­dle Guy, Aver­age Joes and Janes can­not af­ford to go af­ter “the boss,” who is pro­tected by com­plex con­tracts, well-paid law­yers and deep pock­ets. In short, in too many sit­u­a­tions it now takes time and money to get back your time and money.

Those in power go out of their way to di­min­ish the like­li­hood and mag­ni­tude of those con­se­quences. In other words, they try to re­duce the odds of get­ting caught and, if they some­how are caught, they try to limit the se­ver­ity of the pun­ish­ment.

Over time, the pow­er­ful have cre­ated more and more cre­ative ways to evade de­tec­tion and es­cape pun­ish­ment. They’ll use dis­tance (see King George count­ing on an ocean to avoid fac­ing the col­o­nists); time (see dic­ta­tors de­lay­ing elec­tions); mid­dle guys (mov­ing com­pa­nies hir­ing con­trac­tors); and bu­reau­cracy (gov­ern­ments) — all in an ef­fort to re­duce the odds of lit­tle guys co­or­di­nat­ing to ac­tively hold them to ac­count.

Regret­ta­bly, the pow­er­ful usu­ally suc­ceed. Lit­tle guys don’t have the time and re­sources to sail across the sea or wait on hold. Even when the pow­er­ful get caught in the act, they man­age to avoid fac­ing se­vere con­se­quences — their con­tracts are too strong, their law­yers are on speed dial, and their po­lit­i­cal ties are too deep.

Good­bye to le­git­i­macy

Advertise with us

When ac­count­abil­ity goes, so does le­git­i­macy. When lit­tle guy af­ter lit­tle guy has a story about be­ing taken ad­van­tage of, with noth­ing to show for their suf­fer­ing, en­tire in­sti­tu­tions can start to crum­ble. The sto­ries of cor­rup­tion spread and the will­ing­ness of Joes and Janes ev­ery­where to trust in­sti­tu­tions dis­si­pates.

That lack of trust is spread­ing to­day and has be­come one of the most im­por­tant is­sues of our time. One way to re­store that trust is to look for ways — through reg­u­la­tions, rules and norms — to cut out the mid­dle guy and make sure that the pow­er­ful can be di­rectly, swiftly and ap­pro­pri­ately held to ac­count.

Kevin Frazier teaches at the Crump College of Law at St. Thomas University. His previous article was “Voters should decide when and how AI can be used.”