The decoder ring for understanding, and predicting, the Gainey Administration is that it desires to be the photo negative of its predecessor. But, as has become apparent during Mayor Ed Gainey’s first 17 months in office, merely unspooling the legacy of Bill Peduto is not an effective governing strategy.
If a project or initiative was launched by Mr. Peduto, Mr. Gainey’s team has no interest in it. The fully funded 2022 police academy class? Never called, and the 2023 class still hasn’t come to order. The award-winning Gender Equity Commission? Allowed to wither on the vine. Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library, which required only a small foundation sponsor to send free books to thousands of children? Canceled. The OnePGH concept, which had secured a $40 million commitment from UPMC, plus $75 million from other nonprofits, for social service projects? Nixed in July 2022, but on the chopping block from Mr. Gainey’s first day in office.
There’s no ideological thread that connects these canceled and ignored projects. The cop class may be coded rightwing, but the Gender Commission is (was?) very much leftwing. And Dolly Parton is neither left nor right, but a goddess who has deigned to alight on this planet for a short time before blessing the next. The only principle is Bearded Man Bad.
Stewardship
No mayor is obligated to see through all of his or her predecessor’s initiatives, but the mania with which Mr. Gainey has ignored and undermined Mr. Peduto’s work is unprecedented. Besides whatever personal animus it betrays, it also demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of how government works.
As much as the local progressive movement, of which Mr. Gainey is the most visible leader, might believe it has a mandate to radically uproot the status quo, government (like gardening) a matter of stewardship, not possession. To govern well is to work with an imperfect inheritance, to improve it and then to pass it on to the next guardian.
Read More
That might involve pruning, even removing entire branches that hold the organism back from its full potential. But pruning is a deliberate and discriminating process, not willy-nilly destruction of past progress. And it’s always ordered to future growth.
In other words, governing is an act of humility that recognizes a debt to the past, no matter how flawed, and responsibility for the future, no matter how uncertain. And this is why leaders puffed up with the spirit of revolution often struggle to actually make government work.
Year Zero
There’s no question, to use a phrase made popular by Sen. Bernie Sanders, that a political revolution has occurred in southwest Pennsylvania. With Sara Innamorato’s victory in the Democratic primary for county executive, progressives have absolute power — to the extent allowed by a messy republican form of government — within reach.
In this revolution, Mr. Gainey is the tip of the spear, but his first year and a half in office has demonstrated a characteristic flaw of revolutions: an inability to discern between the good and bad aspects of a political inheritance.
Every ambitious revolution desires not just to change the present system, but to wipe it away entirely, allowing for a fresh foundation on which to build a new world. But this is always part of its undoing, because there are no truly clean slates in human affairs.
The most ridiculous example of a “Year Zero” revolution was the 1975 victory of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia. According to the new regime, led by the deranged Pol Pot, April 17 of that year was to be the very beginning of time, and all memory of what came before burned out of culture and consciousness.
But Pol Pot’s rule only lasted four years before his regime was overthrown. “Year Zero” was an impossible dream: Every person and every regime acts within history, and must consider and deal with the inheritance of history. There are no fresh starts.
And yet Year Zero is an undeniably beguiling proposition, one that holds great appeal even for people with conservative dispositions like myself.
Imagine what could be done if we didn’t have to worry about everything that has already been done, all the habits that have built up over the generations, all the messiness and detritus of human life and civilization! Everything could be as it was always meant to be. Everything could be perfect.
But this dream is a mirage, and the only path to it is through a nightmare.
Hubris
Mr. Gainey and his team may believe that City Hall is all theirs now, and that they have no obligation to anything that came before, and that the future belongs entirely to them. But they are mistaken. City Hall will outlast the Gainey administration, and in all likelihood will outlive Mr. Gainey himself. His task isn’t to turn it into something entirely new, but to make it a better version of itself, so it’s ready to be inherited by the next steward.
And if, in his ambition to tear down the past, he fails to replace it with anything better (or anything at all), he will fail politically, and fail as a leader. He will pass down a government not repaired and renewed, but more broken than he found it.
Herodotus has the great Persian emperor Xerxes remark while surveying his conquered lands, “I was moved to compassion when I considered the shortness of all human life, since of all this multitude of men not one will be alive a hundred years from now.”
The word on Grant Street is that the Mayor’s Office is already obsessed with reelection, and makes every decision with 2025 in mind. Perhaps Mr. Gainey imagines that, in a city without term limits, he can outdo Xerxes and rule for a hundred years.
But unless he starts building rather than just tearing down, the smart money is on four.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.