For the past 20 years, the Lower Hill District has been one of the greatest missed redevelopment opportunities in Pittsburgh, and maybe among all mid-sized cities in America. The 28 acres that formerly housed the Civic Arena and surrounding parking lots — but which was originally supposed to be an extensive mid-century “cultural acropolis” — sits immediately adjacent to the urban core, and offers the unique chance to connect that core to what once was and must become again one of the country’s greatest centers of Black life and culture.
Today, for the first time since early days after the Civic Arena’s closure and demolition, we are optimistic for the future of this site. It is the fulcrum of Pittsburgh.
After two decades, the costs of delay are apparent — the emptiness is an ongoing reminder of the scar left by “urban renewal” 70 years ago — and so there appears to be momentum toward achieving a workable solution. Most important of all, the land itself is finally in more capable hands, after the Penguins hockey club relinquished its development rights last October.
The development of this land must take into account the generational sins of displacement, but it cannot completely atone for them. That is to ask too much of any real estate development, and of real estate developers. But what is built here, and those who build it, can lay a foundation so that another 70 years from now, people from the Hill and from the rest of Pittsburgh can look back and say that this was the moment a better future was made possible.
Pittsburgh needs this void to be filled. The Hill District, in particular, needs this void to be filled. There is no more time to waste.
There and back again
The history of the Lower Hill District is well-known, but bears a brief review.
These ridges between the rivers overlooking the Golden Triangle attracted tens of thousands of immigrants from overseas and migrants from the American South in the first decades of the 20th century. From the 1920s into the 1950s, this was one of the great centers of Black music and culture in America, but was also a successful example of huge ethnic diversity in a dense city neighborhood.
But by the mid-50s, the neighborhood was showing its age. Mayor David L. Lawrence spearheaded the kind of plan that was in vogue in American cities at the time: raze the “slums” and move the residents to high rises, while replacing the old neighborhood with major amenities. Despite a grander vision, only the Civic Arena was every built.
Thus cut off from the beating heart of the city, the rest of the Hill District — now almost entirely Black — withered over the decades.
Fast forward to the mid-2000s, when the demise of the arena offered a chance to make amends. After years of jockeying among politicians and team owners and casino operators, a final deal was struck: To ensure the team stayed put, the Penguins would get a new facility and development rights to the 28-acre site of the old arena.
Yet 20 years on, the results have been meager: the FNB Financial Center tower and the Citizens Live at the Wylie music venue. About 75% of the original site is essentially untouched.
A turning point
There is blame to go around for the two-decade delay. First, the hockey team was not equipped to perform complex real estate development. Then, some of the requirements placed on their efforts by community groups — especially minority business requirements in a city that unfortunately lacks a robust minority business ecosystem, in particular for development and construction — made their job even harder.
But litigating this matter doesn’t move the ball forward, which is now the task at hand. The reversion of the land to the Sports and Exhibition Authority (SEA) and the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) is cause for hope.
In particular, we are glad to see three common-sense adjustments: First, the public authorities are seeking to engage a variety of developers to work on parts of the site, instead of a single developer to execute a massive master plan. While this approach might sacrifice some continuity among site projects, it offers a major advantage in terms of getting shovels in the ground.
Second, the URA has already engaged a trusted, local developer of affordable housing to get the ball rolling. Trek Development is already active and respected in the Hill District, where it is working on 800 units of affordable housing for those displaced from the bedraggled Bedford Dwellings, which is itself getting razed and replaced. In fact, the federal grants for these projects can be applied to the Lower Hill.
Reason for hope
Third, there appears to be an implicit (or perhaps explicit) bargain between the URA and Hill District community groups to loosen (beyond the Trek-built 50% affordable complex) affordability expectations, while the percent of property tax revenues from new development that will be sequestered for use in the Hill over the next decade will increase from 50% to 100%. This will make the site more attractive to developers while generating millions in revenue for affordable housing and other infrastructure and amenities throughout the Hill.
We’d add that there should be a public-facing dashboard that accounts for these revenues, and what they’re spent on, to ensure public confidence that everyone is living up to their side of the bargain.
For two decades, the asphalt plains of the Lower Hill have been a standing rebuke to the city’s leadership at all levels, from sports teams to public officials. But with new eyes on the problem and new incentives in play — above all the need to get something done to resolve this pathetic eyesore — there is, finally, good reason to be optimistic for the Lower Hill.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.