All cultures have culture wars. Can we at least agree on that? All groups of people, large and small, experience conflict as they establish or reexamine shared values. Nations, tribes, religious denominations, school boards, fraternal organizations, you name it — conflicts are inevitable and often important.

What’s also true — at least in what we used to call “the civilized world” — is that as we do battle over ideas and beliefs, we do not use our children as cannon fodder.

Until now.

The latest battlefront in American culture is over the meaning and expression of gender. Activists teach that gender is an arbitrary social construct and is therefore mutable, an identity to be determined by the individual.

Advertise with us

America’s devotion to self-determination being as extreme as it is — producing outlier statistics, worldwide, on everything from divorce rates to abortions to gun violence — it wasn’t long before some in our culture decided that gender options should be introduced to children in grade school.

They believe teenagers who feel uncomfortable in their bodies should be provided with drugs and sex-change surgery, even during puberty.

Some even believe it’s okay to take little children to sexually explicit live performances.

The ensuing uproar has inevitably become politicized, with the predictable partisan divisions. Responsible adults, however, need to rise above the politics, because these provocations do have real victims, very young victims, and the consequences of activists’ choices range from moderately damaging to terrible and irreversible.

Imagine attending a neighborhood party and seeing an adult behaving in a sexually provocative way — dancing, lifting her skirt, singing sexually explicit lyrics — and directing all of this toward a minor. What would you do or say in such a situation? What would you call it?

Advertise with us

I call it child abuse. Sexualizing young children is psychologically damaging, but this kind of interaction has now been observed and recorded numerous times, not at neighborhood parties but at various restaurants’ so-called “family-friendly drag queen shows.”

Videos have documented performers targeting pre-teens with suggestive movements while lip-synching extremely vulgar songs, as parents or other adults encourage the children to tip the dancers.

If a woman had done this to my young sons at a neighborhood party, I’d have considered it a crime. At a drag queen show, is it the exchange of money that somehow makes this okay? Or is it that the performer is a man in makeup and costume?

Drag queens inhabit a cultural space fairly distinct from most transgender people. In our approach to trans youth we risk doing not just psychological harm but also irreversible physical damage — both to them and to their non-trans peers.

Do we actually think it’s a good thing to deny females the opportunity to enjoy fair athletic competition, to occupy safe locker rooms and bathrooms or to live only with biological females? (At the University of Wyoming, members of one sorority have been forced to admit a “trans woman” who still presents as a man and seeks dates with women on Tinder.)

Advertise with us

The greater danger is to transgender youth themselves. A 2021 study published by the American Academy of Pediatrics found that gender-non-conforming youth are much more often victims of psychological and sexual abuse than their peers.

In 2022, in response to a critical review, Britain’s National Health Service closed its only gender-identity clinic for children. One of the findings was that fully one-third of its patients were on the autism spectrum.

Earlier this year, at Washington University Transgender Center in St. Louis, whistle-blower Jamie Reed decried “morally and medically appalling” treatment of trans youth, “who came to us [with] many co-morbidities: depression, anxiety, ADHD, eating disorders, obesity. Many were diagnosed with autism,” she said, but instead of serious counseling and treatment for those problems, they were being pushed toward hormonal therapy and surgery.

This explosion of transitioning youth, especially females, is very recent. Right now, the de-transitioning rate is about 3 percent. It could grow, but whatever it is, young people who once thought they’d prefer being the other sex have permanently scarred bodies.

Why would we rush to make unalterable decisions in such fraught realms of life?

Advertise with us

We can respect all humans and teach our children to do the same without hyper-sexualizing them, polluting their innocence or mutilating their bodies.

We need to be wise and civil but unapologetically bold in confronting activists who are turning children’s minds and bodies into social science experiments.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Companies should be inclusive, not woke.”