On April 25, the network Newsmax hosted a fascinating and revealing conversation about Tucker Carlson with Tony Perkins, president of one of America’s leading Christian conservative organizations, the Family Research Council.

Perkins scorned Fox News’ decision to fire Carlson, and — incredibly — also attacked Fox’s decision to fire Bill O’Reilly. He deemed these terminations — along with the earlier departures of Glenn Beck and Megyn Kelly — evidence that Fox was turning its back on its conservative viewers, including its Christian conservative viewers.

What was missing from the conversation? Any mention of the profound moral failings that cost O’Reilly his job, including at least six settlements — five for sexual harassment and one for verbal abuse — totaling approximately $45 million. Or any mention of Carlson’s own serious problems, including his serial dishonesty, his vile racism and his gross personal insult directed against a senior Fox executive. It’s a curious position for a Christian to take.

Similarly curious is the belief of other Christians that Carlson was a “casualty of war” with the left, and that his firing was a serious setback for Christian Republicans. To the popular evangelical “prophet” Lance Wallnau, Carlson was a “secular prophet,” somebody “used by God, more powerful than a lot of preachers.”

Advertise with us

Other prominent Christian members of the American right applauded Carlson’s “courage.” After The New York Times reported that Carlson condemned a group of Trump supporters for not fighting like “white men” after “jumping” an antifa member, some declared that Carlson did “nothing wrong.” Rod Dreher, editor-at-large at The American Conservative, and an Eastern Orthodox Christian, said, “I hope Tucker Carlson runs for president,” and a “Tucker-DeSantis ticket would be the Generation X Saves The World team.”

Within conservative circles it has always been surprisingly difficult to tie a decline in Christian political virtue to the rise of Donald Trump. Didn’t Christians used to place a premium on the importance of character in politicians, especially during Bill Clinton’s scandals?

What seems obvious from a distance was less obvious up close. In countless personal conversations with Christians who are staunch Republicans, I heard some variation on the same plaintive question, “What do you want us to do? Hand an election to Hillary Clinton? Or to Joe Biden?”

For Democratic readers, that’s an easy choice. There’s no sacrifice in voting for Clinton or for Biden. But let’s turn the question around — under what circumstances would you actually vote for your polar political opposite? How corrupt would a Democratic politician have to be to keep you home, make you vote third party or perhaps even cast a vote for a Republican who wants to ban most abortions and nominate Federalist Society lawyers to judgeships?

Honestly exploring that question can perhaps help you sympathize with Republican Trump voters. When character conflicts with policy, voting choices can be hard.

Advertise with us

But the Carlson question is different, and in some ways his loyal Christian support is even more troubling. What are the “lesser of two evils” or the “binary choice” arguments for sitting down and devoting an hour of your life, each night, to a cruel, dishonest man, much less hailing him as a “secular prophet?” The more the Christian right latches on to cruel men, the more difficult it becomes to argue that the cruelty is a bug, not a feature.

The great tragedy is that a moment of dangerous national polarization is exactly when a truly Christian message that combines the pursuit of justice with kindness and humility would be a balm to the national soul. A time of extraordinary social isolation, where people report less companionship, less time with friends, and less time with family, is exactly the time when a healthy church community can be a beacon of inclusion and hope.

But not when the right-wing pursuit of its version of justice overwhelms its commitment to kindness, much less any shred of humility. This is how the religious right becomes post-Christian. Its “secular prophets” become even more influential than its Christian leaders, and it actively discards clear biblical commands for what it perceives to be the greater good.

That’s not Christianity. It’s a primitive form of consequentialism, the idea that the morality of an action is to be judged solely by its consequences. Many Christians fear that kindness doesn’t “work,” so they discard it. This is how even decency itself becomes a “secondary value.” Aggression, not virtue, becomes the touchstone of political engagement, and anything other than aggression is seen as a sign of weakness.

I’ll end with a point of agreement with Lance Wallnau. I do agree that Carlson was more powerful in Christian politics than “a lot of preachers.” I’ll go even further. Is there a single public figure not named Donald Trump who had more real-world influence over evangelical political engagement than Carlson?

Advertise with us

But that influence was dark and malign. For the sake of contestable political issues, he abandoned necessary moral virtues, and he taught his followers to do the same. His daily example demonstrated that honesty and grace — indispensable qualities in every sphere of life — have no place in the politics of the new religious right. Christian political engagement must include Christian moral virtue, or it will tear this nation apart.

David French is a columnist for the New York Times. His previous article was “The gun rights culture is destroying the case for gun rights.” This article originally appeared in the New York Times.