This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city, and southwestern Pennsylvania more generally, during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.

Every Pittsburgher knows that you take first-time visitors to Grandview Avenue on Mt. Washington. Yet many of those newcomers end up asking the same question: Why isn’t there more stuff up here?

It’s one of the great mysteries of Pittsburgh that the precipice of one of the great urban vistas of the world is populated largely by low-rise residences — including many single-family homes — a school, a library and a good deal of vacant land. It’s time for city and regional leaders to develop an ambitious plan to build up Mt. Washington.

Specifically, the city should announce, in collaboration with private developers, an international contest to design a new mixed-use high-rise development on the ridgeline, which would become the highest point in the city. The request for proposals should stipulate that the city seeks an ambitious, iconic structure, meant to define this era of Pittsburgh’s history.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s future, both as a place to live and as a place to visit — as we’ve argued, Pittsburgh has what it takes to become one of America’s must-see metros — depends on leaning what makes it distinctive. And there’s nothing more Pittsburgh than the ridge south of the Monongahela River, which is without a doubt the most dramatic topographical feature at the center of any major U.S. city.

It should have a dramatic skyscraper to match.

Three options

It’s important to stipulate up front: Mt. Washington is more than a hill; it’s a community. Specifically, immediately behind the condos and mansions on Grandview itself, it’s a working-to-middle-class neighborhood, similar to other South Hills city communities. This — the fact that one of the world’s great urban hillsides was built out, and retains its character, as a true workaday neighborhood — is also distinctively Pittsburgh.

One of the main reasons Mt. Washington is not built up like Niagara Falls is the desire to not to damage or destroy this century-old neighborhood. This is honorable. But we believe that more can be done to make Mt. Washington a destination, without seriously harming its character.

There are at least three locations where a significant structure could be added without directly displacing current residents.

Advertise with us

First, on the west end of Grandview between the Trimont and Grandview Towers — officially in the Duquesne Heights neighborhood — is about 600 feet of empty space right on the ridgeline. Unfortunately, the city appears to have approved at least some of this land for the continuation of a lineup of low-rise townhomes.

Second, there’s the abandoned St. Mary of the Mount School, which rises above Grandview Avenue near the intersection with McArdle Roadway. Any big construction here would be surrounded on three sides by single-family homes, posing an obvious challenge to community integration.

Third, there’s the former site of the Edge restaurant, adjacent to the upper station of the Monongahela Incline. This property has been the subject of speculation for decades, including a Ritz-Carlton hotel and a tiered glass skyscraper with residences tumbling down the hillside. Near transportation and the excellent Shiloh Street shopping district, this still the most viable location for large-scale development.

Direct connection

Another barrier to Mt. Washington development is transportation. We think these concerns are in some respects overblown; for instance, Grandview Avenue is already the site of major high-rises like the Trimont and Grandview Pointe (home of the Monterey Bay Fish Grotto restaurant) without chronic traffic issues.

Still, getting to the ridgeline, and then back off of it, can be challenging. In fact, we believe that the success of any truly iconic Mt. Washington development — especially one that will attract visitors who value seamless access to other urban amenities — depends on having a direct link to the Golden Triangle.

Advertise with us

The Monongahela Incline, though iconic in its own right, doesn’t cut it. The slow every-15-minute rides function well as a tourist experience, but not for efficient transportation. It doesn’t help that the walking route from the lower station to the Station Square T station is unclear and unpleasant.

Further, the incline’s chronic and expensive maintenance issues are only getting worse — culminating last month with dozens of riders getting stuck in the vehicles for several hours. It may be time to consider closing it for good.

Doing so would present a unique opportunity to replace the incline with a more functional, more modern homage: the long-discussed gondola. A gondola strung from the ridgeline straight into Downtown Pittsburgh could transport more people with greater efficiency to the heart of the city — while still being an iconic experience that leverages and accentuates Pittsburgh’s unique geography. Like the Mt. Washington skyscraper, it would define the Pittsburgh of the mid-21st century.

A new icon

Mt. Washington is one of Pittsburgh’s coolest and greatest assets. As the city looks to grow and to compete with its peers, civic leaders must ask themselves: Are our assets being put to their fullest and best use?

The truth is the Mt. Washington skyline has been stagnant for decades, even though it represents one of the most dramatic opportunities for urban redevelopment in America. Pittsburgh just needs to realize what it has, and go find the people who can create something beautiful out of it.

We think it’s clear that Mt. Washington can become a tourism and architectural icon without ruining the community that makes it special. A new, ambitious, mixed-use high-rise development would immediately become a symbol of the city that celebrates its heritage while embracing the future.