We’re better than 24 hours deep in a news cycle that’s turned into the Tucker Carlson Post-Game Show, about the man John Oliver once called a performatively outraged wedge salad, so here’s your occasional reminder to beware: Carlson only ever fails upward.

Fired by Fox News on Monday for any number of plausible reasons not including, obviously, lying on the air and propagating malignant conspiracy theories, Carlson executed the nearly impossible media stunt of getting banished from both ends of the cable news ideological forest. He’d previously been canned by MSNBC.

“When you get fired in TV, you know, especially when you’re running a show with your name on it,” Carlson told an interviewer from the Atlantic a few years ago, “it’s impossible to evade responsibility for it.”

Really.

Advertise with us

I’ll try to keep that in mind when Carlson turns up as Trump’s 2024 campaign manager. Who has more demonstrable experience synthesizing Trump’s psychotic world view than Tucker?

He’s been at it for at least seven years, and don’t forget, Tucker is not just the former Buffoonatic-in-Chief’s biggest megaphone, he’s a Trump-whisperer with historical bonafides. When Trump was reluctant, by which I mean petrified, to take COVID seriously in March of 2020, it was Carlson who drove from his Florida Gulf Coast mansion across the state to persuade the President of the United States that, you know, this could be big.

Without that conversation, there might never have been an Operation Warp Speed, which accelerated a vaccine that Fox kept telling its viewers not to take. As I’ve said before in this space, Carlson is a man who can’t even believe himself.

The last truly honest thing Tucker did on television was a brief turn on Dancing With The Stars (Season 3). He was hysterical. Eliminated in the first round, he was trampled by the likes of Jerry Springer.

But again, it’s probably less important to wonder why Tucker woke up Tuesday to find himself at liberty than to fret over this story’s next development. Among them, in ways that feel way too logical, Carlson teams with Trump for 2024, either as campaign manager or on the ticket, Fox installs Trump in Tucker’s prime time slot, and most logical of all, Tucker himself seeks the Republican presidential nomination for which, admit it, he’s dead solid perfect: white, privileged, track record of failing upward, compulsive liar, darling of white supremacists — he’s got it all.

Advertise with us

He’s Trump without Trump, DeSantis without the Mouse wars, he’s got everything the MAGA base adores, and the only way he could be more not-Biden is if he were Black. Republicans and many Democrats consider octogenarianism a Biden albatross. Carlson is 53, but still looks like his mom just dressed him for picture day.

The other possibility, now backed by multiple news reports, is that Carlson ends up working for Russian state TV, to which my reaction is probably the same as yours — no, he just left that job.

While we wait for that other shoe to drop and hope it’s not a boot to the head, let’s try to pretend that Carlson got fired this week because Fox has finally been made to understand that it can’t lie with impunity and get away with it.

Let’s try to pretend that Fox finally took the measure of Carlson and decided it wouldn’t live with it anymore. Wouldn’t live with someone who trashed Trump in internal communications (“I hate him passionately... We are very, very close to being able to ignore Trump most nights. I truly can’t wait.”), then had Trump for a show-length sit-down where the former president blathered out his favorite grievances.

Wouldn’t live with the reality that Carlson promoted election lies right up to and through the Jan. 6 insurrection, then tried to explain it away as some kind of 8th-grade picnic/costume party that might have gotten a little spirited. Wouldn’t live with Carlson’s bleatings about the superiority of Western Civilization while perpetually channeling the gospel of old world autocrats from Russia to Hungary to Florida.

Advertise with us

The problem is, that’s not how the 400-pound gorillas get fired from Fox. They get fired the old-fashioned Bill O’Reilly way, through serial sexual harassment complaints that threaten the company’s bottom line. That’s how Tucker got the 8 o’clock show in the first place. See also Roger Ailes, who ran the whole “news” operation until the Murdochs ran him off for the same transgressions.

Now comes word that Tucker’s former producer, Abby Grossberg, has filed a lawsuit claiming Fox lawyers pressured her to give false testimony in the Dominion case Fox settled last week for $787 million to avoid having its superstar commentators put on the stand. Grossberg further claims that when she left the Maria Bartiromo show to work for Tucker, as per the filing, “she had merely traded in one overtly misogynistic work environment for an even crueler one — this time, one where unprofessionalism reigned supreme, and the staff’s distaste and disdain for women infiltrated almost every workday decision.”

And that, in combination with prospective shareholder suits over Murdoch mismanagement, is probably what was at work in the Carlson dismissal.

It wasn’t anything he said. You can say anything on Fox News. It doesn’t even have to be true. You can say so many untrue things that it threatens our democracy and even ends the singular American miracle called the peaceful transfer of power. That’s all OK.

But jeopardize the Murdoch portfolio, well, there’s the door.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.