This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city, and southwestern Pennsylvania more generally, during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.

Allegheny County has, objectively, the worst government structures in America. This isn’t a statement about quality of leadership or party politics. It’s a statement about mathematics and geography.

With 130 municipalities, this is the most governmentally fragmented county in America. Meanwhile the county of about 1.2 million people is anchored by a city of only 300,000 — a tax- and population-base too small to effectively serve an urban center upon which the economic health of the rest of the region depends.

This is the result of more than two centuries of periods of development and decline, of shifts of people and production, of decisions based on politics and prejudice. No one would design Allegheny County’s borders and government structures this way today.

Advertise with us

Indeed, the inefficiencies and missed opportunities caused by these structures, from unnecessarily high local taxes to the inability to land large economic development projects, are some of the biggest factors holding Pittsburgh back. But fixing it is among the most difficult tasks in all of politics.

In the coming weeks and months, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board will explore possible solutions, or at least abatements, for the problem of governmental fragmentation. Today’s option is merging the City of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County.

Missed opportunity

One century ago, Pennsylvania studied whether Pittsburgh would be better served by a consolidated city-county government. “This entity would have retained the nominal structure of most municipalities within the County while shifting the responsibility for most public services to what would have been a merged city and county government,” according to a 2008 report on city-county government.

In 1929, 68% of Allegheny County voters approved of the plan. But the vote was voided because of a “printer’s error” in the wording of the referendum. The question has never been put to a vote since.

But the city-county merger should have happened. And judging by the success of regions that have gone through the process more recently, Pittsburgh would have been a more prosperous place today had it happened.

Advertise with us

Louisville, for instance, merged with Jefferson County in 2003, and over the next five years was “first nationally in small business growth…first in the Southeast for manufacturing job growth…and one of the nation's 50 hottest cities for expansion.” A RAND study found that among “economic development officials…opinions about the effects of consolidation on economic development ranged from mildly positive to downright euphoric.”

Reducing redundancy

The framework we are presenting today is essentially that which emerged from the 2008 Citizens Advisory Committee on the Efficiency and Effectiveness of City-County Government (say that five times fast) in April 2008. Needless to say, despite an all-star panel chaired by then-University of Pittsburgh Chancellor Mark Nordenberg, nothing came of the report.

But it remains the most serious and recent attempt to figure what a city-county merger could actually look like, so it will be our starting point.

The most important point to make, immediately, is that the merger envisioned by (what we will call) the Nordenberg Report does not eliminate the 130 municipalities. Mt. Lebanon, Sewickley, Kennedy and Wilmerding would remain independently incorporated. A city-county merger is not the same as the city’s annexation of the rest of the county, which under current state law would require a majority vote from every single annexed community.

Rather, it would involve folding Pittsburgh’s powers and bureaucracy into Allegheny County’s, eliminating redundancies and reducing the layers of regulation to which businesses and individuals are subject. Developers of real estate within city limits, for instance, would only have to work with the joint city-county government, rather than with the distinct leaders and cultures of two governments. And everyday taxpayers would only have one set of local government levies to pay.

Advertise with us

Suburban independence

But what about the other 129 municipalities? The report — in line with city-county mergers elsewhere — envisions that the merged government would include two “districts”: The Urban Services District (USD) and the General Services District (GSD). The former, encompassing the current City of Pittsburgh, would fulfill the distinct responsibilities of a government of a large and densely populated community, in the same way that state law currently accords more powers to cities than to boroughs or townships.

The latter would provide services to the remaining 900,000 people of the county, suited to its generally more dispersed population and development patterns. Some of these services would replace those currently being provided by the municipalities.

For instance, it is easy to imagine the city-county GSD handling refuse collection around the county, allowing for a single, less expensive, more efficient waste removal system rather than over 100 separate ones. The same goes for public works, including snow removal, which would be much more efficient if plows and salt-spreaders didn’t have to turn around once they reach the municipal border.

As for what municipalities would retain, these would be matters of local governance that work best, or only make sense, under local control. For instance, they would retain significant authority over zoning and land use, which define the character and culture of communities, as well as services like parks and recreation, with each community able to design and fund facilities and programs suitable to their needs.

The biggest question is whether public safety — specifically policing — would be retained or handed over to the GSD. We have previously argued for a middle path: regionalization of police departments, balancing the importance of local knowledge and community relationships with the cost-effectiveness of sharing resources. This would be compatible with a merged city-county government.

The devil, as always, would be in the details. But the merger envisioned by the Nordenberg Report, which would eliminate redundancies without eliminating municipal independence, offers a promising starting point. And the financial stress of both city and county, combined with youthful elected leadership, offers a promising opportunity to reopen this essential conversation.