There’s never been an abundance of Hollywood films about journalism, and even an American landmark like “All The President’s Men” had long since faded from the national consciousness until this week, when investigative reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein suddenly found themselves talking about Robert Redford again.

Redford died Tuesday at 89, having acted, directed, produced, and enabled all manner of cinematic artistry across six decades. There can be plenty of easily assembled arguments that “All The President’s Men” was not the best thing he’d ever done, but you won’t find one here.

An energy and intelligence

The movie drew eight Academy Award nominations, won four Oscars, and eventually found a place in the National Film Registry curated by the Library of Congress. It somehow made journalism look sexy, if in no sexual sense.

It starred Redford as Woodward and Dustin Hoffman as Bernstein, the Washington Post reporters who exposed the burgeoning Watergate scandal within the Nixon administration. Based on the book of the same name by the same reporters, it only came into existence from Redford’s trademark curiosity, intellect, and passion for his craft.

Advertise with us

“I was quite skeptical,” Woodward remembered for Anderson Cooper the other night, “but there was an energy and intelligence that he had that is not normally associated with Hollywood actors.”

Bernstein was even more skeptical when Redford called Woodward. “Hang up!” he said. “Don’t talk to him!”

Bernstein figured they’d both “get crushed,” in Woodward’s words, if anyone found out they were talking with Hollywood mid-scandal, but Redford purchased the film rights to the book and his vision for it — the story of the dynamic tension between the reporters as they overcame 1,000 setbacks to unearth the biggest political scandal of the 20th century — would not be deterred.

“The movie’s not just pretty damned true, it is true,” Woodward told TIME Magazine the year it came out, 1976. “I just think, if reporters see it, they’ll say, ‘This is how we do it.’”

Woodward and Bernstein had already won Pulitzers, so the enthusiasm for Redford’s project in the Post’s executive offices was tepid at best. In that same TIME piece, executive editor Ben Bradlee said he was initially enthusiastic, but as the process advanced, he worried the film would make a caricature of the Post’s newsroom:

Advertise with us

“Redford kept saying, ‘You’ve got to trust us.’ We didn’t understand that. We were thinking, ‘Why the hell should we trust Robert Redford? Why should we turn our reputations over to him?’”

Outlasting the newspaper

I’m not certain whether somewhere in the voluminous and worthy tributes to Redford this week anyone suggested the contemporary irony of Redford’s reputation outlasting the Post’s, but plenty of media critics have noted the exodus of the paper’s most conspicuous talent, particularly within its political reporting and opinion functions.

In the past year, political reporters Ashley Parker, Michael Scherer, Tyler Pager, and Josh Dawsey left the paper for other outlets, and veteran columnists Ruth Marcus and Eugene Robinson resigned in the face of shifting editorial philosophies.

When cartoonist Ann Telnaes quit after claiming editors killed her cartoon depicting Post owner Jeff Bezos and other oligarchs genuflecting before Donald Trump, the shift and the talent drain from buyouts looked irreversible.

Bezos’s impact on the Post’s opinion pages has been little short of tectonic. He spiked an editorial endorsing Kamala Harris for president, claiming that it would have no impact and would only encourage the suspicion of bias. Had the editorial board endorsed Trump, you might guess things would have been different.

Advertise with us

Unlike Bezos and long before Trump became a political showman, Redford understood the dangers of an increasingly turbulent media climate. In interviews as far back as 2013, he noted the vast changes in media since Watergate and lamented the rise of misinformation and the vanishing of journalistic imperatives. The fractious nature of so many outlets, he said, has made it a whole lot easier to publish and a whole lot harder to know the truth.

The truth about Redford, judging from the widespread testimony of those who knew him and worked with him, is that he was as authentic in life as he was in character, where he was equally smooth and flawless whether he was Bob Woodward or Roy Hobbs.

He knew the dangers

My favorite Redford movies have been the same two since 1984, “All The President’s Men” and “The Natural,” which is mostly because they’re about a couple of things I still like, journalism and baseball.

Redford’s athletic performance in “The Natural” is just about flawless. Having once earned a college baseball scholarship, his sweet left-handed swing as the star-crossed slugger of the New York Knights has a delicious authenticity.

America will remember him for a range of expertly constructed characters, but in “All The President’s Men,” he fully recognized the stakes of play. He saw the incredible potential of journalism against the dangers of unchecked power, a lesson learned, forgotten, and, maybe you’ve noticed, fairly relevant.

Gene Collier’s previous column was “Spencer Cox and the only way out.”