Serious tributes to former president Jimmy Carter, moving and comprehensive, are churning through the middle of a second week, a remarkable achievement for a country with no measurable attention span and little taste for its own history.
The near-universal outpouring of respect for the self-effacing Georgia peanut farmer who died Dec. 29 won’t even begin to slow for another 48 hours, sometime after the United States Navy delivers a thunderous missing-man formation flyover of Carter’s house in Plains, where there’s to be a private burial Thursday evening at the end of a national day of mourning.
That Carter spent nearly 45 years post-presidency building and rebuilding his legacy — humanitarian hammer literally in hand — and that history has little choice but to look favorably on his singularly American life are things that we will inevitably get back to forgetting or contorting with varying degrees of ignorance.
The scientist
Mine, for example. In March of 1979, I was covering spring training in Clearwater, Fla. when news reached the beaches of the Grapefruit League that an accident at Three Mile Island had the potential for unimaginable destruction.
My parents lived about 90 miles from there, so a nuclear misadventure and the resultant release of radioactive gas into the atmosphere (traces of contamination were eventually found as far away as Albany) seriously diverted my attention from the slightly less nettlesome issues of subtropical baseball. When I heard that President Carter would be visiting the nuclear facility, I remember snarking, “Oh good; nothing to worry about now!”
I guess it’s better to be young and ignorant than old and ignorant, but failure is failure where it stands.
Read More
The fact was that Jimmy Carter, from the time he was in his ’20s, was a budding scientist and nuclear engineer, better positioned to understand the expanding crisis that spring in Pennsylvania than any president before or since. In all of the fresh testimonials to his intellect and compassion, the story of his selflessness and courage in just such a nuclear emergency seemed little more than a footnote.
It happened at a place called Deep River, Ontario, 100 miles west by northwest of Ottawa, not too long after Carter had graduated in the top 10% of his class from the Naval Academy. His training in nuclear engineering relating to the development of the Navy’s first nuclear submarines made him a logical part of the American support group that assisted Canadian authorities after the world’s first nuclear reactor accident.
Carter led a 12-man team that used a simulated reactor to practice dismantling the real thing, which, in 1952, likely had none of the safety standards for radioactive waste removal that were common even at Three Mile Island, much less today.
After weeks of practice, he was among those lowered into the damaged reactor itself for a period not to exceed 90 seconds of contamination exposure. Carter’s mission was to unscrew a single bolt. He was extracted in 89 seconds, and in his 1975 autobiography, “Why Not the Best?”, he recalled that his urine tested positive for radiation for the next six months.
The president
It was partly from this experience that Carter would, as the 39th president, establish by executive order the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which consolidated the potential confusion of having up to 100 or more federal bureaus and departments involved in disaster response.
“Rarely has an American president had the science and technological prowess that helps to constructively contribute to the management of emergencies,” wrote Jack Rozdilski, associate professor of Disaster and Emergency Management at York University, on TheConversation.com last week.
“The loss of President Carter gives us the opportunity to reflect upon a different era of American presidential politics: A time when the White House was not hostile to science and the American electorate valued having a leader educated in the sciences and engineering.”
The story of nuclear engineer Jimmy Carter pretty much ended in 1953, when his father died from cancer and Carter and his wife Rosalyn returned to Plains to run the family peanut business. His intent had been to work on a nuclear submarine, preferably the still unconstructed Seawolf, but instead he became President of the United States and the winner of the Nobel Peace Prize “for his decades of untiring effort to find peaceful solutions to international conflicts, to advance democracy and human rights, and to promote economic and social development.”
So yeah, things worked out.
The best of us
Some may find these weeks of Carter tributes wearying, but the fact remains and will endure that this unassuming man who taught Sunday School well into his ‘90s was the best of us, and no amount of looming historical whitewash will alter that.
Nor can it ever change what he thought of us, which was only that he desired a nation that is “once again . . . as good and honest and decent and truthful and competent and compassionate and filled with love as are the American people.”
Whether we deserved as much, much less deserved him, is a question for the ages.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Tales of love and disaster for Jan. 6.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.