In Hebrew school, I grew up learning how antisemitism took 6 million of us to an early, horrific death. In 2018, I saw antisemitism take 11 more. Every day on my way home from work, I pass the Tree of Life Synagogue, where in 2018 a gunman allegedly walked in during Shabbat services and killed eleven people. This drive is my daily reminder of what will always happen when a community remains visible within a culture that prioritizes social comfort over that community’s lives — like a ritual.

Visibility is a source of connection that requires assuming the risk of destruction. Some argue it is better to remain hidden and safe than visible and dead. Invisibility, though, is not true safety — my body may be intact, but only at the expense of precisely that which makes me, me — my Jewishness, my queerness, my transness.

Over the course of 3 weeks, the University of Pittsburgh will host three events bookending Transgender Day of Visibility. Each features a speaker who, in their own way, has demonstrated they do not want to see trans people as part of their community.

First to speak is Cabot Phillips, a senior editor of the Daily Wire. This is an organization that spent at least $5.7 million on ads promoting anti-trans programming.

Advertise with us

As if that weren’t enough, a second event amplifies the voice of Riley Gaines. She is known for advocating for the disappearance of trans girls and women from girls’ and women’s sports.

As if that weren’t enough, Michael Knowles, notorious for his recent declaration that “transgenderism must be eradicated from public life entirely,” will debate whether people like me even exist. He will be debating whether or not I am real.

As if the mere presence of these speakers weren’t enough, the series concludes on Yom HaShoah, Holocaust Remembrance Day — a macabre reminder of what happens when the intolerant want a community “eradicated from public life entirely.”

But these events are not isolated incidents. It is not as if the University of Pittsburgh were somehow uniquely tolerant of speakers whose words endanger students and staff alike. This past October, Penn State was slated to host the founder of the Proud Boys, Gavin McInnes. Just a few weeks ago, Michael Knowles spoke at the University at Buffalo. Meanwhile, Turning Point USA, the same organization sponsoring two of Pitt’s speakers, has nearly identical events planned at colleges and universities all over the U.S.

Nor is the goal of extinguishing trans people from view relegated solely to the realm of higher education. No, this is a national issue whose wiry tendrils extend from children’s classrooms, to private doctors’ offices, to legislative halls across the country.

Advertise with us

In the first three months of 2023, legislatures in all but four states have introduced a total of 487 bills targeting trans people — nearly three times more than in all of 2022. These are bills that seek to deprive us of our healthcare, of our right of equal access to education, of our right to exist, and to codify all of it into law, like a ritual.

It is not hyperbole to say our very lives are at stake. In the U.S., 40% of transgender adults have attempted suicide at some point in their lives, almost nine times more than the general U.S. population. Among those trans adults, almost 75% were less than 18 years old the first time they attempted suicide.

Trans youth are dying and we know why: it is the direct effect of people proclaiming intolerant ideologies and passing laws that don’t just ban us from receiving appropriate medical care, they ban us from living our lives. Fortunately, this bleak outlook is not without hope. When trans youth receive gender affirming care, their risk of suicidal thoughts and behaviors decreases by 73%. And when schools create a supportive environment for their queer students, the entire student body’s mental health improves, as well.

At first glance, it might seem like this story is simply about students at universities throughout the U.S. inviting — and protesting — controversial speakers. Instead, it is a story about the power and the danger of visibility. It is a story about who is allowed to exist in the public sphere. And it is a story about which children deserve to reach adulthood.

We know that a supportive society reduces suicide, improves mental health, and gives us the freedom to pursue our own happiness. Instead, we are being made to live in a hostile environment, where it will never be enough until we trans folk, we queer folk, we Jews, we marginalized, racialized, and oppressed communities are all “eradicated from public life entirely.”

Jesse Dubin is a program evaluator at the University of Pittsburgh addressing the opioid epidemic in Pennsylvania. Their previous article was “Neighborly Pittsburgh should welcome immigrants.”