The deferment of maintenance and rehabilitation of Allegheny County’s public transit infrastructure, as announced by Pittsburgh Regional Transit this week, is simply not sustainable. The state of Pennsylvania must commit to a transit funding solution, or Pittsburgh will eventually be faced not just with service cuts, but the loss of essential legacy infrastructure that simply can’t be maintained.
The Post-Gazette’s Ed Blazina reported this week that after being forced to move over $100 million from capital projects to its everyday operating budget — a result of a Harrisburg stalemate over funding — the transit agency will spend $85 million on major rehabilitations and upgrades over the next two years. That’s less than it had hoped to spend, and much, much less than it needs to spend.
The most alarming data point: PRT’s chief development officer Amy Silbermann says the agency has $2 billion in projects backed up, which are simply needed to maintain existing infrastructure and facilities in reasonably good condition. But only 10% of these projects are currently funded.
Examples of projects deferred beyond 2027 include the purchase of new, more efficient and cheaper-to-run buses, work at several stations where the rider experience has declined, and (most alarmingly) “preventative maintenance” on bridges throughout the system. In every one of these cases, especially preventative maintenance, the inability to spend now will make the work much more expensive in the long run.
A perfect example: When PRT first proposed to perform a needed overhaul of the Panhandle Bridge, which carries the light rail system over the Monongahela River, it was supposed to cost $55 million. The work, which is supposed to begin in 2027, is now budgeted for $95 million.
There is only one possible conclusion: Barring radical change, within just a few more years the city’s legacy transit infrastructure — especially the light rail line to the South Hills, along with the East, South and West Busways — will become impossible to justify. The cuts won’t just be to the number of buses and trains; they’ll be to the bridges and tunnels and tracks and pavement themselves.
The solution begins with Harrisburg settling on a permanent transit funding solution, as we have insisted many times. But PRT must also recognize the seriousness of the crisis and take action of its own, which has to include trimming its overhead without service cuts. While much of the agency’s costs are fixed, such as significant pension obligations, PRT does have an unusually high cost per rider — a measure of the overall efficiency of its operations.
We’d like to see visible efforts from PRT to tamp down these costs. While Harrisburg’s help is needed, it’s unlikely any compromise will solve PRT’s problems forever. It also needs to help itself.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.