As I write, former president Jimmy Carter is in hospice care and close to death at 98. He left office 43 years ago and spent his retirement doing good. I mean genuine good, not for-the-camera good, though he did that as well.
Six years after he became a political civilian, the Carter Center took the lead in working to eradicate Guinea Worm, a horrible parasite that afflicts millions in Africa. It was a work that would change millions of people’s lives, but not one that would quickly produce press release results or make people in America feel good about Jimmy Carter.
He wasn’t a political saint, though. As the historian Kai Bird put it, he was “a ruthless politician” with “raging political ambitions.” In his run for governor of George in 1970, he ran as a populist representing white and Black voters. But “he was perfectly willing to send deft dog whistles of support to rural poor whites who were abandoning public schools for all-white private ‘academies.’”
Then on his first day as governor, having gotten the racist vote, he declared. “The time for racial discrimination in Georgia is over.” That’s the line people remember. Effective, but ruthless.
But still, Jimmy Carter was (for a politician) an unusually complex and thoughtful man. We know that partly because during the 1976 campaign he let himself by interviewed for Playboy magazine. And by one of the most adept leftist journalists, Rolling Stone’s Robert Scheer, for hours and hours, in meetings over months, often when he was tired or dashing between campaign events.
It was maybe the most revealing, self-disclosive statement by a presidential candidate ever. We’ve certainly never gotten anything like it since, and never will, given how tightly candidates and their handlers control their image. You only risk disaster, being as open as Carter was.
Read More
Why risk it? You can win even the presidency by avoiding the press and campaigning from your basement.
The most striking part of the interview to me is the way Scheer kept trying to force Carter into a standard political box, and Carter keeps refusing. Instead, he articulates an idea of political tolerance and pluralism we need today.
Scheer’s second question suggested Carter had “several faces” and “that you try to be all things to all people.” Later in the interview, he says“People find it hard to get a handle on you.”
Carter answers, with what I think is annoyance: “On human rights, civil rights, environmental quality, I consider myself to be very liberal. On the management of government, on openness of government, on strengthening individual liberties and local levels of government, I consider myself a conservative. And I don't see that the two attitudes are incompatible.”
Scheer seems to think he can’t really be a liberal. I’m not sure what else the poor man could do to prove it.
He’d already praised his party’s platform as “a very progressive, very liberal, very socially motivated platform.” He promised to reform taxes and welfare in a progressive way, create a national health program, and insist on equal rights for Black people and women, the mid-70s’ progressive causes. He repeatedly insists on a moral foreign policy, one that advances human rights and didn’t require lying to the American people and invading or subverting other nations.
Later, getting at the question in a different way, Scheer asked Carter about his friendship with Hunter Thompson, the “gonzo” journalist with a prodigious appetite for illegal substances and an anarchistic lifestyle. It’s “confusing,” he says. Carter seems to have been insulted, and it was an insulting question.
“Well, in the first place, I'm a human being,” Carter responded. “I'm not a packaged article that you can put in a little box and say, ‘Here's a Southern Baptist, an ignorant Georgia peanut farmer who doesn't have the right to enjoy music, who has no flexibility in his mind, who can't understand the sensitivities of an interpersonal relationship. He's gotta be predictable. He's gotta be for Calley and for the war. He's gotta be a liar. He's gotta be a racist.’" (Lt. William Calley was the soldier most responsible for the My Lai massacre in Vietnam. Carter had been unfairly accused of supporting him.)
Part of the self-disclosure, the most famous part, was Carter’s unashamed assertion of his religious beliefs. His was not the politician’s typical vague civil religion that invoked God, about whom little specific is said except that he approves of America and loves the country very much, probably more than the others — and is, depending on the politician’s party, either a Divine Democrat or a Divine Republican. This was his opponent Ronald Reagan’s religion, at least as he expressed it in public.
Carter talked about being a Southern Baptist, his prayer life, his trust in the Bible, and defended the Christian moral teaching about sex. But he insisted that the rules applied first to Christians, who were not better than anyone else and couldn’t judge anyone else.
Trying to explain this, he earned much public derision for saying that he’d lusted after other women in his heart. He meant an act today we condemn as objectification. He was more morally sensitive than the people who laughed at him then.
He tried, and this is why his example remains important, to figure out what role his moral beliefs had in a society that didn’t completely share them. What do we decide when people disagree? How do we decide? How does a president know what to do?
“Liberalization of some of the laws has been good,” he says at one point. “You can't legislate morality. We tried to outlaw consumption of alcoholic beverages. We found that violation of the law led to bigger crimes and bred disrespect for the law.”
It’s the perennial problem of politics, and an increasingly pressing one for Americans, because everyone has absolutes and those absolutes conflict with others’ absolutes. Simply accepting polarization and continual political warfare isn’t an answer. Jimmy Carter was the last major American politician to try seriously to find an answer.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Pope Francis understands Christianity better than Jordan Peterson.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.