When a 16-year-old Shawn Flaherty answered the home phone one day in 1977, he had no reason to expect anything unusual.

But as soon as he heard the distinct southern drawl and “slow, deliberate” tone on the other end of the line, he knew this was no ordinary call.

“I thought, ‘Oh, man, I’m talking to the president,’” Mr. Flaherty told the Post-Gazette this week. “And I said, ‘Dad, it’s the president! I’m talking to the president!’”

It was, in fact, then-President Jimmy Carter, calling to inform his father, then-Pittsburgh Mayor Pete Flaherty, that he was being selected as the nation’s next deputy attorney general.

Advertise with us

“Dad hung up the phone and said, ‘Well, we’re going to Washington,’” Mr. Flaherty said. “My mom looked at him like, ‘Are you kidding? We didn’t talk about this at all.’ It was kind of funny.”

It’s one of the fond memories that Mr. Flaherty reflected on this week as he watched funeral observances honoring Carter, who passed away in December at the age of 100.

The commemorations began last week in rural Georgia, Carter’s home state, and concluded Thursday with an official state funeral at the Washington National Cathedral, where President Joe Biden delivered the eulogy.

As the nation mourns the loss of the longest-lived president, Pittsburghers reflected on their personal connections to the “devoted public servant.”

For Mr. Flaherty, he remembers the down-to-earth man his family came to know before he reached the White House.

Advertise with us

“Dad liked Jimmy Carter a lot and thought he had a tremendous amount of character,” Mr. Flaherty said.

Pete Flaherty, who died in 2005, played a pivotal role in Carter’s ascent to presidency. As the first northeastern mayor to endorse him, he traveled all over Pennsylvania, from Beaver to Butler to Philadelphia, rallying support for Carter.

“Then, lo and behold, Jimmy Carter won Pennsylvania big,” Mr. Flaherty said.

The two men had quickly bonded over their military service, which often sparked friendly debates.

“I remember them having that conversation, ‘The Navy is better,’ ‘No, the Air Force is better,’” Mr. Flaherty said. “He was impressed with my dad’s record in the Air Force.”

Advertise with us

They also connected over their farming backgrounds. The Flahertys owned a farm in Somerset County, which the Carter family visited. The president’s identity always remained deeply tied to his humble beginnings as a southern peanut farmer, Mr. Flaherty said.

“He was not pretentious,” Mr. Flaherty said. “He wasn’t around telling everybody, ‘I’m president, I’m the next best thing.’ He was just, ‘I’m Jimmy Carter from Plains, Georgia.’ I think he lived the rest of his life like that.”

Robert J. Cindrich, appointed U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania during Carter’s administration, shared a similar admiration. The former judge was struck by Carter’s approachability during their meeting at the White House, especially considering his initial hesitation to accept the role.

“He’s the president, and who am I, just a young lawyer from Pittsburgh,” Mr. Cindrich said. “But he treated everyone that way. It was very comforting to be in his company.”

Carter’s presidency came during a pivotal moment in American history. Entering office in the aftermath of the Watergate scandal, he pledged to restore public trust in the government, and a key part of that effort was establishing independence within the justice department, Mr. Cindrich said.

Advertise with us

“It was one of the post-Watergate reforms we hoped would prevent another situation like the one with President Nixon,” Mr. Cindrich said. “I saw him as a real idealist.”

Although Mr. Cindrich met the president only once, he later uncovered a surprising connection between them: a shared love of fly fishing. The discovery came during a fishing trip, a favorite past time of Carter’s post-presidency.

Mr. Cindrich wishes he’d had the opportunity to know Carter better outside of politics.

“But I was privileged to meet him, I was privileged to be a part of this administration,” he said. “Detractors can have complaints about his presidency, but not on the basis of any dishonesty or shaky tactics because he was a good man.”

Peter Kalis, former chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates LLP, met Carter on a flight from Los Angeles to San Francisco about 25 years ago, when the former president left his seat in coach and walked the aisle of the plane to greet each passenger.

Advertise with us

He told the Post-Gazette the ascension of a devout Christian peanut farmer from rural Georgia to the highest office in the land restored his faith in the country.

Jeff Harbin never met Carter in person, but he had a close encounter. As a police officer in Carnegie, Mr. Harbin responded to what he thought was a routine call about suspicious activity one Sunday afternoon in 1979. He knocked on the caller’s door.

“Something’s going on here, kid,” the man told Mr. Harbin. “G-men all around.”

At first, Mr. Harbin saw nothing unusual in the quiet neighborhood, until a man in a suit approached and identified himself as a Secret Service agent. Moments later, a convoy of six to seven cars and limousines passed by.

“I knew it was somebody pretty important for that type of activity to be happening,” Mr. Harbin said. “I didn't really know what was going on.”

Advertise with us

It turned out, as he found out from the local news, that Carter was in town to talk to local families about the nation’s energy crisis.

Back then, it wasn’t standard protocol to notify local police about such visits. “Obviously that’s changed now,” he said.

It’s a story Mr. Harbin has recounted countless times over the years – a small yet memorable connection to the president, who he especially admires for his lifelong humanitarian work.

“He served this country well, both as president and in the other things he did afterwards,” said Mr. Harbin, who went on to become police chief in Carnegie and has since retired. “He lived a long and fruitful life, and I think that’s what he’ll be remembered for. He was president at a tough time.”

It’s true that Carter’s legacy was complex, even for Pittsburghers. Mr. Flaherty recalled his father’s frustration with Carter’s reliance on a tight-knit group of advisors dubbed the “Georgia Mafia.”

Advertise with us

The relationship grew strained, influencing his decision to step down and pursue other political ambitions, including runs for governor and senate. Though Mr. Flaherty said his family never lost respect for Carter’s leadership.

From his visits to local steel towns to address the energy shortage’s impact on the economy to his famous stop at Pittsburgh’s Original Oyster House to try a fish sandwich with his dad, Mr. Flaherty believes the region maintains a special connection with the former president.

“Jimmy Carter had nothing but fond things to say about Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania,” he said. “I know that.”