In a country with more guns than people and more churning digital hatred than it could ever have imagined, the chore of talking us down from the latest violent atrocity can fall to anyone.
A pastor in Baltimore, a sheriff in Texas, a mayor in Oregon, a first responder in Illinois, the point person responsible for the emotional wrangling of thoughts and prayers in the hours and days after another sickening display of our worst pathologies can emerge from almost anywhere.
Most recently it’s been a governor in Utah, Spencer Cox, manning the national grief pulpit after the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. Part counselor and part national scold, Cox drew plaudits from nearly all outposts of the political landscape, even if his message was complicated.
And complicated generally doesn’t play well in these moments.
In his conservative philosophy
Cox talked about “agency.”
“In my conservative philosophy, and, quite frankly, in my faith philosophy, we believe in agency,” he said. “We believe that we are each individually responsible for ourselves.”
Such was the philosophical basis, Cox explained, for assigning blame for Kirk’s death to the suspected shooter and to no one else, but it’s complicated because he identified and scalded the forces in play that cause us to “lose our agency.”
“I would encourage people to log off,” he said of social media. “Turn off. Touch grass. Hug a family member. Go out and do good in your community.”
Just a few news cycles into the investigation, the governor had fully refined the message, and it had muscle and eloquence. “Every one of us has to make a decision,” he was explaining to multiple Sunday news shows.
“Are we going to hate our neighbor? Are we going to hate the other side? Are we going to return violence with violence, or are we going to find a different path? Are we going get out of those dark places in the internet where the conflict entrepreneurs reside who are preying upon us? These companies with trillion dollar market caps, who are using dopamine just like fentanyl to addict us to their product and the algorithms that lead us to more outrage. Can we put that aside?
That is,” he concluded, “the only way out of this. There’s nothing else we can do to solve this dark chapter in our history.”
The internet has been with us for a generation, and some might say its available poisons have far outpaced its benefits. Plenty of politicians, including Spencer Cox, have voted for better internet access. Some thought at the outset that the internet would eliminate lying because correct information was available with a quick burst of keystrokes.
The bi-literate society
So how’s that going?
Most of the web’s users have come to understand the dangers and psychological addictions at play, but many of the ways in which the web has injured the culture aren’t so obvious.
What the web and social media in particular have done to reading, reading for pleasure, and especially reading for pleasure by young people has been ruinous, according to the few who’ve noticed.
Reading (and its correlative partner, thinking) has been on the decline since the advent of television, but the accelerated drop in the internet era has been hair-raising. In the 1980’s, showed one long-term study, only 8% of U.S. 13-year-olds reported that they “never” or “hardly ever” read for fun. By the 2018–19 school year, that figure was 33%.
The percentage of adults who read books (especially literature) has faded significantly in the internet age as well, especially among young adults, meaning the need for a kind of dual literacy has never been more urgent.
Adnan Masood, the Harvard software engineer and data scientist, writing on Media.com in May, said the challenge is to foster “a bi-literate society — one that is adept at navigating the digital world while retaining the capacity for deep, reflective engagement with long-form text.
This he said, “requires proactive interventions in education to teach critical digital consumption and attention management, parental guidance in modeling balanced media habits, and supportive policy measures. The future isn’t about choosing between screens and books, but about intelligently integrating both to cultivate a more informed, attentive, and critically-minded populace.”
That’s the strategy, but the brilliant data minds behind the social media platforms have strategies too, and those people never seem to get perp walked.
Facebook wanted division
As Cox seemed to be calling them out after the freshest round of violence, the memory popped of a former Facebook insider who testified before Congress not four years ago, Frances Haugen.
“During my time at Facebook, first working as the lead product manager for civic misinformation and later on counterespionage, I saw Facebook repeatedly encounter conflicts between its own profits and our safety,” Haugen testified.
“Facebook consistently resolved these conflicts in favor of its own profits. The result has been more division, more harm, more lies, more threats and more combat. In some cases, this dangerous online talk has led to actual violence that harms and even kills people. This is not simply a matter of certain social media users being angry or unstable, or about one side being radicalized against the other. It’s about Facebook choosing to grow at all costs.”
That’s the kind of thing that can put a lot of strain on your agency, but Cox is probably right. America might just have to lead itself away from those dark places.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “The Trump deportation show faceplants in Georgia.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.