One often overlooked aspect of Jimmy Carter’s foreign policy was his tough-as-nails-approach in dealing with two racist African states: South Africa and Southern Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe).
He had other foreign policy successes that are better known. Notably, he followed Richard Nixon’s opening to China by formally recognizing the nation in 1979.
He also pushed through Congress, at considerable political cost, the treaty that provided for the peaceful transfer of the Panama Canal, and settled what had been a festering point of conflict not only with Panama but with much of Latin America. The 1977 Torrijos-Carter Treaties led to the transfer of the Panama Canal Zone back to Panama on Dec. 31, 1999.
Most famously, Carter negotiated a truce between Israel and Egypt known as the Camp David accords in 1978. Working with Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin, Carter created a milestone peace treaty, under which Egypt recognized Israel’s right to exist and ended the decades long, sometimes violent, dispute between the two states. That ultimately earned him a Nobel Peace Prize.
Carter in Africa
Jimmy Carter was the first sitting American president to visit sub-Saharan Africa, landing in Nigeria in April 1978. At the time, the continent was caught in an East versus West tug-of-war.
Some African leaders were growing sympathetic to the Soviet Union’s ideology, while many others saw the country as a way to escape America’s influence and control, as America tried to take the place of their former colonial rulers.
Read More
They saw a surge in support from the Soviets for their independence movements and grew wary of Western interests. They did not see America as a beacon of human rights.
As Carter wrote in “A Full Life,” his autobiography written at age 90, “One of our major goals was to help institute majority rule in southern Africa and to strengthen the commitment to human rights throughout that continent.”
He appointed Andrew Young, who’d been a trusted aid of Martin Luther King, Jr., as his ambassador to the United Nations. He sent him to Africa, “to find out what the leaders wanted or needed from the United States, and to see what could be done to encourage democracy and human rights.”
Young reported that America should “put heavy pressure” on the South African and Southern Rhodesian regimes. Carter and his administration did.
In South Africa, the world was confronting a system of white supremacy that was among the cruelest authoritarian states ever designed, known officially as apartheid (“separateness”). South Africans who were white — roughly 10% of the population — were born into a society where they benefited handsomely from an economic privilege that resembled Europe for them.
Non-white South Africans, however, (the remaining 90% of the population) were completely segregated, deemed aliens in their own country and required to carry passes that resembled passports to travel to and from their homes — many of which lacked basic resources like electricity and running water.
Public protests against this form of government were met harshly, often with prison and even with death sentences.
Immoral regimes
Until Carter, American presidents had not condemned apartheid, nor Southern Rhodesia’s version. Previous administrations looked away, because the two nations stood (they claimed) against the communist surges in Africa.
Carter did not hesitate to tell the both governments that their way was immoral, and to press for sanctions against them. He urged international bodies to restrict arms sales to the country, for example. He spent political capital that allies wanted him to spend on domestic politics.
Among other actions, Carter pushed Congress to overturn the Byrd Amendment, which had let America ignore the U.N. sanctions and import critical materials such as chrome and nickel from that country.
In his 1997 memoir, former Southern Rhodesian leader Ian Smith, who vehemently opposed Black rule, complained that the Carter administration had a “negative attitude” toward his country. Carter was adamant that any successful, forward political motion in Southern Rhodesia would require that opposition leaders be included on the ballots.
He was right. His continual pressure helped Southern Rhodesia transition into an independent Zimbabwe, allowing the international community to lift its sanctions against the formerly rogue state.
Historian Nancy Mitchell notes in her book “Jimmy Carter in Africa” that in Southern Rhodesia “Carter succeeded in narrowing the gap between US rhetoric about equal justice for all and its actions abroad.” The U.S. was asked to build the first foreign embassy in the newly independent Zimbabwe.
Carter did a lot to undermine both regimes. It could be argued that he helped the U.S. gain support among other African leaders who saw his commitments to majority rule.
In action and words
American politicians before Carter had tended to honor human rights in words but not in effective action. They always had reasons for supporting oppressive regimes: the communist threat and America’s need for the nations’ natural resources, for example.
Carter made them central to his foreign policy. His care for human rights stems from his upbringing in a heavily segregated Georgia — and his own participation in it, which he regretted. He saw the harm that policies of division and the withholding of human rights caused.
Maybe, just maybe, Americans could push our future leaders to follow his example, and to broadcast a strong message of hope and dignity around the world on behalf of the United States.
Edward Banchs is a freelance writer, author and independent scholar based in Pittsburgh. His latest book is “Scream for Me, Africa!: Heavy Metal Identities in Post-Colonial Africa.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.