Last Tuesday at Wellesley College, one of the nation’s few remaining women’s institutions, students supported a referendum to open admissions to transgender and non-binary applicants.

On Monday, a male Australian basketball star sparked controversy when he criticized the board of a semi-professional women’s league for voting to let transgender players join women’s teams.

And four days before that, First Lady Jill Biden presented an “International Women of Courage Award” to a transgender Argentinian government official.

All of this raises the question, whatever happened to the “war on women”?

Advertise with us

This decades-old slogan gets frequent use when certain hot-button topics are being discussed. In old and new media alike, there is an obvious political slant in the slogan’s application.

In fact, Wikipedia helpfully (and repeatedly) notes that it’s used “to describe Republican policies in areas such as access to reproductive health services, … the definition of rape, the prosecution of criminal violence against women, and workplace discrimination against women.”

Why isn’t the slogan being used now to describe the abrupt ideological shift embraced by left-leaning administrations, universities, medical schools and sports institutions — a shift that frequently and significantly harms women?

When transgender women — that is, biological males — compete against biological females, completely dominate the sport and destroy the birth-women’s opportunities for success, why is this not a “war on women”?

When doctors must refer to “chest-feeding persons” instead of “nursing mothers,” or when transgender men take spots at elite women’s universities, is this not manifestation of a gender war?

Advertise with us

Of the referendum at Wellesley College, the New York Times said “the vote was in some ways definitional: What is the mission of a women’s college?”

But of course the vote is “definitional” at a much more basic level: What does it mean to be a woman?

This question has absolutely riven the ranks of feminists here and abroad, but the feminists who argue to protect territory for biological women only (such as J.K. Rowling) have been vilified by most of the left. In the public debate, their position is ignored, creating a simplistic left-right divide.

A political divide is thus unavoidable: Those who’ve been quick to adopt radical new definitions of sex and gender that defy millennia of human history are people on the left. Those quick to deplore it have been mostly (but by no means exclusively) people on the right. The reasons are right there in their labels:

“Liberals” are liberators of the oppressed. “Conservatives” seek to conserve cultural norms and traditions. Most people shift between those two impulses, depending on the issue.

Advertise with us

But in this controversy, the “liberators” are carrying their mission to such an extreme that they jeopardize far more humans’ welfare than they help.

When the transgendered Lia Thomas competed on the women’s swim team at U-Penn, one person — Lia Thomas — was helped, while scores of young women were demonstrably, measurably harmed.

As other institutions follow suit, all the way to the White House, is the “war on women” slogan appropriate?

It is, and for the sake of intellectual honesty, it’s important to point it out. But in order to move forward, why not set it aside?

Most of us — mercifully — don’t define ourselves primarily as political beings, nor spend most of our time on social media. We find our identity in other beliefs and pursuits. Moreover, most people, in my experience, do want to live in peace with one another.

Advertise with us

Isn’t it possible that gender identity conflicts could often be defused by simple common sense?

If Wellesley’s leaders agree to admit nonbinary and transgender applicants, it does no harm to me or mine. A young woman can decide for herself whether she’ll thrive or not in that environment.

However, when a woman’s physical safety or opportunity for life-changing achievement is at stake (such as women-only prisons or fair competition in sports), we do more good by protecting biological women and their distinct realm.

I’d also argue strenuously that since gender dysphoria and transitioning do not make for an easy path in life, normalizing this path for impressionable youngsters is a foolish strategy. It is certainly a worldview that others don’t get to foist upon anyone’s children.

We can accommodate one another, but we do not have to deny science nor the reality of the physical world we inhabit. In fact, we must not.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com