It’s axiomatic that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought,” as Presidents Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev declared at their summit in Geneva in 1985. Yet, despite this piece of commonsense, the main nuclear agreement between the United States and Russia has been knocked off its bearings.

The so-called New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, or New START, was signed into effect by Presidents Barack Obama and Dmitry Medvedev in 2010. It capped the number of each country’s deployed nuclear warheads at 1,550, and their respective long-range missiles and bombers at 700.

Russian president Vladimir Putin announced in February that he had suspended participation in New START, refusing U.S. inspections of Russian nuclear facilities — seemingly another casualty of the war in Ukraine. Though one might expect Russia to return to the negotiation table at some point.

In 2021, Presidents Joe Biden and Putin had exercised a provision to extend the treaty for five years, to 2026, to allow time for renegotiation.  However, Putin’s recent suspension, though not outright annulment, nonetheless played loose with one of the potentially existential watersheds the world has stared at for decades, the possibility of Armageddon.

Advertise with us

I suggest, however, that New START’s off-kilter circumstances may have a silver lining. How? With New START transitorily shelved, perhaps conditions offer an opportunity to alter the recipe for the globe’s replacement front-line nuclear arms treaty — taking it to the next level, to include China. That is, to shift any future treaty that caps strategic nuclear arms from the familiar bilateralism the United States and Soviet Union enjoyed during the decades-long Cold War to a trilateral agreement.

The obvious hurdle, of course, has been Beijing’s disinclination to date to negotiate limiting its undeniably growing nuclear forces, given lack of numerical equivalence with the United States and Russia. That’s arguably understandable, if not peered at from a cynical, parochial perspective. But the hurdle isn’t insurmountable.

Maybe there’s a remedy, to entice an unenthusiastic China to become a third-party signatory. After all, it was eminently apparent to the world that President Xi Jinping relished his role as a deep-pocketed powerbroker during his recent trip to Moscow, signaling China’s revitalized Middle Kingdom reinvention with its ambitious, rapidly growing soft-power and hard-power projection on an increasingly global scale.

In broad terms, negotiations among the United States, Russia and China might lead to a two-pronged deal. The first prong would entail slightly dialing down the numbers of deployed nuclear warheads and missiles currently heavily favoring the United States and Russia. The overarching aim would be to employ the trilateral treaty as a way to disrupt the status quo and reduce the nuclear threat to the world.

The second prong would set agreed-upon benchmarks for China to dial up its nuclear arsenal — not willy-nilly, but in managed fashion. With China seeming to have, according to Pentagon estimates, the potential for at least an additional thousand deployed nuclear warheads by 2030, circumstances put a spotlight on the apparent trendline.

Advertise with us

The goal would be to motivate China with rough equivalence. Though the devil would, of course, be in the treaty’s details as the final numbers get baked in.

Even approximate three-way parity would preserve the gambit of mutual deterrence, importantly with force levels existentially still sufficient to keep everyone’s fingers off nuclear triggers: the “mutual assured destruction” of Cold War fame, which earned its keep. It would take far fewer warheads, missiles and bombers to achieve that consequential power balance.

But what’s also crucial is that China’s treaty inclusion would acknowledge irresistible, irreversible 21st-century geostrategic realities that cannot be overlooked indefinitely; proactivity by all parties is the best maneuver. All the while, meantime, avoiding three nations’ bristling nuclear arsenals from growing uncontrollably into a new pernicious arms race.

Keith Tidman is an author of essays on social, political and scientific opinion. His previous article was “Everyone uses the earth, few take care of it.”