A few weeks ago, during a public meeting, a colleague said, with obvious pride, that she and others had worked very hard to bring a major event here to Pittsburgh. She then fought back tears as she shared that despite her work and love of the game, a recent ruling by the sport’s governing body determined that she, as a trans-woman, was no longer eligible to participate. It was absolutely heart wrenching.
I have been a high school and community youth coach for close to 30 years. While my main sports have been wrestling and softball, I have coached several other boys’, girls’, and coed teams as well. In all those years, I have worked with no openly transgender athletes.
Yet people claim, as Ruth Ann Daily said in this newspaper, that “transgender women — that is, biological males — compete against biological females, completely dominate the sport and destroy the birth-women’s opportunities for success.” This is a false narrative created and embraced by those that would deny the rights and very existence of trans and gender non-conforming people.
When discussing this issue, many are quick to cherry-pick the successes of trans-women in athletics. Are there individuals who have excelled? Of course. But they are very few and, as you’ll read, their successes hardly rise to the level of “dominance.”
Outsports.com records and reports on the actual data. In the past decade, fewer than 40 trans athletes competed in college athletics (out of a current 500,000 athletes, according to statista.com). Of those, fewer than a dozen are trans-women and of them only four competed at the Division 1 level in any sport.
At the absolute most, .00005% of female college athletes are trans-women. There is simply no truth to the assertion that trans-women are taking over athletics and denying cis women opportunities.
Read More
Many are quick to point to the “dominance” of University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas. Critics tell us Thomas has smashed records and ruined swimming for cis women. The truth is, she broke absolutely no world, or even NCAA, records. She holds Ivy League free-style records only.
Yes, she swam very well in the NCAA championship during her final season. She won the 500-meter freestyle (by .24 seconds), tied for fifth in the 200-meter, and finished eighth (last in the championship heat) in the 100-meter. She was sixth in overall individual scoring. Was she good? Obviously. But she hardly dominated, let alone destroyed, the sport.
Keeping with swimming, prepler.com reports that there are over 14 thousand women competing in US colleges. In the past 10 years, three of them have been out trans-women. Three. Aside from Thomas, only the University of Michigan’s G. Ryan holds any records (Big 10 record in the 500 free). She has no NCAA top eight finishes to her credit.
Trans-women have competed in the Olympics and won absolutely no medals. Only two, in any sport, have won college national championships, Thomas and Franklin Pierce hurdler CeCe’ Telfer. Worth noting is that while Telfer took first in one event (the 400), she finished fifth in her other (the 100). These were from the 2019 Division II championship, so not even the NCAA’s highest level.
There is no data to support the idea that trans-women threaten women’s athletics. This is simply a lie. If anything, the data proves that there is an abundance of opportunities for cis women in athletics and that they continue to excel.
Cis women dominate their sports and need no one’s protection to do so! Everyone should be able to play the sports they love and embrace who they are while doing so.
Lenny Obovich is the head wrestling coach at Carrick High School.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.