Riding the train from Pittsburgh on his way to Baltimore in the mid-1920s, H.L. Mencken described the area east of the city, around Greensburg, as lined with “human habitations so abominable that they would have disgraced a race of alley cats.”
One of America’s major writers and most influential journalists, he’d made his name by taking down nearly everyone, but especially the easy targets, the people his educated and affluent readers would enjoy seeing abused in print. If he were alive today, I think he would be Tucker Carlson, but anti-populist — he despised democracy — and much more creatively abusive.
Mencken insulted Pittsburgh for a column in the Chicago Sunday Times titled “The Black Country.” He described “the unbroken and agonizing ugliness, the sheer revolting monstrousness, of every house in sight.”
He went on and on, ladling out the insults. It was “hideousness without a break” and the towns “the most loathsome towns and villages ever seen by mortal eye.” The houses “show grotesqueries of ugliness that, in retrospect, become almost diabolical. ... One can scarcely imagine human beings bearing life in them.”
As far as I can find, he didn’t have it in for Pittsburgh. The column was the writer’s equivalent of a drive-by shooting. The major biography, Terry Teachout’s “The Skeptic,” tells two stories about his relation with our city.
Teachout writes that Mencken “reveled” in publishing Black writers in his magazine The American Mercury, making Pittsburgh’s George Schuyler a regular contributor. On the other hand, he told the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle that he didn’t like religious Jews and objected to “professional Jews.” He told them to assimilate. “Just try not to be unpleasant and stop thinking that you’re ‘it.’ You live in this country, try to behave as others do.”
He was complicated — Black writers yes, Jews no, for example — and your opinion of him will vary with how much you want to see the people he hit get hit. I admit to enjoying his drubbing of religious frauds and politicians in general. And he writes entertainingly, though for me a little bit goes a long way.
To be fair to him, the journalist Walter Lippman, an even bigger figure than he was, praised his concern for “the humblest citizen.” Unfortunately, that meant humble citizens who weren’t in his sights. He wasn’t concerned for the humble citizens of the towns he looked at from the railroad carriage. They were targets, not people.
The article’s still read. Mencken reprinted in two later books of his and it appears in collections of American journalism. Many more people than have read it remember the main phrase, “the libido for the ugly.”
Here’s the most famous passage. “On certain levels of the human race, indeed, there seems to be a positive libido for the ugly. Here is something that the psychologists have so far neglected: the love of ugliness for its own sake, the lust to make the world intolerable. Its habitat is the United States. Out of the melting pot emerges a race which hates beauty as it hates truth.”
The people living in those towns along the track weren’t just poor people who couldn’t afford to build nice houses, like the homes in his posh Baltimore neighborhood. They wanted ugliness. They loved ugliness. They had a deep primal drive to make things ugly.
I think he was simply lying about the churches, which the people sacrificed to build, and built well. (He was not one to let truth get in the way of his swinging prose.) About all the other buildings he may be right, as a purely aesthetic judgment, because poverty demands survival, which does not always leave room for beauty as an east coast elitist would think it.
But those homes and towns Mencken so gleefully insulted were the homes of the poor and struggling. They were the living places of people exploited by their employers, who had to make a life with what they had. (Mencken was the son of a factory owner and had never wanted for money.)
In those ugly homes were many honorable people, probably more than would have been found in Mencken’s circles: devout, loving, neighborly, kind, battling circumstances as best they could, people whose failures were more heroic than his successes. People who shared his sense of beauty but not his income.
Mencken should have seen that. He would have seen that, if he hadn’t been so intent on bad-mouthing the people and the towns to make a point. It he didn’t play them for a laugh.
The lesson one should take from Mencken’s once famous essay is not that the Pittsburghers living in the towns along the railroad tracks had “a libido for the ugly.” The lesson one should take is that Mencken was a jagoff.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Transparency comes with the job, Clarence Thomas.” He thanks Mark Barrett for suggesting the last word.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.